Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_39354396

Feeling better about kitchen planning but...

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

So in my last post, I was nearing a (figurative) nervous breakdown. The contractor I liked but then had a concern about met with me again and was able to allay my worries over using him. So it looks like that is who I will use to install my kitchen. However, he is using a designer from a home center to develop the kitchen plan. That designer (who is retiring this week after 35 years on the job) is trying to talk me out of using a mid-tone to darker stained cabinet on the island and a lighter (creamy white) painted cabinet on the perimeter. He said he doesn't think it would look right to combine stained and painted cabinets. Now I know I have seen many photos with the two combined but he is really pushing pretty hard to go with all stained or all painted, even if using two different colors. The contractor agrees with the designer.

What do you think about his objection and how this fits into my choice of contractor?

Comments (14)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Your contractor should do what you say, not voice his opinion on finishes. I definitely wouldn't be taking anything that designer said seriously, and I would be pursuing other options there. Bad news for him if your contractor can't get on board.

  • 9 years ago

    It's your kitchen so your desire is the important thing. I have dark stained island and white painted perimeters. It hasn't imploded. {recovering from laughter fit, dabbing at the water I spewed everywhere!} I couldn’t agree more with beachem and Gennifer B.


    Just posted and I think it’s quite lovely: [New Kitchen Reveal[(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/new-kitchen-reveal-dsvw-vd~4779413)


    If you like your GC, would he be willing to work with another KD who isn’t retiring this week (that would concern me if questions/issues arise other than the paint/stain choices)? I’m also going with light painted perimeters, darker stained island. Here’s hoping my kitchen also won’t implode… : -)

  • 9 years ago

    Yea, the retiring thing bothers me a bit too. I met the lady who is replacing him and she seems to know what she is talking about, but this is a "small-town" place and does not always have the most forward thinking frame of mind.

    My contractor also is trying to talk me into tile floors rather than continuing our hardwood into the kitchen, but I love the feeling that one type of flooring gives to a home. He is suggesting using a hardwood look-alike tile next to real hardwood. I can't agree with that one.

  • 9 years ago

    I'm still baffled by this. It's so common now. My last kitchen had white perimeter with stained island, and my new one will, as well. How old is this designer?

  • 9 years ago

    Hmm. I'm liking your contractor less and less.

  • 9 years ago

    I agree Gennifer B. He is 70 and on his way out. It sort of floored me. I see so many beautiful combos.

    Still trying to decide if I should do darker on the island and all lowers with light uppers or darker on the island with all light uppers and lowers.


  • 9 years ago

    I know Gennifer. But I do like the guy, his work is good and reasonably priced, but I don't like all of his ideas.

  • 9 years ago

    Is it normal for contractors to do that? I'm working with my first one right now... he doesn't. I also live in a small town, in fact, my contractor and I went to HS together. He helps when I have logistical questions, but certainly isn't volunteering opinions or trying to get me to change my mind on finishes.

  • 9 years ago

    I do appreciate that he is offering alternatives and don't think he will fight me once my decision is final. But it makes me second guess myself.

    These are some combos I am considering:

    Bertch Driftwood with Snowflake.



    Bertch Shale with Snowflake or Oyster White.


    Wellborn Drift with Pebble



    The flooring shows another option for the patterned tile rather than the hardwood shown in the other photos.

    Am I crazy or do they work?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Why are you allowing your contractor to dictate your design choices ands choose they KD? He's supposed to DO THE WORK and that's all! You need to find another contractor and another KD. This is a disaster in the making...

  • 9 years ago

    Anglophilia, I think I am just looking for confirmation that I am not nuts (which this planning is making me). I will do what I want in the end and the contractor will as well. He works with the KD through a local home center.

    What do you think of the color combos above?

  • 9 years ago

    Katie66: you have to take contractors' style/decorating opinions with a "grain of salt"... most are men with a male perspective. I am not trying to be offensive since there are men who have awesome "eyes" and decorating tastes...I envy people with that skill since I struggle...I'm not hopeless but it does not come easy or naturally. Those gifted men, I think, are the exception not the rule. I would feel sorry for the remodeling women who took my husband's opinion on decorating, colors, or finishes...he is opinionated, for sure, since he knows what he likes; but that does not make it stylish, practical, or put together.

    I will share an example. My husband was not convinced that a counter height bathroom vanity really was acceptable practice 30+ years after we last picked out a vanity. He asked every workman (contractor, carpenter, plumber and electrician) who came into the house what they thought. The consensus was that they had never heard of such a thing in 2015! Good grief! The next time we went to a big-box store, I pulled out my trusted tape measure and pointed out the unreliability of his "experts."

    You have done your research...they have not! Come here for awesome input if it helps validate your vision.

  • 9 years ago

    You do not want a kitchen designer that is retiring next week. It's quite simple; you are going to need your KD much further into the process than his retirement will allow. I'm kind of shocked your GC hasn't shifted his business to another KD.

    As far as your cabinet idea of mixing stained and painted cabinetry, that's popular. I think you're dealing with someone who is set in his ways and is pushing his aesthetics onto you. Tell your GC to find another KD to work with, or find your own.

    When we did our remodel we taught our GC, KD, and carpenters about new trends and ideas. They are busy tackling the current job and trying to secure the next. Unless someone brings things into their sphere they are not aware of newer options.