Software
Houzz Logo Print
francesca_brown51

hardwood vs laminate. HELP!

8 years ago
I love the look of hardwood but I have heard they scratch very easily. I have 2 dogs (white and brown) and 2 cats (white and grey). I want something that will be easy to maintain and hold up over the years. I love richer darker woods but I have seen the latest trend of greys and I love that too. I know nothing about flooring and have never owned either options so any cleaning suggestions will also be helpful.
laminate wood
hardwood

Comments (3)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    IMO large dogs can do huge damage to hardwood no matter waht wood it is . Some people like the handscraped floor to hide scratches IMO it just looks like someone was to lazy to finish the floor I have had laminate in this house and my lasyt house with 2 big dogs not one scratch in 10 yrs here and 12 yrs in my last house.

  • 8 years ago

    As Patricia points out, there is a time and a place for laminate floors (hers are high end European laminate which is not the same as Home Depot $0.79/sf type of product).

    To decide, you will need to look at your own situation and your own expectations as well as budget. Here are a few basic questions you need to answer before deciding which row to hoe.

    1. Duration in the home: less than 10 years = laminate because you will update the floors anyways before you sell. Might as well save money to day so that you can spend money before selling. More than 10 years in the home, you can have a STRONG EYE towards hardwood because it is a permanent floor (solid hardwood = 60 - 80 years of service).

    2. Area where you live and your indoor living conditions: a Floridian slab-on-grade home may not be the best place to throw in hardwood. And laminate may not be a great idea either...but it can be much easier to deal with in a poorly conditioned home.

    1. Personal expectations: if you are AFRAID of scratches (you need to be completely honest with yourself) then hardwood may not be a great idea. I high end laminate ($4.50/sf) will give you an excellent floor to work with for 15+ years (a really good one should last 25 years). If you LOVE wood and you couldn't care LESS about scratches and dents because you KNOW you can have them refinished/refurbished anytime you want, then hardwoods are the only thing you will like.

    4. Your budget and the "value" already inherent in the home: If you have 1000sf of home that is worth $140K and only have a $7K budget, then laminate would be the better option. If you have a 3,000+ sf mansion worth $3.2M, and the sky is the limit for budget then a high-end solid hardwood is the expectation - laminate would not be an acceptable material in such a high-end home.

    The tricky part comes when you have a moderate end home ($250K - $500K) with a large(r) foot print (2500sf) and a moderate budget ($15K). This gets really tricky. You will find some of the homes in the area have hardwoods and others have more expensive laminate/vinyl floors. Again, this is where the other 3 questions come into play.

    Sadly, no one can give you the answer you are looking for....but we can lead you to the questions you need to ask yourself so that you can find the right material for you and the appropriate material for your home's inherent value.

    As for colour: A light, natural wood colour with some movement (that means different coloured planks). I would think a White Oak or a lower grade Maple or Hickory would do very well for the different coloured animals. These colours hide a TON of sins! A satin or semi-gloss finish are the easiest gloss levels to live with.

  • 8 years ago
    Thank you so much these are very helpful!