Depends on the look you want and the style you strive for. Any photos of the options you have? Hickory has a large variability when stained. Kind of zebra striped if you know what I mean. Is that a good look for you? Alder is one of the least expensive options and you can stain it pretty much how you want it. If you can get the depth of stain you want without it looking "painted".? So, more info would help.