Software
Houzz Logo Print
ethanfahy

Metal Roofing: does brand matter or is it a commodity item?

8 years ago

I'm having a house built and designed for me and I have settled on getting a standing seam metal roof. (I know this question can and should be addressed to my designer but I like getting community opinions as well.) I will be getting firm fixed price bids on this house, which means the contractors are likely going to be looking for inexpensive metal roofing options unless I specify a particular metal roof material or even brand. Is it worth it to specify in the construction contract a particular brand of metal roof or is the quality more or less equal across brands/suppliers and I should just let the contractor choose the brand/supplier that gets them the best price?

Comments (10)

  • 8 years ago

    Are there go-to recommendations for what I'd want to ask for when specifying brand, gauge, finish type, base material, etc.? This house is in the coastal northeast US if that makes any difference.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Add local connection to millworkman’s list. The actual production factory is about 25 miles from me. How close is it from you? There’s a ton of fly by night resellers out there. Find out WHO is supplying, and where that factory is. That distance does factor into pricing. And then ask them who their longest term retailer is in the region. You don’t get that status by screwingover people. Nor do you stay in business by being the cheapest quote upstart guy who then finds out he can’t pay his light bill.

    As with anything b in contracting, relationships matter.

    e f thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You want 24 gauge standing seam, either double/mechanical lock, or snap lock, not single lock. You want one that has a kynar finish, which has a very long warranty. Stay away from ribs and striations. If you are right on the ocean I believe there are certain types that can withstand the salty sea air, just not sure which ones are best for that. I would also recommend having the entire roof done with a high temperature ice and water shield. And most important, make sure the installer balances and lines up the seams and doesn't just start with a whole piece on one end. The seams on the end should be the same distance from the edges. Also, the seams should meet at the ridges. Find a good metal artist. They are out there. Make sure you tour their work. Metal roofs are gaining in popularity and there are a bunch a rookies roaming about.

    e f thanked taconichills
  • 8 years ago

    @taconichills hey taco!! this is anna (IG @virginia.farmhouse.project) why stay away from ribs and striations? i was told this would help prevent oil canning. what is a high temperature ice and water shield? and i'm trying to conceptualize the "balancing and lining up of seams you mentioned?? it's a struggle. any input on roof I'd appreciate. we're in that phase now. thx

  • 8 years ago

    I was just on another old post asking about these “ribs”. Does anyone have a picture of a roof with ribs they can post?

  • 8 years ago

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Rawket Grl...thank you!

    Fine for a factory or warehouse, but in a residential setting, I think the striated ribs would be particularly unattractive.

  • 8 years ago
    Nidnay....

    I’ve seen ribs and striations done well. Think it just depends on architecture of house, colors, rooflines, etc. See photos below. Source: Instagram Park Capital Homes. This house roof has them and house is gorgeous.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Anna....just responded to this in the other thread :)