Software
Houzz Logo Print
jasong_1975

Which Fert To Apply Please

I have yet to put down any fertilizers this year yet. The front lawn is established, not a nice dark green though. And the back lawn was slit seeded last late September 2016 - and so far it is doing fairly well, but still with some bare spots.

I live up here in Ontario, Canada. So we don't have the good Milorganite unfortunately. I do have a unopened bag of Scott's Lawn Food 30-0-3. What might you all suggest? I would appreciate the guidance.

Thanks.

Comments (35)

  • 9 years ago

    I think most on this site will tell you it is impossible to say what the best fertilizer to put down is without a soil test. A soil test will tell you if your lawn needs extra N,P or K. For instance I had a soil test done earlier this year and now i'm applying a balanced 16-16-16 fertilizer Because my test showed I was lacking in P and K. Getting a soil test done is the best start to determining what fertilizer your lawn needs to be at it's healthiest.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked snowbob11
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you. I have a list of local soil testing labs that I just found, but are not sure which would be the most reputable. Has anyone here used any of them on this list? I wouldn't hesitate to send in a couple of samples if I knew which to try for the first time.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm in S Ontario like you and I sent my soil to logans lab in the USA. They are considered a very reputable lab. Just follow the instructions on how to submit a test. It costs $25US plus shipping costs. It can be difficult to interpret a test and you will probably have to post it on the site to get it interpreted (not that i'm trying to give any members any extra work).

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked snowbob11
  • 9 years ago

    In the front put down 3# of 30-0-3 product for every 1000 sq ft this weekend.

    Ideally in the back you should have been spoon feeding N every 2 weeks for the past 6 weeks. This weekend put down 2# of the 30-0-3 product per 1000 sq ft.

    I'd recommend Brookdside over Logan. Otherwise call any of the others on your list and insure that they provide recommendations with their results.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Jason, I think the Scotts turf builder will be just fine. Just make sure not to over-apply it. Better to fertilizer lightly-often than heavy and infrequently. I'm going to guess your soil sample results will show fertility is fine with perhaps a slight need for nitrogen.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked richsd
  • 9 years ago

    Lots of great help here, that is why I'm enjoying this forum as much as I am! Thank you to all.

    I will definitely be sending in some samples to a lab, and thank you for your suggestions. So do most use a special core sample taking hand tool, or go about taking them differently? What is the turnaround time at this time of year generally?

    Ok so, I used Google Maps to help get an idea of my properties square footage - the Distance Measuring Tool. Click on all of your points, enough to create a closed space, and it will start to calculate your square footage or meters. So I got 2957 sq. ft. - is it safe to round up to 3000 sq. ft. for the sake of keeping it simple?

    The bag of Scott's says that the package applies 3.0lbs per 1000 sq.ft. - so use 9lbs of this 13lbs bag for front and back? Ridgerunner, or should I still go with the 2lbs in the backyard, and 3lbs in the front yard two sections? If I place 5lbs in the hopper (the Scott's Turf Builder EdgeGaurd DLX I'll be using) I'm wondering how I will use it all from start to finish of my entire lawn front and back. This is what concerns me - either having product left over or not enough once I finish. The math is what gets me lol.

    Thanks again all!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Round off. So yes 9# of product for your 3k of yard. You can safely use the recommended settings for the Edgegaurd spreader that is on the bag of Turfbuilder Lawn Food. You just have to get a feel for your spreader and your lawn size and that will come from practice. By the 3rd or 4th time of applying fertilizer, you should have a pretty good idea of the setting, walking speed and distance between swaths needed to apply the recommended amount evenly over your lawn. There is a good bit of "fudge factor", so don't spend too much time worrying about getting down precisely exact. Better to put down a little less than way too much-if that helps.

    If you are going to do a soil test, take the samples before fertilizing. 3-4 samples from the back and another 3-4 from the front. A vertical 1" thick slice. From the 0" level down to 4". Most labs will return the results (usually by email) within a week after receipt. Most people just use a shovel to take the samples. Some use a garden trowel, some use a bulb planter (if the soil is soft enough), some spend the the money for a soil sample corer and some use a Pro-Plugger. Using a shovel is a little more effort, but does the job fine, Follow the directions given above.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    I forgot to address your question about fertilizing the back. The only reason for suggesting 2# vs 3# is that with newer young turf, the roots aren't very deep and at 3#, much of the N would just leach below the roots and be wasted. No harm (other than a little waste) applying 3#.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Ok I will hold off on applying the Scott's for now until I can get some plugs pulled for the lab testing. I can understand how it could contaminate the samples and throw off any results.

    By the way, I looked up what a ProPlugger was, and I was so darn amazed by it's 5 in 1 uses, that I bought one! ;) Thanks for mentioning it! It should be here by Thursday next week, so I will take my samples then, and apply the lawn food next weekend. It looks as though a 2" deep sample taken with it should be about the same as a 1" core at 4" deep. The ProPluggers diameter looks to be about 2". Or take a 4" deep sample and then just half it vertically with a knife?

    How does the layout I used earlier look where I would take the 8 lab samples from?

    So as far throwing down 9lbs of the lawn food, how do others go about weighing what they are going to place in their spreaders hopper? I could use a fish weigh scale! Lol.

    Thank you.

  • 9 years ago

    Always take the samples to the four inch depth for best test results. No need to cut the plug in half. Just put all the plugs in a plastic bucket, break them up, pull out all of the grass, roots (shake the soil out of them), rocks and sticks that you can, mix them all together thoroughly and send two cups of the mixture to the lab.

    Your sample plan looks fine, except I think I'd only take one sample from the city lawn and do three from the front lawn as the front has more area and is likely more important to you as a lawn area.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Somebody's been watching the lawn care nut.

  • 9 years ago

    Not!

  • 9 years ago

    Here is how I weigh products. I weigh myself holding an empty bucket. Then I add product to the bucket and weigh myself holding the bucket, adding more or taking away as needed to get to the required weight.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked beckyinrichmond
  • 9 years ago

    Two inches won't work with the ProPlugger because the roots are deeper than than it seems. I'm just watering the front lawn to help soften up the soil.

    Shouldn't I try and separate them into areas? Like send them different samples for the front yard and back yard?

    No regular scale here :) But that would definitely work for sure! I'll give my digital fishing scale a try.

    Thanks all again!

  • 9 years ago

    Shouldn't I try and separate them into areas? Like send them different samples for the front yard and back yard?

    Maybe. Do you have reason to believe there are differences between the two?

    Reasons for separate testing would include:

    Lime, phosphorous or potassium being applied to one and not the other.

    A difference in soil texture, the front is very sandy and the back is more clay like.

    A distinct difference in color of the soil. One is quite darker than the other.

    The back is flat, but the front is a very steep slope.

    You had soil brought in to fill in an in-ground pool that was removed or to level a large section.

    You've treated both the front and the back the same (fertilizer, watering , mowing, they are both full sun, etc) for years and the turf consistently does much poorer in the front than the back.



    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Mainly I am just curious to see if there is a difference in the analysis. There is a difference between the backyard where it is more like clay, and the front is more like sand.

    I'm going to try and send some samples to this lab about 2 hours from my place - and still being here in my province.

    Here is what they replied back with after I enquired:

    "Good Morning,

    Yes, we do residential lawns. We have a lawn and garden program that will recommend certain fertilizers. The cost of this is $25.00 + tax per sample. We require 2 cups of sample. You can find our residential lawn submission form on our website.
    http://www.alcanada.com/eServices-Forms.htm

    A&L Canada Laboratories

    2136 Jetstream Rd

    London, Ontario

    N5V 3P5"


    Should the basic analysis be good enough for my purpose? I've attached a screen shot of the sheet that I would submit with the samples.

  • 9 years ago

    A couple of observations:

    1. The S1B package (basic test) is adequate for the soil adjustments that are commonly addressed by homeowners and will have the most impact on the turf. HOWEVER, although micro-nutrients are seldom so deficient as to adversely affect grasses and are not easy to adjust, I do believe it is advantageous to know their values "just in case." I would suggest that you ask for S7 test in addition to the S1B for this first initial test. If the S7 shows all micros are sufficient and no adjustments are made to them, the S7 would not be needed or recommended in any future year testing.

    2. The submission form you posted above appears to be for agricultural soil testing. Their site also show a form for residential lawns, but gives no details as to what tests are provided. I suggest that you contact them and ask how you can request a S1B with S7 test and receive recommendations for a residential lawn.

    3. Although I found some details on their site they do not specify which methods are used for some tests. I would suggest that you also ask them what testing method they use for determining buffer pH, and for determining potassium values, and for determining micro-nutrient values (S7), and for determining Calcium and Magnesium values. I would also ask them if they automatically do the ammonium acetate test if soil pH is high, if not ask them what they would charge if you were to ask for the ammonium acetate test after you received your initial report. (You may or may not want nor need the AA test even if pH is high depending of the test methods employed.)

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Being summer time, I wouldn't get crazy with the fertilizer. Toronto gets plenty hot and jacking up the lawn during the summer is crazy. Just wait until fall and hit it hard, based on what your soil test tells you.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked mishmosh
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Ridgerunner. I sent them a reply asking those questions about the test methods. Waiting to hear back yet.

    Is it really to late for me to use the lawn food? Not been overly crazy hot here, with a fair bit of rain. Temps have been 30ºC with humidex making it feel like 40ºC. But they will be returning to normal Monday.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    You're a couple of weeks late, but it shouldn't create any issue if you get it down this weekend as there are cooler temps forecast next week. Just water it in well. (0.4" or more) The biggest issue will be whether the turf can still use it to store carbs for summer stress recover in late August. It shouldn't stress the grass like a July or early August feeding might.

    I take it you have already pulled your soil samples.


    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Excellent thank you. The past couple of days have seen about 1" or more of rain easily. So the soil will be plenty moist still. It's been a very wet start to the Spring - the wettest on record actually. So hopefully the root systems aren't stressed by that already.

    How much will the lawn food help out with weed growth? We do have quite a bit of Clover on the go front and back, with lots of Speedwell around still (not as much new growth, slowing?) and some Moss in very few small spots. Just the front yard in an area we have some small Canadian Thistle plants. Dandelions will be making a comeback again soon for another round. I did pick up a concentrated 4L jug of Fiesta Weed Control that will be getting used very soon before the Dandelion machine starts up again.


  • 9 years ago

    And yes I have pulled my samples of soil too :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    How much will the lawn food help out with weed growth?

    It certainly isn't going to hurt them. Weeds use N just like any other plant. One of the reason's weeds are such a pain is that they each have developed a niche and most proliferate in environments that grasses find less conducive e.g. high heat, low nutrients, a large range of pH, wet or dry etc.). As temps raise, grasses naturally begin to slow down. Studies have indicated that this is directly related to transpiration rates. Point I'm trying to make is that as temperatures rise, grass metabolism is slowing and so is its use of NPK. Many weeds are more than happy with the heat and dry weather and will thank you for the extra N. Due to circumstances beyond my control, I missed the June 1 window. I'm south of you by about 100 miles or so and due to the current heat and slowing rainfall, I've decided not to fertilize as I think the grass wont be able to put it to use (not because I fear stressing the turf) and I see no reason to encourage the weeds. So really your call, if you think temps will be low enough (daytime 80F Tops) for the turf to keep growing and storing carbs then it can be a benefit. If daytime temps are going to average 80+F, then I'd skip it rather than feed the weeds. Clear as mud?

  • 9 years ago

    Jason,

    I got to thinking. That wasn't a very useful standard I gave for you to make a judgement by.

    If your grass is still green, not starting to show signs of dying out, you still need to cut more than once a week. Then it can and will still benefit from the N this weekend. My lawn (KBG) is starting to show some brown tip areas, heat stress, and I'm only needing to cut once a week and that's just to neaten it up, that's why I think N at this point would be useless for me.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you for that. Well, the need for cutting every 4th day has turned into every 6 days now. Still plenty of green in the grass, although it has gone a bit patchy during the past week as you can see in the photos. Some nice darker green, with lighter green around the lawns outer parts. Not sure what this is caused by, and this is just our backyard that was slitseeded late September 2016.




    Upcoming weather forecast does look good with more rain and seasonal temps, maybe slightly below. So the grass should still be able to benefit from the lawn food.

  • 9 years ago

    And I did download the appropriate submission form for residential lawn soil samples from A&L Labs here.

  • 9 years ago

    With that forecast, yes, I'd put it down today if you can.

    Yes that's the one with recommendations included. I wish they'd show a sample of the report or list their testing methods and the form in which they are reported for homeowners. Oh, well, It is what it is. If you don't mind, I'd appreciate you posting the report just to satisfy my curiosity.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    I did put it down earlier, just before some rain. I'll have to add some tomorrow as it was only around 0.25" of rain.

    I definitely used a bit more than 9 lbs to cover all of the lawn. Closer to 11lbs.

    And of course I will share the results with you. I'm holding the soil sample in a sandwich bag at the moment. What do you send your samples in?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The U.S. post office has an assortment of boxes. I stand in line at customer service and I tell them I need a box to mail this: and I show them the bag. (The first time I mailed a sample, they suggested I go home and double bag it to prevent breakage and spillage.) They have always had a box that fits perfectly. Insert double bagged soil into the box and seal it. Return and get it weighed for postage. Many times, they do it all (boxing, sealing and weighing) for me while I'm at the counter. Pay and that's it. I would think Canadian Postal would work pretty much the same?

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Wow. Just looked at the seasonal temps for July, august in Toronto. Not bad at all! I grew up in Toronto and don't remember it being that balmy. I remember sweating it out because the folks didn't have air conditioning. Really, if you are willing to water when needed, those temps are great for growing grass right through until fall. I'm almost jealous except your winters are biting cold!!!

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked mishmosh
  • 9 years ago

    I'll likely just get a small box from work to avoid the hassle incase Canada Post doesn't offer one. They can be bought there, but the sad little thing would cost $5 Lol. I still have the sample in the bag. How long will it be ok in there? I plan to send it by weeks end.

    Hey mishmosh. How long has it been since you've lived here? I'm in Brampton myself. You missed last year's nasty hot and humid summer! Hottest on record it was - lawns everywhere were brown. This summer's temps will be more seasonal or below.

  • 9 years ago

    1984, lol. But i still visit every year because it's still my favorite city.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The weekend is fine. Did you ever get any answers? another poster pointed out that A&L Canada only test the major nutrients. Is that Ok with you? and not sure if they do an actual buffer pH test.

    Jason (Toronto, Ontario Canada 4b/5a) thanked User
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Nice to hear that you still come back for a visit!

    Ok thank you. I never did hear back from them with what questions I had Ridgerunner - a good reason for me to look elsewhere.