Software
Houzz Logo Print
benedicthenry

Leafless and brown tree, may be a cypress.

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Hi,

We're really hoping that some of you are able to help us! We have a tree at the front of our house which we really like, but unfortunately the front of it is brown and leafless, which really spoils its appeal. We don't know how long it's been like this for as we've only just moved into the house. If anyone knows the possible causes of this problem and if we can resolve it that would be wonderful. If we can't we'd wondered if it might be possible to plant something to 'fill in the gap' so to speak, but again we're newbies when it comes to trees. The photo's hopefully show the problem clearly.

Thanks All.

Comments (37)

  • 9 years ago

    Am I right in thinking you are in UK? As you can see from the sawn off trunks your tree has been cut back in the past. It will never regreen on the cut side unlike a deciduous tree. It's not really a suitable choice for a small front garden. I'm afraid I would say cut it down completely and start again with a new small tree or shrub.

    B H thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    Take some close-ups of any cones or berries. Unless it is a yew, it will never regreen on the brown side.

    If you are determined to try to keep it, you could plant an arborvitae or yew to conceal the bad side.

    Much as I hate to say it, you would probably be best off cuting it down and replacing it.


    B H thanked edlincoln
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Ellwood Cypress. Bare stems will not refurnish themselves, if it ever closes the gap it will be by growing in from the sides - as it has already started doing.

    A process that will take many years.

    B H thanked Embothrium
  • 9 years ago

    if I am interpreting the photo correctly this tree is planted in a tiny front garden and is already up against the front garden wall, hence the cutting back which has already taken place. There won't be any room for a new tree to cover the bare patch. The black metal object in the right foreground is the front gate, i am assuming.



    B H thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    Floral_uk thank you for your comment. We are indeed in the UK, good guess! As I said in the initial post we're not knowledgable about trees, so your advice is very much appreciated. In your opinion, what's the reason the tree isn't suitable for a small front garden please? Thanks!

    edlincoln thanks also for your response. I'll take some pictures tomorrow of any cones or berries and post them. The idea you suggested of using an arborvitae or yew to hide the damaged area sounds interesting. What would your reservations about doing this be? Thanks again.

    Embothrium many thanks for clarifying the situation. What sad news!

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks floral_uk, you're absolutely right, both in your interpretation of the photo' and that there wouldn't be enough room for a tree to cover the cut back area. It's such a pity as the tree from the rear looks wonderful. I think we'll follow your advise and take it down. Do you have any advice on what to replace it with please, given the location? Once again, thanks for your advice.

  • 9 years ago

    What features would like like a replacement shrub to have?

    B H thanked Embothrium
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Embothrium. We're not quite sure at the moment, but provisionally we're thinking of either a hedge or row of small trees which goes around the edge of the front garden. We'll miss the tree as it meant we could always find our house!

  • 9 years ago

    BH could you give the dimensions of your front garden so that US contributors can understand how very small these spaces are? They also need to know that the tree in the picture is in the angle between your neighbours wall and the front wall and that the pavement runs along the front edge. It's a very restricted spot. That is why it was cut back in the first place it is just too big for the situation and it isnt full size yet. To replace it you are probably looking for a small upright growing shrub. Do you want evergreen? Or a hedge as you suggest.

    On the other hand, if you like the way it looks from the house you could just ignore the other side and leave it.

    B H thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks again floral_uk. We'll measure up and post the dimensions and put some more photo's of the space up too. I like the idea of upright evergreens, but we're very open to suggestions and hoping to learn.

  • 9 years ago

    could you step back and take a pic or two of the whole situation ... descriptions are great.. but pix are supreme ...


    i suspect this is another example of some previous owner.. buying a cute young plant... with no real concept that this conifer.. tree ... had explosive potential.. over the years ... or decades ... trees just dont ever stop growing ....


    removal is probably best ... unless you want to look at that bare tree for 3 to 5 or more years ...


    ken

    B H thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Ken - this is a typical UK front gardenof the type I am assuming the OP has. As you can see there is very little space for any kind of tree other than something very compact or a shrub.

    B H thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    B H: My reservations are as the others have have stated, size. I'm less willing to assume based on the picture, (these photos can be misleading) but unless your yard is bigger then it appears, you wouldn't have room for the arborvitae or yew. The yew would also take a long time to grow.

    B H thanked edlincoln
  • 9 years ago

    Ken I will indeed do this, as from all the other responses we've received we will sadlybe removing the tree. We don't then want to make the same mistake and would like to plant something which looks great, but works in the space we have. Thanks for your interest and advice.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks and understood edlincoln.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    If you are looking to replace it...what do you want out of a tree?

    If you want an evergreen, some kind of yew or holly would take better to pruning to limit it's size. There are beautiful blue juniper, and dwarf versions of many conifers. Cunninghamia lanceolata 'Glauca'. is an unusual option that is blue, looks vaguely cederish, and takes well to pruning...a bit vulnerable to the winter in my area, but might work for you. Too big, but you could prune it.

    Of course if you want a little flowering tree, there are many more options.

    B H thanked edlincoln
  • 9 years ago

    You could have a fastigiate Yew if you are prepared to clip and train. It would be years before it got too big. Or there are slow growing fastigiate forms of other conifers. There are lots of other possibilities. Do a bit of googling and visit some garden centres and see what you come up with.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks so much to all who have responded, it's so helpful to have some experience and knowledge to call upon. We'll of course have a google search as floral_uk suggested and see what we come up with too. I'd really like to plant some small trees that provide us with privacy, but which are also both interesting and beautiful to look at, so that passers-by won't mourn the loss of the cedar too greatly!
    I've added some more photo's of the space we have. I can measure it at the weekend if needed.

    As the photo's show we have soil at the front of the garden on both sides and along the right hand side, but not along the left hand side. We'd certainly consider putting soil there if needed as we'd like to grow trees all around the white wall.

    Front/left hand side of garden:

    Right hand side of garden:

    Front right hand side of garden:

    Front left hand side of garden:

  • 9 years ago

    You will probably want to look at fastigiate shrubs and underplant them with perennials. Here are some suggestions, although I'm not 100% sure that they will work in the UK (I'm sure floral_uk will correct me If they won't):

    'Sky Pencil' Japanese Holly

    'Helmond Pillar' Barberry

    'Fine Line' Buckthorn

    'Degroot's Spire' Arborvitae

    and now for perennials:

    Liriope Muscari

    Liriope Muscari 'Variegata' (the one above and this one will pair nicely)

    Daylily 'Stella'

    Coreopsis 'Nana'

    B H thanked Logan L Johnson
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Privacy etc. = how tall in your mind's eye? Otherwise a good size is 1 1/2 times as tall as a bed is wide at the point a shrub is being planted. So if your beds are 2 ft. deep shrubs 3 ft. tall would look in scale. (For less work and a neater look you might want to replace the existing occupants with evergreen (broad-leaved or coniferous) shrubs, maybe grow little flowery things in separate containers elsewhere on the site - such as near doors or outdoor seating).

    Another point: if you own the property, it might be possible to budget for it and local codes allow it the best way to get some relief from the street and alley would be to have a taller wall.

    Find a plant

    https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/search-Form

    B H thanked Embothrium
  • 9 years ago

    There is no alley. There will be neighbour's gardens both sides. I doubt the council would allow the walls to be raised. Anyway it would look terrible since the whole row of houses will have the same height.

    Tim, there appears to be a birch in the pavement outside the front wall already. Until you have seen it in leaf I would wait and see the effect on your front garden before planting anything new. Meanwhile, here's some reading for you. RHS front garden guide

    B H thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks again wholeheartedly to everyone who's taken the time to impart their knowledge to us.

    Floral_uk we will certainly read the guide you kindly provided the link too. Your observations from the photo's are once again on the money. Have you an idea as to when the birch will leaf please?

    Embothrium, we were thinking of having trees or shrubs approximately 4-5 feet tall, which would be much taller than the width of the garden patches that are there now.

    Logan, thanks very much also for the list of shrubs and perennials. As novices, we'll now look into them and we'll be sure to keep you updated.


  • 9 years ago

    That *IS* a small space.

    I do like Logan's suggestion of 'Sky Pencil' Japanese Holly.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    >the whole row of houses will have the same height<

    If this is a concern about maintaining same walls throughout the row the wall visible immediately next door does not match O. P.'s wall right off the bat - both in color and to a partial extent, in height. And both are too short to hide the modern garbage cans from public view so if the whole sector has the same low walls it would actually be a general enhancement if everybody within it raised the height of their garden walls. 4-5 ft. shrubs would at least hide the cans from the street but would also appear too tall for the existing bed widths. Yet still be too short to make the O.P. outdoor living space invisible from the street. And would also fail to hide all of the street from inside the property.

    If any reduction in street noise is hoped for plantings will have very little effect on this, it again being necessary to raise the wall height instead.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Embo, the walls may not be absolutely identical but they are basically the same and absolutely typical. Millions of Victorian and Edwardian houses here have similar front gardens and you can't just go building your walls higher. Originally these low walls usually had iron railings on top but thousands of feet of these were removed in WW2 supposedly for recycling. Post WW2, before there were many planning regs, people added a few courses of bricks, higher gate posts, planted hedges, added fences or whatever. Nowadays it is almost certainly impossible to alter the height due to planning laws. You can whitewash it but not change the height - just isn't an option. You'd have to apply for planning permission if the wall borders a public highway and would end up over a metre high - and it would certainly be refused. You could add a foot or two of trellis though. I have two neighbours, one with a Passion Vine and one with a variegated ivy on trellis which raises the wall by about 3 feet. You could also plant a row of shrubs but they must be maintained so they don't impinge on the pavement. This will never be an outdoor living space. It is straight onto the street - noisy, public and polluted and even it it weren't, there is little tradition of people sitting out in front of their houses. You'd probably get stared at. Concepts which might suit a US milieu just don't work in a typical urban UK streetscape. The problem with the large ugly dustbins and the tiny front garden is seen all over the country. Ideally people either lug the bin through the house to the back garden or build a bin shelter in the front.

    BH the birch will be leafing out in the next couple of weeks. The bark on yours looks very white so if you're lucky it might be jacquemontii. The council will be able to tell you. There are loads of smaller shrubs/trees which you could pop into that space but you'd need to be prepared to do a bit of pruning now and then.

    BTW I have only found one single supplier of Sky Pencil Japanese Holly in the UK. It isn't well known here.

    B H thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Embothrium. Floral_uk is right about the situation with the front wall. It's a remnant of a bygone era, but not one we can change. I think 5ft shrubs or trees would suit us very well, as we live on a quiet street so don't need to block it out entirely. Hiding the bins (cans!) and our neighbours' yards is something we'd like the planting to achieve though. The beds themselves are deep so maybe we can find something that will work in their narrow width? I forgot to mention that the garden is West facing, around 240 degrees. Floral_uk thanks again, we look forward to seeing the tree leaf!

  • 9 years ago

    I like Foral's suggestion of vines on a trellis for at least some of the length perhaps along with some slender shrubs. If you used a metal trellis of traditional style, it would be a nod to the iron that topped the walls preWWII. Groundcovers or perennials under the shrubs/vines will help reduce the need for weeding between them.

    B H thanked NHBabs z4b-5a NH
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    If you wanted to be sneaky you could put large cement window boxes filled with tall plants on the wall. The box would add a foot or or two and you could choose plants to add more height. Lavender, yarrow, rosemary, Penstemon, liatris...or something that would dangle and cover the wall.

    If anyone complains you can move the boxes.

    Rail Planter

    B H thanked edlincoln
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks NHBabs and edlincoln. I think that the vines are a really interesting idea. We're going to a garden centre today to look into the ideas you all have very kindly provided. edlincoln, I think that the boxes on the wall might be a little precarious, but I like the thought!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The link I included showed a planter that has a furrow in the middle that a fence rail goes into. It was designed for decks or balcony rails. `Your wall might be too big for that, but you could have a carpenter build something similar to that would fit over your wall.

    I think the fastigate yew, the metal trellis with vines and the sky pencil holly are the best options listed.

  • 9 years ago

    Why yew? They are called the "tree of death" for a reason (1 because that is a fitting description, and two because you will eat the berries and die). I'm assuming yews are common where you live, so look for some other fastigiate shrub. If you are thinking about the trellis and vines, you should plant some type of rambling rose. Most of the multiflora hybrids are easier to grow than other roses. Also, did I add that yews look like plastic?

  • 9 years ago

    Bed size is too small for fastigiate yews unless these are kept closely sheared. And a wall of dark green yew would be claustrophobic and gloomy in that small space - much more so than raising the wall height, continuing to paint it white.

  • 9 years ago

    Not a wall, Embo. Not YewS. A single specimen. And they stay slim for years even without clipping. With a little clipping they can continue for longer. I see quantities of them in gardens here. There is one where I work and in a previous garden I had T baccata 'Standishii' In the 10 years I was at that house it reached no more than chest height. I am not saying there must be a yew. But there is no reason not to have one.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't really like yew either, but they are one of the few conifers that can regenerate from old wood AND is highly shade tolerant. These are invaluable traits when trying to squeeze another conifer into a small space. Other conifers look horrible when you try to hack them to a small size. Other conifers lose branches if they are in shade, and never grow them back if the shade goes away.

    Lots of things are deadly if you eat them. (Including the computer you are reading this on) I tend to assume people will know better then to put random stuff in their mouth. I've never known a dog or child to try to eat yew.

    Oddly, its arborvitae that look like plastic to me.

  • 9 years ago

    I don't expect anyone to eat yew either, I was just stating a fact about it. I'm also not going to eat my computer because it cost $300 Lol.

  • 9 years ago

    And just to inject a bit of fact into the yew scare rhetoric the red aril is harmless and indeed the only part of a yew which is not toxic. You'd have to crunch up the seed to suffer any ill effects. Plus the fastigiate forms in my experience often don't fruit much or, being usually dioecious, at all.