Software
Houzz Logo Print
everaftercottage

What size range/cooktop/oven?

9 years ago

We're expanding our kitchen and need to decide what we're going to do for our cooking. Is there any kind of recommended stove to eater ratio?

There are currently 7 people living at home and I cook 3 meals a day (plus snacks), often with 2 others "helping". I love to have friends over, which easily adds another 8-12. When our entire family is together, there are 15 (and counting). I originally wanted 2 identical 30" stoves which would give me 8 burners and 2 ovens. (I thought it was a simple request, but I didn't think about the required 60" of space they'd need, and we can't find 60" of cooking space except for a wall that would be 15 feet away from the sink.) So I'm trying to figure out my next best option. I've been cooking on a 4 burner 30" stove with only 6 feet of counter space for so long that I can't figure out how much more space would really make sense. Obviously, bigger sounds better, but I like simple and efficient more. So, cooktop/oven space to mouth ratio?

P.S. One of the biggest frustrations on a 30" cooktop is that one of my cast iron pans and one of my pots takes up so much surface area that I can't fit any other pot/pan. So I have 4 burners but can only use 2 or 3 at a time.

Comments (15)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    A 36" Wolf induction cooktop has one burner suitable for large (5 qt) pans, and four smaller ones. I can easily use the big one and still have the others usable. For an oven I have a Bluestar french door wall oven (holds a full size commercial pan). The advantages are that there is no bending over and the doors don't stick out as much so there is more room for me to work. For counter space, I have a 42" Rachiele sink which lets me do most of the prep work in the sink (really cuts down on the mess). For baking prep, I have a 30"x70" mobile baker's table. For me that is better than an island because with an island the limited space I have would allow little room to move around in. It also gives me a home for the grain grinder and mixer.

  • 9 years ago

    For kitchen design help and many eyes and brains coming up with clever solutions, try posting your floorplan in the Kitchens forum.

    Is there anywhere on the available wall to put a secondary sink?

    How much room do you have if you have your range in your preferred location near the sink. There are ranges like the 48" Thermador that give you plenty of burners, a large and a small oven. That might be plenty for your daily needs. The two 30" ranges/60" span is less expensive, as you said, but by the time you make other modifications, might end up costing the same.

    Don't forget ventilation. A 60" cookspace requires a 66" wide hood.

    For managing more cooking with less range, look into alternatives like the immersion sous vide circulator. Put one in a camping cooler with water, vacuum seal your meat, and let it bubble away at low temperature, without worrying much about the timing. Excellent, juicing meat, and saves your ovens for baking, casseroles, etc. There are also portables like the Nesco roaster or catering ovens, which can be set up in places that aren't needed when there's company, like on top of the dryer or a desk.

  • 9 years ago

    I don't regularly cook for the number of people that you cook for. But I have been known to throw large dinner parties. I find, even in the best case scenario, I simply can't keep more than 4 burners in active use. I just don't have that kind of attention span.

    I do hear you though on wanting more space for big pots. So, yes, a 36" RNB would be awesome. We have a 30" RNB which I love. But I do (on rare occasions) hit its limits. My main issue is that I regularly use the big round-bottom wok for both Asian and Western style cooking. It's one of my favorite pots. But it blocks some of the adjacent space.

    I also really love the big oven cavity in the Bluestar range. Fitting full size cookie sheets (or two half-size next to each other) is a game changer.

    What I really do want though is more oven space. I find with large complex meals, I regularly start cooking on the stove top and then move the pot(s) to the oven. I currently, I only have the single oven in our range, and that has been a limiting factor many times.

    For example, as we speak, my oven has been in use for hours today. First for proofing dough, and now for baking my sourdough bread. If I was planning any serious cooking today, that simply couldn't happen.

    In our kitchen remodel, we'll gain a combination steam oven and a speed oven. I fully expect to make regular use of these additional ovens. And I am excited to have a combination of both large and small oven cavities, and a combination of different feature sets.

    For a while, I thought I should get the 48" BlueStar. But I soon realized that a) I didn't really have the space, and b) my real motivation was to get additional ovens. So, might as well embrace this decision.

  • 9 years ago

    As suggested if you're redoing your kitchen post your plan on the kitchen forum. They may have some ideas on how best to get a larger cooktop.

    Are you doing gas or induction?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    wekick, I was just looking at the BlueStar. I love using cast iron, so that may be a good fit for us. But the open burner tray worries me a little for cleaning. I often have a couple of extra hands in the kitchen and they aren't always as neat as I'd like them to be. Are they hard to clean?

    Our oven is used for a pretty big variety of things - from heating leftovers for lunch to baking cookies and pies and bread, roasting vegetables, roasting meats, broiling when it isn't grill season (we live in Maine), making pizza, keeping things warm... and probably other things I'm not thinking of because I just do it. I do get frustrated with our oven because there's only one and if I put one large pan in, nothing else heats well, so I have to rotate. It isn't too big of a deal because I just do it mostly without thinking, but it's harder when there are extra people that I want to visit with rather than attending the oven.

  • 9 years ago

    Jerry Jorgenson that sounds like a great setup! I'll look at the BlueStar ovens. We have to put ours under counter, so a regular wall oven is out, but the french door openings that save a bit of room would be nice.

    We're putting in a 33" single bowl sink. I probably won't do any prep in it, but I'm really looking forward to that one big bowl. We're going to keep our small island for extra prep space (18"x38"). It's what has saved me these last years that we've been slowly working on our renovation and I like that it's an extra landing zone for prep items or for actual prep. I'm going to move my antique gate leg table into the space after we're done and use it for baking when I need it, and fold it down when I don't. I really like having flexibility with the prep spaces. But I'm pretty jealous of your space for the grain grinder. I haven't figured out where to put that one yet. :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    plllog

    I'll try to figure out how to post my floor plan. Thanks for the suggestion.

    We can put a secondary sink in on a different wall, but it would still be about 10 feet away. I really like having the sink and stove on the same plane or at a right angle to the sink so I don't have to worry about carrying boiling water around people who are in the kitchen. So it still isn't ideal.

    The space for the preferred location is only about 45" wide, so even if I squeezed in a 48" range I'd have problems with the hood, so I'm back to the wall that's farthest from the sink.

    I'll have to look up all the options you mentioned for alternative cooking. They're all new to me! Thanks for the suggestions!

  • 9 years ago

    M

    I think you're probably right - I don't really need more burners, but I need those burners to be big enough. I always use 2, often 3 (and need to shuffle pans because the burners aren't big enough) and sometimes 4. I don't know that I've ever wished for a higher number of burners, but for them to be big enough to do the job.
    Extra oven space would be luxurious! I can't even imagine having 2 ovens, but there are, like you said, some days where the oven is being used for something so the meals need to be planned to avoid the oven. I love the old wood cook stoves that had multiple ovens for different applications. We had one once and it was really fun to use. I keep asking for another one, but ... space limits us.


    I don't know what a speed oven is. :) So many new things for me to look into!
    Sounds like you're working on a fun renovation too!

  • 9 years ago

    Are you the type of person that needs their stove to always look like on the first day? Then, cast iron grates are going to be frustrating. On the other hand, if you proudly embrace the natural patina that builds up on cast iron with use, then you'll love open burners.

    Just wipe them off with a damp cloth and they're clean. All the debris falls into the tray and you only need to clean it occasionally. If you line the tray with aluminum foil, it's very quick to take care off.

    Just don't pull the tray out so far that you remove it. That can damage the linear ball bearings. Our cleaning person did that and then forced it back in. Now it moves much harder than it should

  • 9 years ago

    cpartist

    I'll try to post the layout and the options we've considered. It's always nice to get other's perspective on things.

    We're doing a gas cooktop (propane). Our oven is also gas currently, though I'm not locked into that.

  • 9 years ago

    M

    "Are
    you the type of person that needs their stove to always look like on
    the first day?"
    - Definitely not! I have 7 children! ;) I'm okay with patina, but dirt makes me a little twitchy.

    "Just don't pull the tray out so far that you remove it."
    - Is there a stopper or anything to help prevent it from being pulled out too far? Or does it just keep going?

  • 9 years ago

    The issue with the drip tray is less severe than it sounds. There is extra resistance when you try to pull it out all the way. And you can in fact remove it and put it back, if you are careful. But you wouldn't normally have any reason to do so, as there are inserts that come out nicely as soon as you pull the tray just a little bit. And the inserts are what you need to clean every couple of weeks (or months...).

    The problem was with my cleaning person who completely ignore all of that, pulled hard to get the tray out all the way, and then unfortunately forced it back in instead of inserting it more carefully. This is mostly a public service announcement that if you have somebody come clean your house, let them know about how to do it properly.

    I now attached a label that you see when you start pulling out the tray instructing the cleaning people to be more careful.

  • 9 years ago

    You mentioned "gas cooktop". This might just be you being casual in how you worded things. But in general, I find that range tops are better than cook tops. You don't waste space for controls, you don't burn yourself reaching over pots in order to get to the controls, and in the case of Bluestar, you only get the open burners when you pick a range top instead of a cook top.

    From what you have been saying so far, I would suggest a 36" RNB range. That gives you a bigger surface to work on. It gives you up to six burners, even if you usually wouldn't need them. It gives you the easy clean up of open burners. And if you want to experiment, it gives you the ability to use a round-bottom wok -- something that I personally really love to cook in (make sure you get the matching spatula and lid!)

    In addition, I'd suggest you get a combination steam oven. That gives you the second oven that you would really benefit from. But more importantly, it gives you a lot of nice options for fast unattended cooking of large quantities of meat, vegetables or rice (all at the same time, too). And it supposedly does a much better job at heating up food than microwaves do -- it sounded as that was a feature you could benefit from.

    Miele has a plumbed steam oven, so you don't always need to refill the water canister. That might be a good fit for you. They also have a model with an extra big cavity. Not sure if you need that, as steam ovens tend to allow denser packing than other types of ovens. But with 7+ eaters, you might want it. It does get expensive though. There always is a downside to these decisions...

  • 9 years ago

    This is a video that a poster here made about cleaning the BS. He has a French top on his. Cleaning is a very subjective thing. I would prefer the rangetop over the cooktop mainly because the controls are on the front of the rangetop leaving more room. The terminology of "open" burners can get confusing the way it is used by the manufacturers. If you look at the BS website they say the cooktop has "open" burners but what they mean is that the burners are uncapped which is a feature that many like about a gas burner. The burner tray is sealed. The cast iron on the RNB will develop a seasoning like your pans if you want it too. As said above, you can put foil over the pull out trays.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3K2DR2ub1sA&sns=em

    In deciding how many burners, the 30", 4 burner will have wider grates than the 36", 6 burner. I do like having 6 burners and have used all of them. You can always get a couple of induction hobs to add if you need more burners occasionally.

    BS also has the RCS model with burners that are star shaped, uncapped and with an open burner tray but less BTUs @ 15K. Additional BTUs will allow you to heat faster especially something like big pots of water for pasta. It is also great for stirfrying. The also have a range with capped, round burners with a sealed tray but I would stick with a star shaped burner with your cast iron pans.

    Do you use a griddle?

    As for ovens, if you are used to a gas oven, the RNB/RCS range would be more of a consideration. Both the 30" and 36" inch will hold full commercial tray or two half sheets. The 36" would have a longer preheat time.

    The broilers on these are very different from a regular gas broiler. They are much hotter and even but smaller so look at that.

    If you get a second oven, BS does make a gas wall oven but I would consider an electric oven of some type. There are many options though and this can be the most complicated decision to make as there are big differences between gas and electric ovens. There are big differences even in electric ovens. Have you used convection? I would love a combi oven but for me it would have to be a third oven because I need the space in a regular oven.

    I would post your layout as others have mentioned here and over in the kitchen forum.

    A really helpful book for me was

    A Complete Guide to Kitchen Design with Cooking in Mind https://www.amazon.com/dp/0932767095/ref=cm_sw_r_sms_c_api_NSIxzb9TQBJ3Z

    He has some different ideas. I incorporated several in my kitchen.

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions