Software
Houzz Logo Print
kalenangel

Dolomite/Quartzite test confusion

9 years ago

Back to the slab yard I went this morning, in search of a true quartzite. Last week I tested the Shadow Storm that was listed as a quartzite and it failed! Soy sauce stained it and it could not scratch glass (though it did not stain or etch from lemon juice, oil, ACV or ketchup).


So today I brought home two samples:


#1- Fantasy Blue Quartzite

#2 - Superior White Dolomite


I used ACV, lemon juice, ketchup and soy sauce for the tests. Let me first say that #1 Fantasy Blue "Quartzite" could not scratch glass, but I know many times the Fantasy Brown is found to be a marble as well, so I kinda expected it. But what I didn't expect was that nothing stained or etched it??? But dragging a fork across the top left serious scratches.


The #2 Superior White Dolomite dug into the glass pretty deep, making scratches you could feel with your nail. Does that mean it is a quartzite??And nothing stained it.....but EVERYTHING etched it! All four liquids left defined textures changes.


Rock experts, any thoughts on the results?



Comments (8)

  • 9 years ago

    That's what I thought. I think I was confused because everything I have read says that glass is a 5 on the hardness scale and dolomite is like a 3.5. So I have no idea why it etched the glass so easily, like a quartzite, which I believe is like a 6 on the scale.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    kalenangel:


    Stop getting dates at the biker bar; sure the bad boys are attractive, but they're no good for the long term. We've told you and even they're telling you too. All your love will never make them stop etching.


    Settle down with a nice granite, estone, or dare I say it, solid surface.

  • 9 years ago

    Hey... my husband has a bad boy side, and I'm sure we wouldn't be approaching 15 years of marriage without it :-) But to clarify, I just wanted someone who maybe understood why the dolomite was passing the scratch test as if it was quartzite. And maybe explain why the true marble did not stain or etch. I know that these stones all have their downfalls, so I want to make as educated a choice as possible. I think I found the answer in one of karin's comments. Thanks for your suggestion.

  • 9 years ago

    Are you sure the sample you got are actually those slabs because they don't look like them at all. Likely the samples have not been sealed, your countertops will be. My fantasy brown which looks a lot like fantasy blue because it has a lot of blue gray and just smaller amounts of light brown, doesn't stain so far or etch and it scratches the heck out of glass. I think each individual slab has to tell it's own story and know exactly what you are looking at. I got a piece of my actual slab to test. I knew it wasn't sealed. My countertops are well sealed.

    That fantasy blue slab there is gorgeous I would be all over that one.

  • 9 years ago

    Ravencajun- good point! My samples were from slabs in the same lot, but not those pictured. They were pieces cut from remnants. I guess when I make up my mind I'll get a piece from the exact slab. Thanks!

  • 9 years ago

    I really like the blue fantasy. I have blue-grey marble countertops, and I just discovered my first etching the other day. It doesn't bother me in the least. It's still a gorgeous countertop. I do food prep on our butcher block island to reduce acid etching, but otherwise just keep the marble perimeter clean and dry.

    And can I ask, do you see yourself scratching your counters with a fork very often?

    kalenangel thanked mayhemingway
  • 9 years ago

    I doubt I'll be fork scratching, but I have been known to toss my keys on the counter when putting down groceries or dropping glasses from a higher cabinet.