Without seeing the balloon trick or a Photoshop simulation, I would guess the larger ones would work better. It’s a big space, and the clear glass will tend to have less visual presence than a solid form. The shape is more interesting, as well! Lovely space. The finish line is in sight!

I really like the second one!

I get the light and airy instinct, but you have 14’ ceilings. You need a little there there. I would think about continuing your black lighting with cluster pendants or another modern, urban loft type of lighting that can double as a sculptural element for the space.

We like the second one better!

You better post more pictures when it's all done! :)

I like the branch chandelier suggested but since you already have the electrical for 3 pendants, I would go with the larger. 12 inches is going to look way too small in that large space!

There's also a 12" Dome version

I love the idea of the Modern Wire Weave Pendant that benjesbride suggested. I agree that the clear glass would get lost in that room.

I have a few thoughts to add. No pole, I suggest you use black chain or cord. Poles are for fans! Not gold, you don't want to make the chain/cord a focal point. I love the second pendant, but not for your kitchen. I think the size of 17" combined with the curves is just not the right look. A fixture with more straight lines goes better with your kitchen. I think the 12" globe is too small and does not have enough height. Also, the wattage is so important, so please make sure you have enough! I think the fact that you have 3 fixtures is better when your kitchen is asymmetrical, as yours is. It gets tricky with 2. Ask me how I know! Haha!

Of the two clear pendants I like the second better. However, I would not do them. As mentioned the clear glass, even with those Edison light bulbs, blinds you. Also think of cleaning the glass when they get dusty, buggy, and greasy every month or so to keep them looking nice. Too much work unless you have a house keeper you would pay to do it. Every time you unscrew the glass globe and take it down to wash in the sink is a two man job and is a chance of breaking them. I like benjesbrides choice.

Here’s a mock up best I can of them.

Gennifer, go online and checkout the Kichler Deco Pendant. No cleaning issues. I think it would look great. I'll message when I see other options. Here is another one by Kischler in Matte black.

Kishler Taubert pendant - love it.

Maybe look at wooden pendants to tip the look more toward rustic? https://www.wayfair.com/lighting/pdp/light-living-sula-1-light-bowl-pendant-lilv1240.html

We've got a very similar set up with two islands and going with Kichler 14" pendants similar to your choices. $178 per pendant at Lighting direct dot com.

Lighting direct has a ton of pendants and Kichler makes very good products.

https://www.lightingdirect.com/kichler-42046-everly-single-light-14-wide-pendant-with-clear-blown-glass-shade/p1993417?source=gg-gba-dyn_1993417!c425128889!a28732651169!cr225890535314!tboomuserlist%3A%3A5859689!plwww.pensacolafishingforum.com!dc!nd&CAWELAID=120135400003147566&CAGPSPN=dyn&CAAGID=28732651169&CATCI=aud-74846923529&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIvO6P96qs1wIVCGjBCh0k-wO6EAEYASACEgLejPD_BwE

Thanks for all the input, guys! I did end up ordering the Flynn pendants. The hood is my focal point, and will have artwork on it, which is why an unobtrusive glass pendant was what I was looking for. :)

@Hillside House - could you share any pics? Thanks.