Software
Houzz Logo Print
msk70

Help my dogwood please

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Hi. My front yard has full exposure to the sun with little shade, it also has three dogwoods in it. They are ok at best. One of them looks to be struggling badly,

i have removed most mulch, composted around it tree, and tried to expose the root flare as much as possible but it still is struggling.

it looks ( my grass and tree ) like it is thirsty. My lawn service thinks it is getting too much water ( I was watering 1.5 hrs , 2x day ( mornings), 3 days a week which is a lot but the spread on my yard sprinklers is large and they do not put down a lot of water ). I've cut back to 30 min, 2x day, 3 days week.

any recommendation? Leaves are starting to die rapidly.

Comments (17)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Dogwoods are understory trees. They are typically found growing in the dappled shade beneath taller trees (like tall southern pine trees) , or at the edge of a clearing where they get part sun.

    In my area (northwest metro Atlanta) they will grow in full sun, but when they do, they always look stunted with fried looking shrivly leaves.

    If you have any shade in your yard, I would wait until fall and transplant the tree to a shadier area, and then plant a sun-loving tree in this location.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't like the idea of watering lawns and trees on the same schedule with the same irrigation methods- they have different needs.

    Have you ever deep watered these trees with a slow hose trickle over a longer period of time? Have you even felt down two inches after watering to see if the soil is dry or moist? Does the water even penetrate the roots? Are you going to replace the mulch so the roots don't fry any worse than they already are?

    Nutshell: Don't water the thing so often but when you do water it make it deep and do it long enough to penetrate the roots.

    And Ryan is right- it would do much better in a more part shady spot. It still looks small enough to move easily- it won't stay that way forever :)

  • 9 years ago

    There are two common types of dogwoods, Cornus florida amd Cornus kousa. Those are both understory trees which prefer some shade and honestly while I rate them 10 of 10 on flowers and 10 and 9 of 10 on fall color, they are somewhat picky to location.

    There is a somewhat rare in trade Cornus controversa which likes full sun (in St Louis anyway), grows faster and wider. I give it a 9 of 10 for flowers and 7 or 8 of 10 for fall color, good color but not the ultimate Cornus florida has.

    Controversa grows fast for me, you can mail order a small one

  • 9 years ago

    Ok so thanks for info.


    looks like general consensus is that it needs water, deep and infrequent and ideally shouldn't be in full sun. Re-add mulch to help prevent roots from sun and heat.


    given it is, I just want to ensure it is being cared for the best possible.


    correct?

  • 9 years ago

    I'm in zone 7, Virginia

  • 9 years ago

    msk, you have hit all the basics.

    I like swamp trees, its darn near impossible to over water them lol.

    For your dogwood, start testing the rootball soil with your thumb and get a feel for when it dries out.

  • 9 years ago

    Sorry for the stupid question, but how best to do that? Before I laid down some compost and mulch I dig about 4 inches down and the soil was not dry, it wasn't clumpable moist... but it definitely wasn't dried out. Is it possible to over water these?

  • 9 years ago

    Yes it is possible to over water dogwoods.

    The easy part is sticking your thumb into the soil.

    The tougher part is deciding when the tree needs water. The extremes are easy. Dry cracked soil, water. Too muddy to mow, don't water. With my smaller Kousa dogwood I was watering when the soil at its roots was just getting dusty if that makes sense. My transplants are only 3 foot tall so a gallon or so holds them over. Yours will need quite a bit more.

    I might have to defer to others for a proper description of when dogwoods need watered.

    Swamp trees are easier, its near impossible to over water a bald cypress!

  • 9 years ago

    no this helps. The trees do 'look like' they have the signs of drought, leaves turning red and dropping off .. but maybe it is the opposite. overwatered tree. I'll continue to watch. thanks

  • 9 years ago

    Definitely drought. Keep the mulch away from the trunk, no more than 4 inches deep. Ring should spread slightly beyond canopy of the tree.

  • 9 years ago

    How large is the tree and how long has it been planted? Was it field or container grown?

    It looks like it is under stress, do the other two look the same?

    Here in mid TN dogwoods grow in full blazing sun, the local nurseries grow them that way by the tens of thousands. I've got trees 40 plus years old that are pristine. The best trees are ALWAYS open grown, that they are an understory species is a misnomer, most just end up that way. Most start out in open fields and get out competed and over topped as forest trees seed in .

  • 9 years ago

    there are 3 trees and the one on the left is in the worse shape, progressively better as you go across the yard. I am pretty convinced the amount of water here is just not enough but been told i'm over watering .. the ground itself is not dry, but it is a hard clay soil with little drainage in full sun all day. Same soil on side and back which has more shade with less watering has lush grass growth. I've cut back on watering to see if this will help, but concerned this is either root rot, or under watering .. if the latter not sure what to do as was watering with irrigation nearly 3 hrs, 3 days a week. Will move to drip watering if it is the best approach for the trees .. just not sure best course of action other than wait it out a bit.

  • 9 years ago

    Water at 7 or 8pm. I don't have the convenience of lawn sprinklers, so 2-3 times each week I have to hook three hoses together, the one on the end being a "sprinkler hose" (it shoots spouts of water up and over the garden), and pull them into my japanese garden. Everything there is newly planted, so watering by hand would take at least an hour. I ALWAYS do this right before the sun sets. When I get done, it's almost dark. You can also water in the morning, before the sun rises (I'm not a morning person). Try that (water deeply when you do, let the sprinkler spray solely on the trees) and report back here with your results in 2-3 weeks.

  • 9 years ago

    "if the latter not sure what to do as was watering with irrigation nearly 3 hrs, 3 days a week."

    Hours, days, times mean nothing if it isn't penetrating properly.

    Set an empty tuna can out there one day when it runs and measure exactly how much water that is delivering. Then consider that you have the trees set out in the middle of a thirsty lawn where competition is great.

    Better yet, dig down and look at the roots after the irrigation runs- you could figure this out in 30 minutes with a shovel.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    did the tuna can test, which is why I was running for so long .. but really wondering on the effectiveness of that test ( or the way I did it -- I used multiple cans in different places.) Cutting back on watering, and observing for a while. We have a hard clay soil here .. so everything under the topcoat is thick and doesn't drain well. Everytime i've dug down I haven't hit a dry patch but will test again soon.

  • 9 years ago

    You don't need to cut back on watering. Clearly, you need to water more.

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!