IMO it depends on many things. The pendants themselves, your style the table so posting some pics would be nice . Keep in mind you would now have 3 electrical boxes in the ceiling for the table and the island. It also depends on how close these are to eachother but without pictures of the space and the pendants I have no idea.

It would be too busy based on the close proximity to each other.

Have you picked out your pendant lighting for the island yet? If so, post it and we might be able to come up with some ideas for the table.

Post a photo of the ones you like for the dining table.

I've been trying to find you some visuals so you can get an idea of what it would look like having multiple lights over the table and the island and both being so close to each other. I didn't find exact set-up as yours but at least this might give you an idea.

The Neoteric Classic · More Info

Don't look at the table placement. This represents more the direction and closeness your pendants would be.

Open Kitchen · More Info

Same with this photo.

ventnor,nj · More Info

I assumed that you are looking at having more one of those pendant above the table?

Yes, I feel the table is so big that it needs more balance....like 2~ what would you suggest doing? Or how would you do the lighting? I am so lost on this right now~ I have been researching this for day with still no idea of what I should do ~ lol

Only a day??? I'm going to pop over to another island lighting posting where there were some houzzers with some great ideas and came up a solution for her. I'll see if I can get them to come over here and see if we can come up with a solution for you.

opps DAYS~ and DAYs

Seriously DAYS~ at some point I am thinking NO island lights except for can lights lol~

I like the linear lantern pendant over the table.

Like the flynn pendant! I suggested it on the other post tedbixby is referencing. Not a huge fan of pendants over both island and dining. What do you think about flynns over your table and a chandelier over your island instead? (Although I think the Flynns over the island in the second pic look great).

Anything could work if the fixtures were completely different from each other, but that look may be more transitional/eclectic:

Country Kitchen · More Info

Farmhouse Kitchen · More Info

This one shows canned lighting over island and pendants over dining:

Candelas 6005 · More Info

Wait... sorry, what is your countertop material and color/material of your cabinets?

I was kinda thinking the same~ well I have been thinking TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO many things and trying to come up with something~ My cabinets are Blackish~ more of a charcoal color, with Granite that is white, with black, grey, beige mixed in it,. I was too thinking JUST the cans too, but I thought that the NEW style was to put big lights up........was trying to stay "cool" lol or stylish, up to date! So do you all think it will still look Nice~ stylish without island lights, or what would you do with this space?

I should say one more thing~ the island on the plans is not the island I have~ the architect mess up on that, its actually 10 x 5

And in the next few yrs the NEW style will be little lights... don't get mixed up with what is in now. If you put in what you love, you'll be happier with it and you'll live with it longer than what is in today, out tomorrow. '

Looking at your floor plan, it appears that the first thing that you see when you enter your home will be the dining room table? If so, I think your lighting there is more important and needs to make the statement more so than what is over the island.

Do you have you budgeted for the dining light and island pendants?

Have you looked at this site?

https://www.arhaus.com/furniture/lighting/chandeliers/

Zanzibar Rectangular Chandelier · More Info

This site has a photo of it in a dining rm https://www.curreycodealers.com/p-7057-zanzibar-rectangular-chandelier.aspx?EID=152&EN=Category#.WoJPHainFPY

Anything like this? Note the pendant behind it, too. Understated but still makes a statement. Don't know if you have thought about your hardware finish yet.

Transitional Kitchen · More Info

Rogue Chandelier | Currey & Company · More Info

Currey & Company Henri Rectangular Chandelier · More Info

Hi Stephanie. What is your ceiling height over dining table and island? Has recessed lighting already been roughed in? What is the wattage on the pendant you were considering over table?

Hello stephanie Miller

Look for linear chandelier

Stephanie- did you make a decision?

Hi stephanie,

In addition to hand-building copper and iron chandeliers, Bevolo also sells some vintage/new lighting pieces. We also offer a complementary design service and
can scale out the proper size fixtures for your rooms, based on your ceiling heights/table dimensions.

Let us know if we can help you at all. Happy decorating! -Lindsey @ Bevolo

wow I am having a very similar dilemma with our kitchen/dining room renovation and lighting!! I'm so happy to have found this conversation!! Great advice. I'd love to see what you ended up doing Stephanie.