Software
Houzz Logo Print
mina_ghanaie_zarelli

Overcomplicating things

8 years ago
Need advice.
I hired a landscape designer to help me with my overall plan. I know what I like, what I don’t and probably could have done the design myself but I’m constantly changing my mind and over thinking things. They completed the design for our entire property and it’s very busy with a lot of non-native plants I’m not familiar with (zone 8, PNW). I don’t want to start over, but after picking on everything I feel like I am. I like certain groupings of plants, but others I don’t care for (too colorful, too busy, too small, too odd shaped).

Any advice on how to reel things in and simplify?

Comments (15)

  • 8 years ago

    Yes: the bottom line is, for whatever reasons you didn't get the design you wanted.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Post a photo of the plan (not a tiny photo) in order to get an opinion.

  • 8 years ago


    Here is an example of what I mean. I put these images together to try to figure out what we are getting. Juniperus "blue star", Thuja Yellow Ribbon, Chamecyparis Mops, Juniperus ‘Witchita Blue’, Erica golden joy, erica kramer's rote, carex evercolor everillo. This is my view from the dining room window facing South (we stare out this window all day/year long).

    I want a continuous screen of mostly evergreen shrubs about 5 ft tall. to soften the view of the cars, street, etc. This color theme wraps around the lawn to below the window, but with some more different plants (including cedrus "feeling blue").

    I'd like it be mostly green (shades of green, with the variety in texture), with some seasonal interest like a cool bark color, red fall leaves, etc. I prefer drought tolerant/low water.

    Thanks so much for the help!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    When a wall of conifers is being used a good scheme is three kinds, with one plant of a yellow kind in the center, flanked by two of a blue kind with the rest all a single green kind. This is more interesting than all one green kind, without being too much.

    However if you are going to continue with a mixed planting containing more than one type of plant then you might want a uniform green backdrop for more colorful plants in front.

    The main immediate problems I see with the existing proposal - as you have presented it here - is that there is too much yellow (and probably blue). And it does not provide the screening you want.

    Beyond that I again think you should tell your designer it's not what you want, try (again?) to make it clear what you do want. If that leads nowhere then get another designer - it would definitely be preferable to have someone come to the property and find out what is involved in person.

  • 8 years ago
    I like schemes that look like this:

    Mercer Island 1 · More Info
  • 8 years ago
    And this:

    Queen Anne · More Info
  • 8 years ago
    Great Plant Combinations · More Info
  • 8 years ago
    Kirkland Gardens · More Info
  • 8 years ago

    This is plan for the landscaping along a fence



    Gingko, 2 relocated spirea, purple smoke tree, Erica kramers rote, thuja yellow ribbon, carex, Chamecyparis ‘Mops’, Feijoa sellowiana,Hosta ‘Great Expectations’, Acer ‘Red Dragon’Geum Mango lassi

  • 8 years ago

    MZ, if you can activate your messaging option, I would like to reach out to you :-) Or you can contact me via my messaging option.

  • 8 years ago

    You can periodic foliage burn due to cold from pineapple guava this far north.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    My quick gut reaction to your picture "plan" is that the two large evergreens flanking the gate will become oppressive. Too much color variation & busy arrangement. Too narrow of a bed for all that material. would like to see some consistent groundcover transversing most or all of the bed. One presumes you want a lot of privacy from the street, not a landscape that invites passersby to look into the yard.

  • 8 years ago
    I agree with Yardvaark. Too narrow a bed for the plantings and those Junipers will become out of proportion to the rest of the plantings. Why not add a few deciduous shrubs that will add some spring, summer or fall interest and attract wildlife. As is, it looks a bit boring. I do applaud your desire to improve your view and privacy and the plan you have will minimize care. Sometimes the most difficult planting scheme is a bare canvas!
  • 8 years ago
    Cercis- you are so right. I think the blank canvas and uninspiring fence makes this especially difficult.

    When I said “continuous screen”, I don’t mean a wall of conifers that I can’t see through. I just want to soften the view with pretty green things and add some privacy to the yard. This is my “back yard” but we are on a corner lot so we’ve got the sidewalk. I hate to build a tall fence because none of our neighbors on either side of the street has a tall fence. Their front yards are open to the sidewalk/street and is has a nice neighborly feel.