Software
Houzz Logo Print
thomas_anderson72

Liquid aeration vs core aeration?

9 years ago

Can someone please help settle this debate?

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago

    Core.

  • 9 years ago

    Merriam Webster: Aerate: to supply or impregnate (something, such as the soil or a liquid) with air.

    How does adding a liquid do that?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Surfactant.

    Some homeowners have started treating their lawns with cheap, generic baby shampoo (no ABX soaps) before deep watering to help the water penetrate even deeper.

    Supposedly, the cumulative effect (when you do 2-3 treatments in a row) is more effective than coring?

    https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=shampoo+lawn+aeration

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/3385626/how-does-baby-shampoo-help-my-lawn

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/1541138/aerating-vs-shampooing

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/3762294/no-aeration-baby-shampoo-but-whats-next

    Some video had core comparison samples revealing moist dirt at a deeper level with liquid aeration than core aeration.

  • 9 years ago

    If you're a proponent of the "Butterfly Effect" theory, I suppose there may be some truth to be found in liquid aeration. Of coarse plant roots are the greatest builders of soil health - tilth, peds, aerification.

    Fertilizer promotes root growth.

    Greater HOC promotes deeper rooting.

    So I guess someone could coin the terms "Ferti-aeration" or "Mower Aeration." Come to think of it, I better get those terms copyrighted. :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thanks! After watching this video and considering all your points, I'm sold.

    It's much cheaper and much easier to do yourself than lugging around a 250lb coring machine to/from Home Depot. My lawn has really thick thatch as well, although it's not as compacted as seen in the video.

    Plus, this video demonstrates that we can easily test this ourselves, which is what I plan to do:

    1. Take a solo cup and drill or poke a hole in the bottom.
    2. Seal the hole with tape.
    3. Fill the cup with water.
    4. Pull the tape off and let the water drain into the lawn.
    5. Time how long it takes for the water to fully penetrate.
    6. Repeat with soapy water and let it drain on a dry patch next to the original patch of lawn.
    7. See which session absorbed water faster.

    It's so simple, I can't believe I hadn't thought about doing this before.

  • 9 years ago

    There is a difference between core aeration due to compaction and water's ability to penetrate soil due to thatch layer. Be mindful of what your trying to solve. No surfactant will relieve compaction.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Well said owlnsr.

    In addition to the importance of knowing what issue you want to remedy, one needs to understand what "tools' can actually remedy the issue.

    Soap (shampoo) can improve water penetration and will act as a soil wetting agent, but it will do nothing to improve soil air space (aerification). The active ingredient ( sodium lauryl sulfate) was used in commercial wetting agents in the 70's and 80's but was discontinued due to its short period of useful action (a couple of days). Surfactants like sodium lauryl sulfate can adversely affect reproduction and growth of soil organisms including worms. In addition, many surfactants can concentrate trace nutrient levels producing phytotoxicity.

    Using the proper commercial wetting agent can produce a number of turf benefits (aerification isn't one of them), but at over $15/k, most residential lawn owners take a pass. (and NO, shampoo is not remotely similar to commercial wetting agents/surfacants--not even remotely)

    The correct process of aerifying a lawn should be a completely separate topic for addressing a multitude of different issues beyond just counteracting hydrophobic soils improving soil moisture levels.

    These are all tools. Know when to use a hammer and when to use a saw. Some people on this site only see their favorite magic hammer and everything becomes a nail.

  • 9 years ago

    Ridgerunner-

    What do you recommend for compacted soil?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Where I live (Central VA, outside Richmond) shrink/swell soil is common. When wet, the soil will expand... and when dry, the soil will contract. During the summer, any type of compaction will become exacerbated if there is not a ground cover protecting the surface from the sunlight. It's quite amazing, really.

    My wife and I have a large dog, and for about a month, we also had her boss' dog as our houseguest. The two dogs would do dog stuff... running, playing, and generally putting stress on the turf in the summer heat. Some thin areas developed as a result, exposing some of the soil surface to the sunlight.

    Once this occurred, it was game over for those areas. Within a few weeks... those areas became harder than cement. I now have islands of concrete. The soil has compacted and become so tight that the roots of the remaining grass in the thin spots have been squeezed to death. All life is dead in those areas. It's not that compaction caused the issues... it's that the soil was exposed to sun, which caused constriction.

    Just a few inches away, the areas that didn't thin out from the dog activity are lush and thick; I can easily drive a screwdriver down as deep as it will go into the soil without exerting any pressure. The very fact that the ground cover (aka turf canopy) protects the surface from sunlight is a MAJOR component to a healthy lawn.

    To Ridgerunner's point... it's about knowing what tool to use. It's also about knowing IF a tool even should be used. In this case, a surfactant will not help me. Neither will core aeration. The direct sunlight has baked the soil into hard pan. No roots will take there. Without a ground cover, there is no hope.

    Now, I could try to cover the spot with a mulch, which certainly would protect the soil from the summer sunlight and retain moisture... but then I'd have mulch in the middle of my lawn. The only other thing I can do, really, is wait until the summer is over, loosen those spots with a cultivator, add some compost, and then reseed.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Here is an article that reviews the history of wetting agents/sufactants and some results of testing of each development. It includes information about effectiveness, toxicity, duration of benefits and side benefits such as reduced disease incidence and lower seed head development on some grasses.

    Over the last 50 years manufacturers have made many advances in the chemistry creating valuable benefits. Yes, the cost seems a bit high for a home lawn (about $15/k), but its benefits in water and disease reduction in addition to improved overall turf health due to reduced stress for a two year period can make it a viable option depending on the situation and product (for soil wetting-not aeration) in my opinion.

    B G thanked User