Software
Houzz Logo Print
raymondranch

Is this a white pine?

9 years ago

There are two of these in my son's yard. Someone on the landscape design forum thought they might be white pine which would mean they will outgrow their spot by ALOT! I thought she said the needles would be in groups of three to five? I am seeing two in a group?

Comments (8)

  • 9 years ago

    I didn't see my post right away here so I posted on the tree forum instead. I guess it just took a few minutes for my post to show up! How large would a dwarf Scots Pine get?


  • 9 years ago

    Depends on the cultivar...good rule of thumb though is to look at the average annual growth over the last 3-5 years and project forward. Dwarf conifers can, in great age, achieve large dimensions but at a MUCH slower rate (they usually die of old age or something else first however).

    raymondranch thanked Smivies (Ontario - 5b)
  • 9 years ago

    first look to the leader on top .. and see how much it grew this spring .. that would be its vertical annual growth rate ...


    and then look at any side branch .. and see how much that grew this spring ... that is the lateral annual growth .. and a bit lesser than vertical ... hence the natural xmas tree shape


    saying its dwarf.. just means those growth rates are lesser than the straight species ...


    one last clue ... this year new bark.. will look different than last years bark.. and 3 years back etc ... so you can gauge every years growth ...


    all conifers shed older needles ... in 1 to 3 years cycles.. depending on type ... so you can clean out any interior brown leaves ...


    the one fact you leave out.. how close to the house it is.. or how much space it has ... so we cant opine as to how fast or when it might outgrow a space ...


    ken



    raymondranch thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 9 years ago

    There is one on each side of the driveway. I will find a picture....

  • 9 years ago

    i would just plan on getting rid of them ...when is up to you ...


    besides.. arent they a PIA for seeing traffic or children on the sidewalk when backing up ...


    i would not waste time and effort trying to move them .. and i have a lot of experience with moving conifers ... [read that.. they all died.. lol]


    ken

    raymondranch thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 9 years ago

    They probably are a hazard for backing up. We have successfully transplanted two ponderosa pines from our ditch but they were very small when we dug them. We tried again with three more and they all died. I am pretty sure we waited too far into the summer with the last three. I am sure you are correct that these would not transplant well, which is a shame because I have room for them at my place! I like the idea given on the landscape design forum to cut one each at Christmas and use it for our tree :)

  • 9 years ago

    the cement is the problem.. when trying to dig a huge plant from next to it ... i would not want to see that collapsing in a few years.. as the fill dirt settles.. eh ...


    conifers .. since they dont loose their leaves.. are transplanted in fall or at ground thaw in spring ... so they have a cool season.. or two ... to get the roots pumping before the next hot season ...


    and with trees.. the root mass you cant see can be 2 or 3 times what you see above ... so consider what you will cut off in trying to move it ... and hoping it doesnt shed all those needles trying to survive...


    frankly.. at that size.. i just isnt worth it.. short of a large truck with a tree spade on it.. and then you are back to the cement collapsing ...


    ken

    raymondranch thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5