Software
Houzz Logo Print
ashley_leger

Too tall jade plant

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Hello, I was wondering if I could some get recommendations on where to trim my jade plant. I have two black thumbs and don't want to kill it since it's been doing so well.

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Plant looks OK, but perhaps not...'doing so well'... if it needs to be supported? That could be from heavy top growth, or may be from soil staying wet for too long. It would grow more compact if in better sun - it would love outdoors, after acclimatizing it could stay in full sun.

    If my plant, I would use better draining mix (soil in the photo looks wet to me). It could be pruned quite a bit, depending on what your idea for look of the plant is. It is as easy as cutting off parts or even whole branches - these would grow into new plants.

    Eta: missed the location info....thanks Kevin!

  • 9 years ago

    More light and much better soil will greatly as Rina recommends. Since you are Ontario, the weather is pretty good and light outside better.

    The answer to me is not really cutting it back, but improved conditions to ensure it's strong and self supporting.

  • 9 years ago

    What if the OP wants it shorter? Would it be possible to cut off, allow to dry, & a plant that size could grow from a large cutting? Personally, I don't care for the long trunk, and OP might feel the same.

  • 9 years ago

    Sure it could - jades (as long as they are healthy) will tolerate lots of cutting. I do not care for extra tall plants either, rather see a jade with thick and tapered trunk, and shorter overall. That "old tree" look is desirable...:) I wouldn't worry about cutting it in half - just above the light colored stake - if I wanted to. But OP didn't say anything about what kind of look he/she wants...maybe will post later on today?

    PPL often confuse etiolation with 'great growing'... 'it grows fast'... but weak, thin branches is not really good growing.

    Socks, maybe you remember threads titled: 'chopping jades'...'whacking jades'...some great photos in many of those threads.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Usually I would like to fix the things Rina mentions and then have the plant actively growing. Then it's time to start cutting - rerooting and new growth will be faster that way.

    If you cut and then try to reroot, it may be a longer and less productive process.

    Overall, maybe it's debatable either way and doesn't really matter. Don't think it's about the race on this one but the final result.

  • 9 years ago

    If you want, prune a couple inches off of each of the upper branch tips, then get the plant outside to ensure the resulting growth is more compact and balanced above the central trunk.

    If you want then entire thing shortened, it's going to require a hard chop. That, of course, will yield two nice plants.

    Josh

  • 9 years ago

    Hi everyone. Thanks for your suggestions. I would like it to be shorter and thicker, more tree like. Ie cutting below the stake as suggested by Rina. It's currently sitting in a South Western window and gets lots of sunlight. I inherited it from a friend as a housewarming gift. It did have a baby which I have repotted separately


    . For me, if a plant is growing and not dying, "it's doing well!" I am just afraid of cutting it in half (basically) and then losing both ends.

  • 9 years ago

    Ashley

    You won't loose jade from cutting-pruning-chopping-whacking...:) As long as it is not overwatered = kept too wet after cutting.

    Your plants are looking quite good but could look even better. Etiolation is more visible on your second plant: the sets of leaves are too far apart. Plant keeps stretching in search of more light; this could be solved only by keeping it in more. Outside will be much better. I also think the soil may be more water retaining than it should, there are lots of 'salts' deposits on inside of the pot. When you water, soil likely stays wet for too long, and deposits build up.

    First, repot into better draining mix.

    If you are afraid of pruning, maybe try with one of the plants first: cut where desired. Use sharp knife or blade. Let cut off part to callus - scab over, by leaving it out of direct sun until the cut ends starts getting dry. That may be few hours or even few days. Plant will live, there is lots of moisture stored in trunks and leaves. After callusing, this pruned off piece should be potted into well draining mix. Do not water until roots start growing: no roots - no water. Once they start growing, there is usually some new growth appearing. It could take couple of weeks or longer. Part with roots should stay potted and will start branching where it was cut.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Be brave, Ashley! Follow Rina's directions, don't be afraid to let the end dry up before repotting.

    As for the second one, it's trying to look like its brother because it needs more light. Could you put them both outside? They both look wet. To get the very best planting mix for your succulents, combine commercial cactus and succulent mixed 50-50 with perlite or pumice from your nursery. If perlite, rinse it to remove the smallest particles. Pumice is better if you can get it. The second pot is quite deep, so the soil will take a while to dry out.

    Be careful not to overwater. Stick a wood skewer in the soil for a while, pull out to see if it's damp. If it is, don't water.

  • 9 years ago

    Perhaps someone else has the research at hand, but I remember reading that window screens can block 30-40% of sunlight. I investigated this because I had moved some plants from a screened-in lanai area to a nonscreened area and they burned up in days. So maybe the screen could make winter light even more difficult for the plants?

    I just mention the screen because you are probably using your best lit window and south west is pretty good.

    Good advice given here. Looks like a nice plant.

Sponsored
Snider & Metcalf Interior Design, LTD
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars25 Reviews
Leading Interior Designers in Columbus, Ohio & Ponte Vedra, Florida