Software
Houzz Logo Print
brandy_amini

Help me save my succulents!

9 years ago

I'm pretty new to succulents and I'm constantly worried about them. I feel like I might be overwatering one and under watering the other? They are in a south facing window and receive plenty of sun.


The leaves on this one are starting to get soft and wrinkly. I checked the roots and they looked healthy (not that I really know what healthy roots look like). I think I might be overwatering this one, but I really only water once the soil is dry!

This one used to be a bright, vibrant green. Now it's turning brown. Is it possible it's receiving too much sun and not enough water? I also would like help identifying these if possible. I have two other succulents as well, and I'm wondering if it would be a bad idea to consolidate them all into one larger pot? I'm not sure if they have the same water/light requirements.

I have this one, which seems to be doing fine aside from one wrinkly leaf

And this one, which I just bought the other day, so I haven't had time to do any real damage to him yet.


I love these little plants so much, I just want them to be healthy! I'll take any tips on how to be a good succulent mom.

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago

    IMO Pic one pot seems a bit to small in size. At any rate it could be raised up so that it's base is closer to flush with the top of the pot such kind acts often help.


    Pics 2 & 3 I agree they look a bit heat stressed. Keep in mind, even though they are often bright enough not all windows are best suited for plants. While some do almost every single pained and some lower cost double pained windows offer no LOW E UV protection. While the operative wording is brightness not so much on heat.


    Pic 4 looks store bought new in comparison to pic 3 Wont get into what type of pot works better than the other in concerns of clay Vs. ceramic as long as there is drainage the pot could do well. Best odds today are Apx 250,000 : 1 in your favor that there may also be soil concerns from one or more others.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Christina,

    I'm already aware of the glass pot issue. These two were my first succulents and were gifted to me this way. I just haven't been able to find something suitable for them yet! They were doing okay in there all winter up until about two weeks ago, so I thought they might be okay, but then I noticed it turning brown. I water probably once a week to every two weeks depending on how dry the soil is. The one in the first picture definitely gets more water than the ones in the glass pot, not gonna lie. So I should water that one less and the brown one more? They are all in the soil they came in when I got them. They all have drainage holes except for the glass pot.

    Do you think they're salvageable?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    How do you know it's time to water? Soil could be dry on the surface yet still too wet around the roots.

    Soil in your last photo doesn't look like what would be suitable for succulents. It would help if you can get a bag of perlite, sift it (or rinse) using ordinary kitchen sieve, and mix with the soil. Adding just a handful will not make difference, there should be at least 50% of perlite. That kind of the mix would drain better than dense, water retaining soil. And, as you know, pots with drainage. Longer you leave plants in conditions they are, harder it will be for them to 'spring back'.

  • 9 years ago

    Overwatered leaves will pop right off, under-watered leaves slowly shrivel.

  • 9 years ago

    So step 1- get a new pot with a drainage hole of the ones in the glass and a bigger pot for the one that's shriveling.

    Step 2- perilite and like soil that says it's made for succulents?

    I usually stick my finger about an inch or so into the soil to see if it's still damp before I water. Is there a better method? I've read hundred of pages online about how to care for them, everything says something different. I read somewhere about using a moisture meter, does anyone have any experience with those?

  • 9 years ago

    I think people who use moisture meters have some intense growing going on lol, I wouldn't bother with it for a few succulents but that is just IMO. I keep wooden toothpicks in my tiny pots and wooden skewers in my larger pots... I just check the stick for moisture if need be.

    Everyone says something different because there is no "right" answer :), just figure out what works for you.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't know what USDA zone you are in, Brandy, but unless you are in some high, arid desert and growing these outdoors, do not get potting soil labeled as "cactus and succulent soil", which in my opinion is a form of noob hazing. Nearly any other kind of commercial potting soil as long as they do not have sand will be better. Then amend that with 2 parts of sifted perlite (don't waste pumice even if you can get it).

    Going forward, if you notice yourself getting more and more succulents, you will have to graduate to other kinds of longer-term and much better potting medium.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi. Some call-outs


    1) If the lower leaves are drying off and new growth is in the middle, you're OK. That is the natural growing process. However, if the leaf gets wrinkly in the middle and up top, then it may mean it wants more water especially if it is super hot.

    2) Some of your items like the jades are lacking sun. Hence, smaller leaves and long, bare stems that seek light. Low light means low growth and low use of water, which makes them prone to overewatering. So acclimate to brighter places. They can even be trained to survive full sun if adapted slowly. But best is East or West facing outdoor spaces.

  • 9 years ago

    Checking just an inch or so of soil is not really enough; use wooden stick of some kind (bamboo skewer-chopstick; wooden dowel with sharpened end; pencil) and stick at least 3/4 deep into pot. More reliable than typical moisture meter.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    If you are really curious to see how your soil dries, fill a plastic cup with it and a couple holes punched in the bottom. Then water fully.

    Put it with your plants under the same conditions. You'll see how long it takes to dry out top to bottom. That's generally representative of your pots.

    Here is a very scientific cup of soil mix! Aha! You can even do the skewer trick and see how it works. Moisture meters probably won't be that helpful for your case, although I use them extensively.