Thanks so much for your help, Ironwood Builders! I've been searching online but have yet to find an exact match, but I haven't had a lot of time to put into it. I'm hoping my husband can get more information from the owners. They haven't lived there all that long and may not know. The roofer was baffled, so that has me worried. The house is near the top of our price limit and we already have to convert a bath to make it more accessible for my mom and a few other little updates, so having to replace the roof in the near future would be a bummer. Do you see that little valley between the two front gables? That is one of the areas that has leaked in the past. We are in S. Louisiana and get tons of rain and occasionally hurricanes, so I need a strong roof.

Try these guys? http://www.interlockroofing.com/ I think a careful removal of the existing shingles in the area of the two valleys and a new "cricket" that diverts water more rapidly would be possible without removing the entire roof.

Great house! I found a home online with a similar new roof. Check it out for the roof only. http://abcseamlessnc.wordpress.com/2011/06/16/metal-roofing-with-a-whole-new-style-in-currituck-27929/

Thanks Dullea and Associates Inc.!

Glad to help. Were you able to find a similar roofing product for this house?