Software
Houzz Logo Print
emmons_laura

frigidaire vs maytag vs whirlpool

8 years ago
Frigidaire our builders preferred appliance. However, we have the option to substitute for whirlpool or maytag. I do not know anything about appliances. Any thoughts or suggestions?

Comments (11)

  • 8 years ago

    Check the appliance forums.

  • 8 years ago

    I love my Frigidaire induction range and have had Frigidaire fridges for over a decade. They were better than our GE models..

  • 8 years ago

    IMHO, none of the current home owner type appliances(especially refrigerators) are worth buying. In the last 12 years, we have had to replace two washers and three refrigerators---because they broke down out of warranty(2 by less than 2 weeks) and the repair costs were just short of buying a new unit.

    Have never felt the need to buy an extended warranty, but the next fridge will be purchased with the longest warranty possible.

    And, no, we do not want to pay $75+ a month for a whole house program---all the stuff is new now.

  • 8 years ago

    We bought new, inexpensive (builders grade?) frigidaire appliances for the temporary house we live in but own while building. Frigidaire..frig, not so great. Range...ok. Dishwasher...pretty fabulous. This dw is amazing for such a bargain.

  • 8 years ago

    ILoveRed- What is your comparable? We are in a rental now (new 2017) and the fridge DW is the worst thing I have ever had. Loud and terrible at cleaning. We have a Maytag/Whirlpool at our vacation home that is not fancy but certainly better than the fridge. We got the Maytag there because the warranty was different than Whirlpool (not sure if still true).

    Our fridge fridge - reasonable but ruins veges faster than our last (Subzero) and our vacation (Whirlpool).

    The range is reasonable. The microwave has a completely annoying noise indicator and keeps going off. So frustrating.

    HandyMac is absolutely right. They are all terrible when it comes to longevity. But with one caveat - basic brand appliances. My last house had not a single failure in 8 years. There was one warranty visit for a rattle. Wolf/Subzero/Kitchenaid DW/Samsung Washer/Dryer. Correction - I did have to fix a sensor on the dryer. Cost me $10 but 2 hours of my time.

    If you are locked into basic appliances, see what you can do about warranty. Then remember still you won't have any of them for that long. At our vaca house that is 6 years old - we have new washer and new fridge. Calling GE for repair today on the less than 1 yo fridge. Got a 5 year extended on that one. Had 3-4 repairs on the Whirlpool before it kicked the can.

    So frustrating that you have to pay for prestige brands to get decent quality. I suspect there are some finds in the mid range with decent quality but I would not bet on it.

  • 8 years ago

    Spend some time reading on the appliance forum and you'll see that even the "prestige brands" don't offer any more longevity or fewer issues.

    We bought all Frigidaire and Elux (which owns Frigidaire) for our build. W/D are Elux and I have -0- complaints or issues. Elux slide in induction range had lots of issues (search on the appliance forum with my name for the saga) and we had to battle and get the state involved to get it replaced after only 5 months of use where 1 month was totally unusable. We've had 3 service calls for our Frigidaire French door Refrig (nothing through the door because I didn't want the complications), the ice maker has been replaced and we've received total BS about what is making the knocking noise (google that). My husband finally figured it out, the ice maker change minimized it but didn't stop it. A condensate hose in our Frigidaire dishwasher was not properly connected (2 service calls and a leak) and is only supposed to be a friction fit which is dicey to begin with so again, DH had to created a proper coupling to keep the connection sound.

    All that said, do searches on any appliance brand, even down to specific models and you will find a litany of complaints. People tend to get more vocal about negatives than positives unless asked specifically. But nothing is made to last and if you have any past experience with appliances that did, do not expect the same this time around. We had an Amana refrig that never required any service for 24 years, same for a Kitchenaid glass/elec stove. We had Kitchenaid dishwashers in 2 houses but wouldn't buy them again because of the venting issues ruining cabinets on the current models.

    Good luck - it's a crap shoot.

  • 8 years ago

    They are all equally bad. Set up a savings fund to keep them running and expect to replace them in 6 years. Expect dissapointments.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Bought Frigidaire for my old house before sale. Worked great. Buyers loved the new appliances.

    Bought Frigidaire for the inlaws when we remodeled. She loves them.

    I have the Frigidaire gallery dishwasher. I really like it.

    Samsung. I am trying to get them to FIX my refrigerator. Ghastly service.

    Samsung front load washer/dryer. Meh.

    Bosch. I love my slide in range. Should have bought the whole set but I thought I was being frugal by shopping each individually.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Dont think that all appliances need to come from the same manufacturer. I chose Frigidaire induction range for price and reliability. I chose Whirlpool DW because I wanted a low end model that got good reviews on longevity - I am a low volume DW user and often do dishes by hand, so didn't care about bells and whistles.

    There were two brands of refrigerator (33 inch, bottom freezer) that stood out for quality, at least by reviews, when I went looking - the Whirlpool was marginally less expensive, so I got that. Note, different sizes and configurations of a fridge may have different optimal brands.

    I've not been using these appliances that long yet, time will tell.

  • 8 years ago

    I am guessing you are needing to purchase an entire suite of the same brand, right? I would get the models of all the items in your suite and start reading reviews. Pick the suite of products that you feel had the best ratings, I always check Home Depot, they have a lot of reviews. If you see the same issue being mentioned obviously it's not a one-off problem. I have 0 trust in Consumer Report ratings. Most here would never recommend buying an entire suite of the same brand. Make sure you focus on the most expensive items first...fridge, stove, dishwasher, microwave. There have been a lot of changes, not for the good, in appliances brands. Someone that loves their 10 year old Maytag, even 5 year old, isn't buying the same product today...just saying.