Software
Houzz Logo Print
marzik

Cottage cathedral ceiling - which way to install tongue-in-groove pine?

13 years ago
last modified: 13 years ago
Dear design friends,
We are ready to complete the ceiling of our cottage, which cathedral ceiling (see pictures) is nicely insulated and ready for the next step. All interior walls are also pine (running horizontally). We plan to lay the pine vertically (which is somewhat dictated by the fact that the joists are running horizontally) and we are trying to select among a few options. Which would you pick? What design is best to draw the eye upwards and enhance the design?

1. Unbroken expanses of staggered planks, something like the ceiling in http://st.houzz.com/simgs/a9e123d60d2c9aff_8-5176/traditional-living-room.jpg but with the planks running perpendicular to the wall
2. Unbroken 8 foot sections coming down from the peak (nicely ending at the joist), a pine trim to hide the joint, and then 10 foot sections continuing down until the wall starts, and another trim to hide that joint too.
3. Like 2, above, but with 3 lines of trim, say, at 4 feet, 8 feet, and 12 feet. Like this one only sideways: http://st.houzz.com/simgs/ff61b4020f86e923_8-0178/eclectic-bedroom.jpg

In my uploaded pictures, you'll see the ceiling, the large wall with windows that faces the lake and has a sliding door to the deck, and also a highlight of how some of the wall pine meets the loft and railing. We plan to put simple pine around all the windows, by the way. p.s. we are installing a hanging, 3-blade fan from the ridge vent (you'll see an electrical box there).

I welcome your ideas! We start the work next week!

Comments (13)

  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I've dealt with this a few times and vote for 1) staggered. You could also add strapping and go horizontally. It is a little extra work up front but it is easier to install the T&G horizontally (each piece can sit on the one below) so you get your time back.
  • 13 years ago
    Mary, any chance you or your contractor can do a mock-up of your choices, say a 4' square or so? We're lucky to have a contractor who's only too happy to do mock-ups and leave us to mull them overnight, or over a weekend, and it's been hugely helpful.
  • 13 years ago
    Of the choices you presented # 3 is the winner for me.

    I would like to throw an idea your way….with all that wood, that grand ceiling, would you consider sheet rocking the ceiling and using the natural wood for dramatic beams?
    Family Room · More Info
  • 13 years ago
    Thanks for the comments so far! J, and Bubbly, we *are* the contractor, so a) adding new strapping and changing the pine orientation is possible but extra work! and b) absolutely, we can mock up a few samples, for sure. Judyg, sorry, this is my husband's "dream" cottage so we're pretty well committed to pine. I'm going with the flow for now: it can certainly be painted in the future if we decide we need a change. (The bedrooms do have pine walls and pine ceiling and they do look fine. We have a very dark flooring, which helps.) Meanwhile, we have a schedule: we are renting scaffolding for 2 weeks and have some helpers coming, so we've got to get at least the very high stuff done while it is all onsite.
  • 13 years ago
    Wow - good for you (two), Mary - that's quite the challenge! Hope it goes well for you, and looking forward to the after photos, and sorry not to be more helpful :)
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    You guys did a great job installing the insulation, a rarity and often missed opportunity when remodeling. I typically find a lot of air leaks (energy leaks) in T and G ceilings so I would try to seal as many of the gaps and cracks especially at the gable ends, peak, and rafter tails as you do your install. Good luck with your project.
  • 13 years ago
    Thanks, Harding C&SS. We welcome any tips you have. We are a little nervous about this part, as we are not that comfortable on scaffolding. That is why we are thinking that option 3 above might a) look very nice, as there won't be any joints showing, and b) be easier to do, as handling 4 foot pieces of pine up on a scaffold might be easier than 8 or 10 or 12 foot pieces! We have indeed put expandable foam in all those crevasses around the windows too,by the way. We're trying!
  • 13 years ago
    Everyone, another question: should we leave the pine UNSTAINED, UNVARNISHED completely (bearing in mind that in the loft, people may leave handprints etc.) or to Stain/Varnish? If the latter, which we are leaning towards, we are planning only varnish. Natural colour. Do you agree? (The floor is a dark brown)
  • 13 years ago
    Given there will be some sticky hands, I'd be inclined to put a finish on it, yes. An oil-based finish will eventually encourage the pine to yellow over time, whereas a water-based finish generally leaves the wood its protecting a more natural colour. Can you get away with putting a finish on the walls only, and not the vaulted ceilings - that'd save you a lot of sweat equity! I wouldn't stain it, but I'm not generally a fan of wood stains, so ymmv.
  • 13 years ago
    Hello everyone, I thought I would update you on the work that transpired. I varnished (water-based, semi-gloss) the pine ceiling boards in advance of installation, and we have installed them with a staggered look. We're still finishing the work but the result is now available for your view. See the attached photos!
  • 12 years ago
    It is beautiful! You did an amazing job!
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks! we just love it, and the interior work is all done. I posted a thread also about our kitchen colours, and now the kitchen is done too.