Make sure the white for cabs matches the white of the woodwork, otherwise (in fourth photo) where the cabinets meet the baseboard) one of the white will look dirty.

what white do you have on the pantry door? if you pick a warmer or creamier white, that door will also have to be done. ditto the trim work.

SW Pure White

Frosty White

Alabaster

Dover White

Snowbound

Thought you might like to see this pic. Almost the same counter and flooring. how do you like the darker island?

Your cabinets look great, but white will brighten up the space. I would recommend some of the off-white paints as they look more natural and would definitely keep the island in the existing color or paint it in dark brown to add contrast and avoid plain look.

rajiv, there wasn't any info w/that picture. I don't know the white. why don't you get some samples of some the colors I posted, above, and try them out in your kitchen?

"I would consider changing counters but that will be a lot I assume"

Have you priced out properly having the cabinets painted? New tops might be cheaper............