Software
Houzz Logo Print
sharonavl

Need help choosing countertops for kitchen

8 years ago

I am planning to upgrade my kitchen countertops but am having a hard time deciding what to choose. The current counters are a sagey green Corian type surface that have become very scratched over the years. We inherited this kitchen when we moved here, the cabinets are a good quality natural Maple and the floors are Brazilian cherry. We also have a rock wall that the back side of a fireplace in the living room that adds to the mix of colors.


I have looked at granite and quartz and like those materials. I am just having a hard time finding the right color. Any suggestions? I don't want to go too gray because the rock wall already has a lot of gray in it. When I look at light color quartz they are just too blah. Thank you in advance for any suggestions you might give.





Comments (20)

  • 8 years ago

    I went light with my wood cabinets - my kitchen is a different style but the countertop is flexible to different styles. Mine is LG White Pearl, but I think there are several with a similar look.

    https://www.houzz.com/photos/my-pics-work-in-progress-phvw-vp~110720042

    https://www.houzz.com/photos/my-pics-work-in-progress-phvw-vp~54988831

    If it is in the budget, there are some beautiful quartzite - not to be confused with quartz. Quartzite is harder then granite but often as pretty as marble. The difficulty is that some stone sold as quartzite is really marble and not durable.

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/countertop-geology-part-six-lets-talk-about-rocks-some-more-dsvw-vd~2692150

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/the-definitive-guide-to-quartzite-dsvw-vd~4426353

    I love your large window!

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks very much for your advice. I will look into the White Pearl, it looks great in your kitchen! I have seen some Quartzite but I was kind of afraid of going that route since I heard that it can etch and the maintenance is similar to marble. (The guy at the stone shop told me this.) Thanks again for the help!

  • 8 years ago

    Real Quartzite is harder than granite, but much marble is mislabeled as quartzite. The two discussions above have a lot of info about stone counters and are very helpful if you pick a granite or quartzite. They include some tests you can run on a sample to see if you are getting real quartzite, granite or if it is really marble. The discussions are posted by an expert in stone countertop materials.

    If you actually really like your present counters (they aren't bad), Corian is one countertop that can be revitalized back to looking almost new. Perhaps Joe Corlett - our expert countertop / sink repair guy - will stop by and explain or you can try to message him.

    https://www.houzz.com/pro/joseph-corlett/joseph-corlett-llc

    Keep looking at the different quartz too.

    sharonavl thanked jhmarie
  • 8 years ago

    Back in summer of last year I was going through the same thing. I was actually spent over 4 hours reading on various type of countertop because I went to a showroom and discovered quartize, which I never heard of before. There was an article on Houzz about it . The name Laura Bolen kept coming up as the expert on the various countertop types, especially stone. I actually sent her email with a picture of my stone to see if she can confirm if it is a real quartize. Long story short, real quartize is a natural stone and is actually harder than granite. Mine is Perla Venata. It has a creamy background with treaks of greeen, gold, and purple. Still don’t know why I was attracted to it the moment I laid my eyes on it since I didn’t think I had room for green as part of my colour skim. Now that I’ve it for many months, I love the look of it! Like most natural stone, it is uniquely beautiful. So easy to take care of and there is no etching or staining, even when it is left overnight. The only thing I don’t like is it feels much colder compares to my previously laminate countertop. Also, unlike laminate countertop, things will break if you dropped it :)

    May Be you can pick your stone and send your picture your Laura to ask her to confirm. She seems very knowledgeable and supper nice!

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Jasmine. I saw Perla Venata at the slab place and actually put it on my list of possibilities. Then when I talked to a different stone company, the guy swayed me away from it. I love the look and your kitchen looks gorgeous. Love your cabinets as well. I'm having a hard time deciding on the color as well. One place recommended going dark, like black. Another thinks that light would be better and recommends Colonial Cream granite. Another thing I worry about is whether granite is out of style and if I do go with granite then my kitchen will look dated. I'm glad I only need to choose the countertops because this is overwhelming! Don't know how you guys choose the whole kitchen!!

  • 8 years ago

    I’d go light on the countertops with warm colors that tie the fireplace and cabinets together. You should probably avoid large, dramatic patterns given the fireplace.

    sharonavl thanked ilikegardens
  • 8 years ago

    Just love your kitchen. I have nothing to advise for you just want to follow and see what you end up doing. Your home is beautiful.

    sharonavl thanked simplify52
  • 8 years ago
    I loved the quartz countertops by Cambria. They have so many beautiful choices that are more fun.
    sharonavl thanked Decisionfatigue
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for the advice and complements. I will check out the Cambria and agree that lighter would be better. Next time I bring home some samples I will post for your opinions.

  • 8 years ago
    With the two very different wood species, I would probably choose a white Quartz for a solid look or a light color granite (minimal graining in gray on mainly white stone).
    sharonavl thanked felizlady
  • 8 years ago
    Hey sharonw88, thanks for your compliment on my kitchen. I know what you’re going through because I was totally stressed out when I went through the same thing last year. Unless you’re planning to sell soon, you can just make sure to pick something durable and you like it. The kitchen doesn’t have to be a show room. You’re the one who has to be there everyday. After so many show room visits, I had my choices narrowed down to a granite, a quartize, and a Cambria quartz. As it turned out, the one Cambria pattern that I like is 3K more than my other choices. I went with Perla venata because I was able to get Laura to confirm back that it is a real quartize and not some mis-labelled marble. Apparently, this is a real problem. So, if you pick a natural stone, make sure you have the stone tag so you’ll have exactly what you picked. They all are uniquely ID. Just because they have the same names doesn’t mean that they’re the same. One thing I did was to ask the store for a stone sample. Then I tested it with red wine, blueberries juices, etc overnight to make sure that cleaning stains is not an issue.
    You may want to take a look at the Perla venata quartize stone again and get in touch with Laura. She will help you to confirm if you send a couple of good pictures. Looking back, I’m real happy with the choice I made (saving 3K is not bad either :). Got many complements too on the uniquely colours of the stone.
    I’m sure you’ll make a good choice. Good luck!
    sharonavl thanked Jasmine B
  • 8 years ago

    I need to replace the countertops because my cooktop needs to be replaced. I thought I could just go out and buy a new cooktop and pop it in the old hole but it is not that easy. They are all different sizes and the one I want requires a smaller hole. I have talked with several people about how to get the hole smaller but it not as easy as it sounds and is really not recommended. If the hole I needed was bigger it would be a different story. So I thought new countertops would be a nice facelift for the kitchen. The existing counters are about 12 years old.

    I am going to revisit the Quartzite and check out the other materials in lighter, warmer tones. Luckily we do not plan to move soon so I can do this for me and not for the next owner of the house.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Quartzite is beautiful & durable, but it's not colorful; however, you'll most likely never tire of it. Cambria Stone is "pure quartz with a small amount of pigment and resin", according to Cambria Stone's website. It has great reviews, but if you want the slab that makes you swoon, look at granite. It is the stone as it was before it was excavated from the earth. You purchase the exact slab(s) you see in the showroom, including many white granites & colors, some with bits of Mica, which sparkles....gorgeous.

  • 8 years ago

    Is the sample above granite (the square one) and if so, which granite is it?

  • 8 years ago

    Barbara, it looks very much like the granite I ended up choosing for my counters, which is Colonial Cream.


  • 8 years ago
    I agree with Chocolatesnap. Refinish your countertops and take a trip to Paris with the savings.
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Sharon, I will check out Colonial Cream.

  • 8 years ago

    if the perimeter can be left and refurbished...then do the change in the middle area. I would use the opportunity to get it one level: butcherblock or soapstone for the needed middle area.....

  • 8 years ago

    I totally agree with herbflavor. Update the island to one level and a nice top, refurb the perimeter. You have a lovely kitchen!