Your fireplace and floor are going to clue you in about which one will look best. If you've narrowed your choices down to those three, get samples, paint up some testers and take a look at how the colors work with the FP and floor.

samples of Pale Oak and Halo look blue/puplish!?? what now? :( looking for a white with warm brown undertones. years ago we loved a color called Buckwheat by martha stewart. Read Baby Fawn may neutralize the yellow floors?

You can order a sample of Buckwheat H02 by MS from My Perfect Color .

If it ends up that's the one you want, you can take the hand-painted sample to the paint store and ask for a custom mix.

Hi! Maybe something like SW Shoji White? Glidden has a shade called Natural Wicker that is similar to Buckwheat Flour, but is lighter and could stand as a warm white. I still have tons of those old Martha Stewart color cards from her paint line! Your example pic looks like it could be the popular BM Edgecomb Gray, maybe you could try a sample of that and see what undertone it pulls in your room? With the one window you might not be getting a ton of natural light though. Good luck with your search!

We are having the same problem! We tried pale oak and classic gray and revere pewter and are getting lots of wierd undertones from all of them. I’m not giving up yet!!

@mom2co, you didn't like Edgecomb gray?

What about BM Balboa Mist?

I used BM Natural Cream - also a greige. Not sure it's warm enough for what you're looking for...

Manchester Tan might be a good option for you.

Could try BM Ballet White or Feather Down.

Sherwin williams Wool Skein worked for me

what color did you go with? I have the situation and the same colors in my living room.

What is that original color on your walls? I love it - I want it!

Ballet White is not warm. It reads as a soft yellow in my home.