Software
Houzz Logo Print
supersam4735

Granite Countertop Question

8 years ago

Okay so a month ago we had granite installed. Brown Fantasy. After they were done everything looked great. They put a sealant on and left, it was nighttime when they finished. The next day we noticed a cloudy soap scum looking film over the top. And the seam was not even or flush and there was excess glue on the countertop along with some scratches. Also, the stone sink that was just installed had a crack in it. We contacted them back and they said the unevenness to the seam was because the floor wasn’t level and it was putting too much weight on one side. But we paid extra to have them come out and set and level our cabinets so I don’t see why pay them to do that then? Their response to the crack in the sink was to contact the manufacturer, he said it was his gut feeling the warranty isn’t covered and it’s normal wear and tear and to feel free to verify that for ourselves (he made that judgement before even seeing it)but contacting the sink manufacturer. I asked him how is it normal wear and tear, we’ve had it less than a month, and it’s a crack. And he sent me the direct contact to the manufacturer again. Anyway a month later they finally come out. We asked about the scratches, they said it’s natural, then asked about the cloudiness, they said it’s natural, then a crack and they said it was a natural fissure. They wind up grinding the seam and making it more flush and took off the excess glue, replaced a piece of the backsplash and fixed a chip. We felt the seam and it was flush and much better. We noticed not even two minutes after they left, the cloudiness that was all over the countertop was now even worse in the area where they “fixed the seam” and it’s a streaky mess and looks like soap scum. It looks terrible. We contacted them back right away and no response. Is there anything we can do about this. They are taking no accountability and use our lack of knowledge about granite to say “it’s natural” bc we aren’t professional so who are we to argue? I just know the placement of the seam and the cloudiness and scratches just do not look right. *** Also, when they just came out the said not to throw our keys on the down on it (we don’t we put them in a drawer) but on their site it says it’s very hard to scratch, not even a knife will scratch. And they claim the perfected the art in making the seam not notciable.








Comments (281)

  • 8 years ago

    Firstly, it's not "Brown Fantasy". It's Fantasy Brown, and there are a million images with that label, online. There is no granite that I have ever heard of, that is similar to your stone, or that has that name. There may be some companies that call the stone that, but they are either very unknowledgeable or intentionally misleading.

    This is a good description of what it is.

    https://www.archcitygranite.com/countertop-spotlight-fantasy-brown-marble/


    MSI calls it marble, which it does resemble in etching and scratching tests.

    https://www.msistone.com/marble/fantasy-brown/


    Here it's called quartzite, but of course it's not a true quartzite.

    https://marble.com/material/quartzite/166/fantasy-brown


    This the rare site that has it labeled correctly as Dolomite.

    https://superiorgranite.com/current-inventory/


  • 8 years ago

    Thank you so much! So, with them calling it a level 2 granite is not true? I was just curious because it’s so confusing to me.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    No - I think you were told that much earlier in this thread. Your counters are definitely not granite. Fantasy Brown is NOT granite. Did you google it yourself before buying it? If so, you would have known what it was. There is a huge long thread right here on Houzz just about Fantasy Brown - as there are so many fans of that stone. And as such, it is hard to understand how a so-called pro would not be able to look at that stone and not instantly know what it is. Heck I can do that just from the time spent on this website - I've walked into many showrooms and model homes and identified it, easily. How they could market it as a completely different type of stone, than it really it, is beyond me. One more reason why this company should be avoided at all costs.

    Here is the thread for your reading pleasure. :-)

    [https://www.houzz.com/discussions/calling-all-fantasy-brown-owners-dsvw-vd~2607689?n=686[(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/calling-all-fantasy-brown-owners-dsvw-vd~2607689?n=686)

  • 8 years ago

    I have read that thread thanks. But I was only asking because GP said after I rebuttled them saying they didn’t charge me for the correct stone in the BBB claim just now and was just asking for clarification. No, I didn’t research or google the specifics before hand, I just believed everything the professionals were telling me bc I am not, which I why I hired a professional. I was going through a lot of stress and hurricane damage and dealing with other construction companies I just stupidly put my trust in them. Yes, I know that was stupid of me to believe a professional. Even though I did research of their company and seen good ratings and believed the sales pitch... Which is why I am leaving reviews and going through BBB to warn people.

  • 8 years ago

    I wanted granite he sent me to a facility to pick out what I thought was granite because he had a sample in his car and said these are our granite samples, and fantasy brown is what I chose. So, I went to facility picked out my slab and he charged me for a level 2 granite. How was I suppose to know differently? I don’t study stone and which is why I went to a professional bc idk..

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I wouldn't say it was stupid for going with a "professional" just choose the wrong one because as a professional myself I hope ppl would trust me. But time and time again ppl get swindled in shotty ppl. Sorry it happened to you but there has to be a way to get it resolved.


    Fantasy Brown is definitely a marble

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thank you. It’s just people keep telling me I should have researched more and I did... This company had a great ratings, had badges from Houzz, home advisor, I seen pictures of his work and he made a bunch of promises in person on the consultation that he didn’t honor. I looked and looked and I liked what I seen when it came to that company. I had no idea they were going to do what they did. I had no idea they weren’t going to take accountability for their mistakes. I honestly just don’t even care about the money anymore I just want them to be held accountable. I just wish I could share what this company is saying in the BBB complaint on all of their review sites... And I know not all professionals are bad. I had my entire house floors done by woodlike ceramic tile, baseboards, new roof, new a/c unit, painter that painted the outside of my house and they all did phenominal jobs. I have learned just to be more cautious now is all.

  • 8 years ago

    Definitely use BBB to file the complaint. Unfortunately, lots of people install granite that are not qualified. The seam and the match-up are TOTALLY unacceptable and obviously your installer has no conscience and no morals--and no idea what he is doing. Nothing that you have encountered is "typical" for granite/marble installation. Have you checked with homeowners insurance? Try every avenue because your situation is every homeowners' nightmare.

  • 8 years ago

    I agree mom2hsm, I haven’t checked with homeowners insurance, can they do something?

  • 8 years ago

    I never heard of a home owner's insurance paying for a hired contractor mistake unless what they did burned down the home but then the contractors insurance would pay for that if it was proven. I do know that just inquiring about it could (it may or may not) result in your insurance company canceling your insurance or raising your rate so unless you know they won't, then weigh whether pursuing this would be worth the risk. Perhaps I'll learn something new about home owner's insurance if someone pipes in that they had success going this route..

  • 8 years ago

    I have no idea that’s why I asked. I didn’t know if I was missing something or not.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    supersam4735 - sorry I didn't mean to come off as snarky, and I am certainly not saying your were "stupid'!! Not at all!! You got a scumbag company, unfortunately, that appears to not know even the basics. I just wanted to emphasize the importance of "caveat emptor". Always always do your own research - don't take anything for granted. I really am hoping this gets resolved for you - this guy needs to have this story posted on his FB page and Yelp reviews.


  • 8 years ago

    Supersam- I think, too, that life experiences and age lead one to do lots of research. I know in my much younger yrs I hired contractors based on excellent ratings and reviews and put all my trust in them. No other research needed, or so I thought. So as you go through life, this is one of many life experiences that will shape as to how you approach a contractor again. Believe me, if anyone who hasn't worked with contractors before hasn't had at least one bad one, that is really rare!

  • 8 years ago

    Chess your comment is not showing up for some reason but in response to your comment “supersam4735 - sorry I didn't mean to come of as snarky - I just wanted to emphasize the importance of "caveat emptor".” What about companies taking responsibility for their mistakes? Twice? There’s a reason why people pay for professionals. It’s because they are suppose to have the knowledge and they studied the practice of whatever it is they do. I went by what the company told me. They had the knowledge, I didn’t. How I was I suppose to know that after the sealant dried and it would look differently in the day time? How I was I suppose to know the sink would crack without even having been use? How was I suppose to know that having them come back out to fix it was only going to make it worse? How was I suppose to know the professional was lying to me? How was I suppose to know there was a difference between marble and granite? How was I suppose to know any of this would even be an issue? I was paying a professional to help me. Not lie to me.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I agree with that Tedd! It was definitely a life lesson for sure! I’ve only been a home owner for 3 years and 2 out of 3 of those years we got hit hard with a hurricane so we have learned a lot but this has taught me so much when dealing with contracters from now on that’s for sure

  • 8 years ago

    "What about companies taking responsibility for their mistakes?"

    Oh I am not saying that they should not!! Quite the contrary! But if you had posted a picture here on this forum of the "granite" slab you had chosen, you might have been advised to steer clear of that company. There was no way to know ahead of time what a horrible job that they would do, but I always try to learn as much as I can about a project/process so that I can ask intelligent questions of the "pro" and make sure that they actually know as much as I have found out in my own research - at least that is a start. As Ted said - this is definitely a lesson learned. I could tell you SO many stories about so-called professionals that have ripped me off so badly...or tried to, it's insane. You really do have to be on your toes.

  • 8 years ago

    I had zero red flags. This guy was a great salesman and I trusted him stupidly. Everything seemed to go smoothly until the moment I contacted them with issues. I never knew it would be this much of a nightmare dealing with a granite company. He seemed knowledgeable and I have zero knowledge about this stuff. That’s why I put my trust into a professional. I read reviews I had no reason to question them. How was I to post a photo of the slab on here when I didn’t even know there was an issue with it? I went with what the professional told me. I was lied to and I didn’t know.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sam, I just wanted to pipe in and tell you that you didn't do anything different than loads of other people would have done. You did your homework on the contractor and then you put your trust in a professional. It's perfectly normal for most people who aren't obsessed with Houzz like we are :)

    Don't beat yourself up over this. You did right. Sadly, it's a sucky experience to have to have, but you're continuing to do the best you can with a bad situation. Hang in there and just keep putting one foot in front of the other...

    Maybe go out for a nice meal and a movie to break up the stress a little...;)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    " I have zero knowledge about this stuff. " That's why I am telling you - LEARN. If you simply assume that every pro you hire, is going to do the job correctly, without learning ANYTHING about what it is you are having done, then you have a lot of disappointments ahead of you. I'm not blaming you - I am trying to save you more heartaches in the future!! Really I am. I hate that this happened to you - it SUCKS.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I did my research with this company... if I knew I would have to take a lesson in granite installation I would just have installed it myself... I certainly have learned from this experience and I did do my research on this company... The issue is not learning... The issue is the contractor were liars... Had nothing to do with me learning the ins and outs of granite installation... If it was my mistake I would own it but I did nothing wrong. P.s I could have done all of the research in the world and it still wouldn’t have mattered bc my initial issue wasn’t even the type of the stone it was their workmanship.

    Penny I just want to thank you for your comments. I found out about Houzz after the fact and from now on I’m coming here if I have any needs with home improvement!

  • 8 years ago

    I also wanted to update. They extended the time for their response 3 times and called them twice and left voicemails over the course of a couple weeks. They had until the 29th to respond I’m assuming their last chance, and they responded before the day was over. Now I’m just waiting to see what happens next. I believe I gave my last statement and there is no more rebuttles.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    You need to make them know that fixing this is less work and expense than the alternative.

  • 8 years ago

    checked out homeowners and most policies would not cover this issue. Take them to small claims court. They seriously need to reimburse you and cover removal as well. I would not let them do the removal--that would be a disaster. You have plenty of pictures and hopefully all of your correspondence. This is way too expensive to just walk away from and consider a lesson. Best of luck-

  • 8 years ago

    "Take them to small claims court."

    If they don't move in the next few days to correct it, that would be my next step as well.

  • 8 years ago

    This business has already made it clear that they will not be doing anything. They didn’t feel like doing “charity work.” Right now we are waiting to see what BBB is doing, I believe we finally just took the last step with them and waiting for resolution. After that we will be taking next step. I will keep everyone updated.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Wow... So it’s looking like BBB did nothing... At least I can use his rebuttles in court. Even though they literally had to make 3 time extension, call him twice and leave VM just to get him to respond... If they didn’t give him the time extension he never would have responded but yet they gave him countless chances... I feel so conned. I can’t believe they aren’t being held accountable... Even though I had proof of them lying it didn’t matter to BBB... And not to mention if I could just show everyone what he said in his rebuttles you’d be shocked...

  • 8 years ago

    BBB did what their business is set up to do which is to attempt to get a resolution for you but they aren't in the legal business and you didn't pay them so how could you expect them to spend hours and hours on this and have them make that company "accountable". That is what small claims court is for. I really didn't think you expected more, did you? I had thought the main reason for contacting them was to get a negative rating out there so others might learn from your experience and IF BBB was able to get a resolution for you that would have been a bonus. Time to move onto small claims court as this is where this belongs.


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That’s what I mean by being held accountable, is a negative rating sorry I didn’t make that more clear. I know they are not a legal business. I already know all of that. I didn’t expect more other than a negative rating. And yes, I have already contacted a lawyer, time to go through this route.

  • 8 years ago

    I know this is a long shot but can anyone recommend a granite fabricator in my area? Volusia County. The one I have contacted obviously hasn’t gotten back to me so I need to find a new one.

  • 8 years ago

    I'm not getting why you feel you need to contact a lawyer and spend more money. Recouping $4500. is for small claims court and that you do on your own.

  • 8 years ago

    I know I would be taking them to small claims. And because I need legal advice.

  • 8 years ago

    I don't know if you've research small claims court for your county but here is that info which explains the whole procedure very well and may help you determine if you need legal advice at this point or not.

    https://www.clerk.org/small-claims.aspx

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, yes I have researched in my county. The attorney I’m speaking with for advice isn’t costing me anything. He said it sounds like I do have a case and letting me know what I should do next and what paperwork to get together etc.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Show him this thread.

  • 8 years ago

    The only thing the attorney wants to see is well organized facts that he can make a determination of the course of action within minutes of reading quickly through it to get the jest of it. This thread is of no benefit to him. Attorney's fees aren't cheap ( $300. and up usually) and the 1st courtesy mtg their goal is to be as efficient as possible and get to the point since it is not a billable hour. And for $4500. I expect that it will be a quick mtg.

    If you decide to use him/her, keep in mind that whatever they quote you is a general amount. It is not written in stone. Every time you make contact, even if it is a 2 min call or an quick email, you will be billed. It adds up quickly as depending on the office that 2 min call will be billed as 15 min or 30 min. So you want to be as efficient as possible by sticking to the facts and be well prepared. Keep your emotions in check as you don't want to waste time. Even if it is a courtesy mtg, the attorney is going to take into consideration how you would present yourself in court and how much hand holding you need.

  • 8 years ago

    Oh trust me I’m well composed. This company however is not. Even in the BBB I acted accordingly and not in a disrespectful tone like they did. At this point I’m not even worried about the money, I just don’t want to let them get away with this is all and don’t want another person to have to go through what I have been through.

  • 8 years ago

    Still dealing with this, but have a question. They say in the contract that it says the seam can be seen and felt. I’m just wondering, in the countertop business is it normal for the seams to have lippage and to be felt? Or do most countertop installers never have that issue? Because I was under the impression that it would be flush? Also, if the seam is not done properly, can that cause bacteria? TIA!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    They are hiding behind wordage man, every seam or cut that is made to a stone counter will be felt come on now....are they kidding? There is a difference between a correct seam that can still be felt because after all it is is a seam, and there is a difference when you have shoddy work plainly exemplified in your counter. Do not back down.


    supersam4735 thanked Filipe Custom Woodwork
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thank you! We are going through arbitration with the BBB and I think we have a pretty strong case. Just trying to get more advice so I’m prepared on everything they try to throw at us. I was never given a contract until they sent it in to the BBB so I wasn’t sure what was in there. I understand that the seams may be felt but not have excess glue and grind marks and lippage.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I would say that glue, grind marks and lippage are NOT within anybody's "acceptable parameters"...

    supersam4735 thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Wow I just read through all of this Supersam! I am SO sorry you went through this. My dad always said “Florida is full of thieves and liars”...I know it’s horrible to lump a whole state together but after reading this and having almost the EXACT same experience with a different company I think his words are becoming gospel! I truly hope that you get a resolution because it’s not fair at all to spend this money and be left with a disaster

    supersam4735 thanked thetzone
  • 8 years ago

    Supersam- has that company agreed to BBB arbitration? Just surprised me since the company hasn't been willing to resolve this problem and arbitration through BBB doesn't hold them liable if the agreement favors you and they don't agree. Or is that not the case?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    They are held liable if it’s in our favor. If they don’t do what is ordered then they get bad rating and we can take them to court.

  • 8 years ago

    I don't think that the company is liable as there won't be any legal binding to the outcome as the BBB isn't a legal entity. It's just a case if a bad rating is important to them or not and you could take them to court now if you so desired. I believe if the court ordered arbitration that decision would be binding as it is going through the legal system. Have they agreed to this arbitration?

  • 8 years ago

    I don’t feel comfortable going into too much detail about it as I’m not sure if I’m allowed to speak about it. No, it’s not a legal system but both parties are agreeing to whatever outcome the arbitrator comes up with. If they don’t then they will get bad rating or not be accredited anymore. And I can then take to court with this information stating that they agreed to this and are not honoring it and will look better for my case.

  • 8 years ago

    Supersam, sorry you were treated this way! Gave your hard earned money & trust to a company that should’ve done their very best! Hope you receive a resolution to all this!

    supersam4735 thanked Denysse Smith
  • 8 years ago

    Just wanted to update! As of yesterday I can put this nightmare behind me! Went through Arbitration last month through BBB. They kept asking for time extensions and not responding but finally responded and agreed to go through arbitration. It was ruled in my favor and they were ordered to refund! They had 30 days to send the check and today would have been the 30th and they waited until the last moment to send the check which I recieved yesterday! I’m not complaining though! Either way they had to pay for their mistake and were held accountable even though they wouldn’t take accountability! :) 8 months later and we are DONE! Thanks for all the help everyone!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That is fantastic news Supersam!!!

    Have you decided to leave it? This seems quite rare that someone like this doesn’t get away with it. Well done about staying strong and continuing to pursue them. An inspiration to us all!! Thanks for updating us.

    supersam4735 thanked wmsimons85
  • 8 years ago

    Congratulations! Your perseverance paid off. I wish more people would stand up and fight for their rights from these shoddy contractors.

    supersam4735 thanked Chessie
  • 8 years ago

    I’m going to be replacing the countertops for sure! I’m ready to not have a huge cutting board covering up the grind marks lol

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting