Software
Houzz Logo Print
cptk1

What To Do With Cuttings

9 years ago

Bottom line up front is that I seem to have successfully rooted Ashe Juniper (AKA Mountain Cedar)* in my Aerogarden. The question now is, how should I proceed to give these guys the best chance of survival long term? In the past I have been successful with cuttings only to lose the plant in the subsequent stages. I'm thinking I should maybe just grow these things in the Aerogarden all winter as long as they don't start growing too big.


Additional backstory: Got an Aerogarden as a gift. Did the herb growing thing. Aerogarden sat in the garage for a while. Bought a property lot that is mostly covered in trees, but has a clearing where the property meets the adjacent one. Decided I wanted to try to propagate the existing trees and plant them along the property line. Reasons are two-fold: 1. I'm cheap and enjoy propagating plants; and 2. there is only about 6 inches of soil before you hit caliche, and from my research this is one of the few trees that tolerates such conditions. Remembered the Aerogarden and here we are.


*Yes, I know this tree is hated by many. Mostly because of allergies, but many people also claim that it consumes excessive amounts of water. To be honest, I actually thought the trees were cypress trees when I first decided to do this. At any rate, this entire town is already covered in cedar trees, including my lot. Construction of the house I'm building there will result in the removal of many more adult trees than the 3 or 4 (if they even survive) that I'll be planting along the property line. I'm sorry if anyone is offended by this.

Comments (14)

  • 9 years ago

    offended by what .... ??


    can you link us to your gizmo ... is it just the little counter top thingee??


    if they have roots ... i would probably pot them and try rooting more ... but then.. do you have a bigger light stand???


    also ... where are you.. is outdoors in winter an option???


    see pic for how i potted up some rootings ... and then i put them into my light stand ... for the rest of winter ...


    trees are not aquatics ... and i would fear that you will end up with root rots in an all water system for an extended period ... but then.. i dont really know what your Aerogarden is .. more info in that regard ....plz


    ken



  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm in the Austin area. I could put them in containers but then I'd be looking at them spending the winter outside because I don't have other grow lights besides what's attached to the Aerogarden. Texas doesn't exactly have harsh winters, but I'm worried about a tiny cutting being thrown outside like that. What do you think?

    Yeah, it's just a little tabletop hydroponics system for growing herbs and such. I have the one that accommodates 6 plants.


    Theoretically you should be able to grow anything in a hydroponics system without the roots rotting, but this isn't exactly a professional hydroponics set up. It's basically just a pan of water with an air stone in it.


    http://www.aerogarden.com/

  • 9 years ago

    trees are not aquatics.. nor are they water loving veg .... you are correct about theory.. vs reality ...


    i know nothing about TX ... maybe someone else will chime in ...


    but even if you wanted to move them outside ... you would have to harden them off to all variables.. moving them from indoors to out ...


    too bad they werent rooted by sept.. and you could have moved them out in fall ...


    if nothing else.. and they stay in your gizmo ... and they end up there all winter.. plz report back and let us know what reality ended up being ... we learn more thru our failures.. than we usually do thru easy success ...


    ken

  • 9 years ago

    This whole experiment might need to be scrapped. Another thing I didn't know when I started this is that this tree has separate male and female specimens. So I could have avoided the whole pollen issue by taking cuttings of only female trees. As it stands, I have no idea if these cuttings are male or female. I suppose I could wait and see, and then maybe graft a female onto any males? I dunno. It's a pretty interesting experiment with the Aerogarden anyway.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't think you are crazy. I Like a mature old Mountain ash cedar. The young ones , not so much.

    The pollen is wind born for MILES and MILES so it does not really matter if they are male or female. Did you take the cuttings off a male or female tree. I have a ZILLION Mountai ashe Juniper trees on my property out by Hamilton pool road that you are welcomed to dig up if your cutting fails. Also I do not know hoe to sex a small tree, but the digging is hard rocky work.. I can only tell them apart once they start to berry or put out pollen. Spanish Oak, Escarpement Black Cherry, Lote tree, Elbow, tree, madrone, redbud, Live oak , Texas Mountain Laurel, all like the dirt situation that you mentioned. I know because I have the same dirt situation. I am high in the uplands on young limestone. That also makes a difference. Madrone prefers young limestone. They say that Bur Oak, chinquapin Oak , Cedar elm like it too but I don'r know about that. I thought that Chincapin and Bur oak liked more soil. Chincapin likes the canyons around here.

    Maybe you arte having failure because the water rooted plants need a more humid transition from water to dirt. I do all my rooting in perlite and mist in a plastic container. I only do cuttings of perennials. cedar trees grow quickly from seeds also

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Oh, I know it is not going to make any real difference in the amount of pollen in the area. I just mean from an overall "responsible citizen" perspective, it seems like if you're going to propagate Mountain Cedar, you really ought to propagate only females. But heck, I guess at this point in the game, if some turn out to be male, oh well.

    "Did you take the cuttings off a male or female tree?"

    That's the thing, I don't know if I got the cuttings from a male or female tree. At the time, I wasn't aware of the issue, so I was just walking around the lot taking cuttings.

    Excuse my ignorance of this tree. I'm not originally from this area.

    If you think Live Oak can do the trick, then I'll try that. The builder of my house put in Live Oak as my front yard landscape tree and it's been suckering like crazy. Also, Arbor Day is sending me 10 free Bald Cypress for signing up, but from what I've read they would not do well in that soil. What do you think?


    The lot is in Lago, so not too far from you. I might actually take you up on that if my experiments fail. Right now I have 1 Live Oak sucker in a pot, about 5 Live Oak cuttings (stem cuttings of suckers), the six cedar cuttings in the Aerogarden, and then an additional 4 cedar cuttings that I just stuck in the ground in a shady area. All but the ones in the Aerogarden are going to spend the winter outside though, so I dunno what will become of them.

  • 9 years ago

    if nothing else.. and they stay in your gizmo ... and they end up there
    all winter.. plz report back and let us know what reality ended up being
    ... we learn more thru our failures.. than we usually do thru easy
    success ...


    ==>>>> do not abort the experiment ... you will learn a lot ... until you can get the cuttings you want ...


    ken

  • 9 years ago

    Sure, I'll let you know how it goes.

  • 9 years ago

    If you plant live oak and your cuttings don't work, make sure that it is locally grown ESCARPEMENT live oak. Source is very important. You are not far from me AS THE CROW FLIES but probably an hour + drive around the lake and down 620.

  • 9 years ago

    Is Black Locust considered invasive around here? I love the fast growth and nitrogen fixation, especially in the poor soil. Not sure how it would do in the Texas summer though.

  • 9 years ago

    "Maybe you are having failure because the water rooted plants need a more humid transition from water to dirt. I do all my rooting in perlite and mist in a plastic container. I only do cuttings of perennials. cedar trees grow quickly from seeds also."


    This is my first time using the Aerogarden. The past failings I was talking about were rooted usually in sand. I've had some good successes as well, but I've had some issues with cuttings appearing to have good enough roots, but then not being able to sustain itself without mist / humidity dome. I'm guessing in those cases my interpretation of "good enough roots" was off. Had some other failings when I lived in Kansas with thinking I could plant out cuttings in late fall and they didn't make it through the winter. Not a big fan of growing things for long periods of time in containers. They seem to stay too wet indoors and dry out too fast outdoors. Plus if you keep them indoors you need to provide artificial light. I'm usually in a hurry to get things outside, and I've been burnt with that a little. My solution going forward I think is to focus on hardwood cuttings. That way they progress in a more natural way.

  • 8 years ago

    When you said give live oaks a try did you mean from cuttings? I wouldn't bother. If you meant digging up some root sprouts or seedlings that's ok. But they can take a long time to recover if you lose a lot of roots . from acorns they are usually slow for a year or two then start to grow pretty quickly , until they are transplanted then they check for a year or two and start growing well again.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I really don't understand why using cuttings of Live Oak when the trees are so available all around. I have a very knowledgeable friend who says his acorn grown oaks outstrip the store bought planted trees in time. True he is planting out in the wild.

  • 8 years ago

    Just for fun really. Seed is too easy. But it also sprung from the fact that I have a young live oak that suckers but hasn't produced acorns yet. Since I cut down the suckers anyway I figured I'd stick some and see what happens.