Software
Houzz Logo Print
helbrod

Gluing down over osb: 3/4 engineered or 3/4 solid wood

8 years ago

Any thoughts? One room is over a fairly insulated garage...in NC so not TOO much of a humidity issue.


Thanks

Any thoughts for a good solid or engineered brand not more than $6 installed price.

Comments (8)

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Glue or staple down the 3/8". Nail down the 3/4".
    Are you wanting prefinished or sand, stain and finish?
    $6 installed? Maybe through Home Depot in Mexico.

  • 8 years ago

    Please don't glue down to OSB. The glue and the OSB don't like it. And nailing/stapling have issues with OSB as well.

    For $6/sf installed you are best to go with a floating laminate or vinyl. The cost of the hardwood will be $7-$12/sf. The cost of install (with glue) will be as much as $7/sf (glue + labour). You need EXPENSIVE glues with OSB. It is cheaper to lay plywood over the OSB and then go from there. I'm not kidding.

    OSB is a POOOOOOOR substrate to glue to. It is full of wax that causes bond failures. Nailing into it isn't much better. OSB LOVES to shrink over time. That means the fasteners (nails/staples/cleats) LOOSEN over time creating a squeaky, bouncy mess that people HATE.

    Floating a decent laminate fits all of your criteria. Good luck.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Booking a flight now! Cute.

    No, smarty pants :) I was thinking $9 installed ( $8500 to 9000 budget for 900 sq ft) translated to $6 cost of floor per square ft.

    Cork is confusing to me bc then you're still gluing.

    We were getting $180 Bostic glue but i guess that is out too.

    Not interested in laminate

    Not too interested in taking out the osb...so what are my options?

    Better screw the osb...then Screw 1/2 plywood to osb?

    I could then staple the 3/4 solid floors I assume? 3/4 or 1/2 engineered with a nice 3mm wear layer?


    Or are you saying thay with osb I pretty much have to float a laminate? I'd rather keep the carpet.



  • PRO
    8 years ago

    $9 installed; material, tax and labor is a much better budget. Glad you have a since of humor and can recognize sarcasm (some can't here).
    I agree with SJ McCarthy's statements as well, good info.

  • 8 years ago

    Thx guys

  • 8 years ago

    Even the 3/8" engineered is better stapled to the disoriented strand board. (I have a Bostich Floor Runner). The Bruce (and the like) adhesive is nasty stuff. I only use it when I don't have something I can nail/staple to.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks again guys. I appreciate all of the advice...in a perfect world I'd go by the book $$$.... I have decided to leave the osb (screwing it down better), apply the best floating underlayment I can get (perhaps cork or something else) and float a decent 1/2 engineered floor (Naturally Aged Flooring has a pretty hickory wirebrushed matt finish). Anything is better than salt and pepper carpet. When I win lotto in 10 years, a new subfloor it is...or I just set it on fire down the line :)