Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19706586

Real Estate Commissions Increasing

9 years ago

Excellent article in The Washington Post this AM on Real Estate Commissions over the past ten years.

I hope the link will allow you to read the Article, if you so wish, without having to create an account.


The real estate industry has something the Internet can’t offer: The human element

Comments (25)

  • 9 years ago

    I wonder to what extent this is related to hiring all kinds of specialists for things one could easily do oneself, e.g. for college admission, meal preparation(ingredients and recipe), taxes, travel, standing in line, etc.

  • 9 years ago

    Non-subscribers can read 10 WaPo articles for free per month. You can also open Salti's link in an incognito browser window.

    Good read. I have been wondering myself why commissions haven't come down. When we bought my spouses parents house we did all the legwork, I called our agent (who we used in the past) and he showed us one place, presented one offer, moved us to closing, and got paid his standard percentage.

    I notice he has the whole team thing going as well. I looked online and he closed something like 140 transactions last year. In a hcol area that's big money. He owns the brokerage.

  • 9 years ago

    Interesting. We sold our last place off market to a neighbor.


    But we had interviewed agents before we knew she was interested (no contracts signed). It was very much a sellers' market. But one of the agents I interviewed was able to show me things like a comparison of two very similar houses, one staged one not staged, and the price differential. That's the kind of knowledge I wouldn't have been able to dig up on the Internet.


    And we found our off market transaction more challenging than expected. Dh and I are attorneys but not real estate attorneys. We tried to find an attorney to review our paperwork--mostly we wanted to make sure we did all the required disclosures. We asked everyone we could think of for recommendations. Either they wouldn't do it, or they insisted on creating individualized contracts for which they would have charged us thousands of dollars and that would have scared off our buyers. Both sides wanted to close quickly and the attorneys also would have slowed us down by two or more weeks. In the end we just used standard forms and did our own research to make sure we did all the disclosures. We had previously bought and sold in a different state where attorneys routinely closed residential real estate deals and I'm sure in that state we would have had no trouble finding an attorney to handle the closing in a reasonable way for a reasonable fee.


    I guess the bottom line is that I see a lot of value in an agent.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We did sell then buy transactions with an agent that netted him $50K last year for 5 weeks of work (would have been another $25K roughly if he'd brought in the buyers for our old house but they put in a low ball offer). Yes, for that money I did expect him to be on email/text at least 15 hours per day 7 days a week (even on his "day off"). I expected him to show the house personally at open houses and be present personally to meet inspectors and appraisers. I expected him to negotiate on my behalf. He is very competitive (fist pumps and yelling "YEAH!" and all). He saved us more than we paid him in commission by getting the house closed fast; helping out with staging; and negotiating a large price reduction on the house we bought based on inspection findings. A great agent costs the same as a mediocre or bad agent. Choose the winner not the one who says nice things to you or who wants to redecorate your house before selling it. It's a business transaction and the realtor is not your friend.

  • 9 years ago

    A great agent costs the same as a mediocre or bad agent

    which is rather curious, no? I understand that a good agent makes more overall b/c they close more transactions and likely get a higher cut from the agency, but it is odd that a good agent can't really charge more than a mediocre one.

  • 9 years ago

    They could...but evidently people wont pay.


  • 9 years ago

    "In 1997, the typical commission on a median-priced U.S. home, adjusted for inflation, was $16,600.

    Today, that commission is $20,131."

    I'd say that's worth a few 10:00 pm calls & texts.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I am not disagreeing, but is that $21,000 commission to one agent or the total commission?

    If you are in an area with buyer's agents and seller's agents this six percent gets split two ways, so it's 3 % for each agent's firm, or

    $10, 065.50 for each brokerage, then the agent pays the brokerage and this can be a 50/50 split to maybe a 75/ 25 split, or something else--this may vary.

    so the individual agent ends up with $ 5032.75 to $7500 odd.

    If they are on a team, there are further divisions, although you may get paid on a team for transactions in which you weren't directly involved.

    So there's quite a difference between what the entire commission is for the sale versus what an individual agent nets.

    In this market for an agent to make $50,000, that typically involves around $3M in sales, because the individual agent nets slightly under 2% for a typical transaction (not dual agency), not the entire 6%.

    In a low housing cost like where I grew up there is typically only one agent, and on some properties, there is a set fee for a transaction because if the fees were divided between two agents and two brokerages an individual agent would walk with $700 on a $35,000 house.

    I think there is a misconception that somehow each agent walks with the entire 6% commission, and that's not the case unless they are dual agency and their own broker and don't have to split with anyone else.

  • 9 years ago

    I think everyone knows the commission is split, it is still the same amount of money for the seller who pays it and usually only chooses one recipient.

  • 9 years ago

    Also a good agent should get a higher split, they should use some of their sales expertise to sell them self to their broker.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Usually the higher your sales the less a percentage you pay the brokerage and other fees may also be covered by the brokerage to keep the higher producers at that firm.

    "I think everyone knows the commission is split",


    Yes, but then it's a bit disingenuous to bring up the instance where one agent (dual, and the broker, as well) gets essentially the entire commission, or that $21,000 commission is worth a few phone calls or late texts as if the entire fee routinely goes to one person. I know plenty of people who make more than realtors do, who are not potentially available 16 hours a day or 7 days a week or on their day off. This just plays into the idea that realtors don't really do anything. The realtors I know work very hard for their money--as well paid as some of them are.

  • 9 years ago

    Some facts...

    The average annual income for all agents is $39,000.

    The avg. annual income for only full time agents is $54,000

    About 20% of agents make over $100,000.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    ncr

    Right, and again salaries are going to be local, because real estate prices are local.

    I doubt full time agents in the area I grew up in even make $39K. The housing prices don't support it. However, it's a relatively cheap to live there.

    And in the area a live now, many of them make over the $54K, and many make over $100K and we have a number who are regularly in the top 1% of producers in the country.

    However, you have to take into account that I also live in an area where the Living Wage (below which you are considered Low Income) is $51,000 pre tax income for a wage earner in a family of four, two adults and two children. I have patients who qualify for treatment under "restricted income" guidelines who make this much. So, sure, they make more money in a HCOLA but so must everyone else in the housing market.

    Real estate is one of those jobs where success is completely self-determined, based upon one's own actual production. I know lots of people who have corporate jobs where they can plod along at less than optimal performance for the bulk of their careers, and while they may not excel, they are relatively protected, can at least not get fired and collect benefits and a retirement. Realty is one of those jobs where you can't do that.

  • 9 years ago

    The greatest investment you can make.....take a course and get your own real estate license.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm sure it's changed over the years. Or maybe not.

    I used to work for a broker. At that time she wasn't into residential real estate but her daughter was. The model was recruit the agents en masse and send them to real estate school. She said each recruit was good for 3 listings: their own home, a parents home, and a sibling or close friends home. After that, pfft.

    Maybe that model has changed, or maybe not. So averages are a little misleading in any case, because there are so many marginally productive agents at the lower end.

  • 9 years ago

    The model has changed somewhat. Some of the brokerages cater to new agents (Coldwell Banker, Keller Williams, C-21, ERA etc) and their model is as you describe (still). However, the other agencies have changed their model to recruit experienced agents where the expenses are passed on to the individual agent. These expenses include desk fees (eg: monthly rent), E&O insurance, marketing expenses (broker doesn't pick up any of these fees), etc. In exchange for this, the experienced agent will negotiate a higher split from the broker. The broker gets agents that produce and stay rather than leave in 6 months. Plus the broker doesn't have to train experienced agents.

    Most of the newby's have no idea of the expense out of their own pockets and come in with a false idea of what an agent does to market and sell a home. Many come in with a corporate attitude that the listings will be handed to them because that is what they experienced in their last career. This real estate career is not for everyone. I do agree with your last sentence: the averages are skewed downward because their are so many agents at the lower end. Those agents are the first to leave after a few months once they discover they have to put up the funds to get anywhere. :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Not sure if it is denial or other.

    Real Estate Commissions have gone up linearly with home values in current year dollars.

    As I suggested in, as an example, in 1969 I personally could buy a nice home for a selling price equal to one years then salary. The 6% commission equaled also 6% of my annual income.

    People no longer can find suitable housing for their annual housing, they more typically feel the need to pay 2 or 2 1/2 or more times their salary. The 6% commission on that house represents 12% or 15% of their annual salary.

    Realtors have seen their commissions increased by leveraging at the expense of seller's closing costs.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I dunno, without seeing some data, saying that you could buy a perfectly fine house in 1969 for equal your salary and you personally can't now seems anecdotal at best. Depending where I wanted to live, I could find a great house for less than my salary right now, and in some areas I couldn't buy a decent house at ten times my salary...what does that mean?Nothing other than housing prices vary by location by a lot. NCRealestateguy at least presented some salary data.

    But besides that in 1969, people bought houses that were smaller and less elaborate than they are now. A 1969 house would not be found acceptable to the same market in 2016. My father was a physician when he was in practice, and other physicians, business owners and even the few millionaires in town built houses that were considered very nice at the time, but "modest" by today's standards. Now these houses are bought by teachers and low level management-- and my father's house was bought by a couple in their 20s (and sorry it is an exceptionally built house in very good condition not something run down because it's 45 years old) --now a Dr. or business person would turn their nose up at a house this modest and it's something that would be built (at least size wise) by someone like a school teacher or office worker and a Dr. or business person would build something monstrous. That's a cultural factor, not some real estate agent conspiracy to make more money.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I based my comment on (obviously) anecdotal experience in moving all over the country and buying every three or four years in different regions.

    You said, "But besides that in 1969, people bought houses that were smaller and
    less elaborate than they are now. A 1969 house would not be found
    acceptable to the same market in 2016"

    Doh. That was the purpose of my post. If folks now feel the need for homes that are priced far above their means, then real estate dollars paid in commissions will represent a greater percentage of their earnings - to the benefit of the realtors.

    Did you even try to understand the math? Do you understand what "leveraging" means?

    Wow.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Median home sold on 1970 was a bit over $24,000. That's $152,500 today, but today's median sales price is $240,000. It really is somewhat geographic dependent.

    Average male made a bit over $6000 anually in 1970. It's harder to find the info for median household earnings not adjusted for inflation.

    My take is Salti made pretty good scratch in 1969 if he could buy a home on a years salary!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Did you even try to understand the math? Do you understand what "leveraging" means?

    Wow

    Actually, I do. And I understand the math. And I understand that median house pricing has outpaced inflation. But that's not really what you said. You implied you couldn't buy a house now for your salary even if you wanted to, when at one time nearly everyone could (which I don't believe) . I was pointing out that even people who could don't want to (and yes understand it's not at all possible for some people to buy something for anywhere close to their salary--depending upon where they live).

    But I don't think this is really the point of your post anyway. I think the point of your post is that you think realtors make too much money.

  • 9 years ago

    In 1969, Salti took his wife out to dinner and tipped the waitress 15% of a $25 dinner. Last week he took his wife out to dinner and tipped the waitress 15% of a $100 dinner.

    On the way home from dinner, Salti realized that his dang waitress' wages from this night's dinner have gone up linearly with food values in current year dollars.

    I don't see any revealing insight coming from the article.

  • 9 years ago

    SD’s posted article was stating the fact the average
    commission paid has increased over the years when most expected with the advent
    of the internet it would decrease. I do
    find this fact curious, good for the RE industry, bad for consumers. The
    internet has radically changed RE, but not the RE commission as was expected.

    The internet has helped me tremendously, I’ve found many
    houses online, perused the listing, seen aerial views. I can also see the
    listing history, what the seller paid and view previous listing pictures to see
    improvements, all done from the comfort of my desk. Right now I’m considering buying in an area
    that I hadn’t thought of, but searching on redfin showed me additional areas
    with the house size and lot size I want. I need the agent to get me in the door once, negotiate
    the offer and bring it to closing. I never
    tour around in the car with an agent, hate that.

    I don’t begrudge any agent whatever commission he can earn
    as it takes a person hiring that agent for him to earn his commission I respect many realtors, I know many are
    professional, earning their high income. Right now I’m interviewing listing agents,
    the agents have not agreed to list for less than 5%, even though he will earn
    about $200,000 in commission. If I find
    this the going rate I’ll gladly pay it to the right agent as I want a quality
    agent. I’ve known I’d be listing so I’ve
    closely watched several of the local agents learning who I want to
    interview. I’m aware I can use redfin or another discount
    company, that doesn’t interest me as I want the service of a knowledgeable full
    service agent. For that matter I can
    list FSBO, again doing this is not in my best interest.

    Palimpsest – you appear to be emotionally connected to the
    profession – commissions can be discussed and defended without making negative comparisons
    to other professions. Also an experienced
    agent learns when to cut a client loose.
    If a buyer is wasting an agent’s time, or a seller has unrealistic expectations
    it’s time to move on to another client, knowing when to do this is a part of
    successful agent’s learned skills.

  • 9 years ago

    It is interesting that the expected decline in commission rates, or a change in the model (i.e. flat commissions) hasn't really taken hold. I would say a lot of it is that unlike say stock trading where technology decreased cost and led to price cuts which then brought about a big uptick in volume, most people only buy/sell real estate as infrequently as possible. And technology hasn't reduced selling costs for the agent all that much, if it all.