Software
Houzz Logo Print
daniel_barecky

Cabinet Paint Quality Advice

8 years ago
Hi, I'm currently in my first remodel and unfortunately am learning a quality contractor is above all the most important decision. I believe I'm learning that lesson the hard way. My current contractor has said that he feels this is a good paint job and that it's the maple woods properties that's causing the dimples. Pretty much saying I'll have to deal with it.
Is this true that this type of finish is normal? Or is it something in the prep or painting process that's causing this issue?

Comments (50)

  • 8 years ago

    I think that's a crappy paint job. My cabinets are constructed out of paint grade maple and I painted them myself. Using off the shelf paint (BM Advance) and an inexpensive paint sprayer. My inexperienced paint job looks 1000% better than that. No dimples or drips at all. Are mine perfect? No. But I knew going in my efforts wouldn't result in a perfect professional job and I'm OK with that. If I had paid someone and the result looked like yours, I'd be unhappy.

    I'm not a painting expert so I'm not exactly sure what is causing the dimples on yours. I'd guess no primer or not enough primer. And not proper sanding between coats. Or maybe it dried in improper temps? Yours should be able to be salvaged though. I'd ask about applying a light coat of wood filler and then sanding them down, repriming and repainting.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I also would be upset by this. Did he spray or roll the cabinets?

    Are these old or new cabinets? (As is are you refinishing something existing?) Did he prime, and with what?

    For reference, we painted our kitchen cabinets ourselves last summer, and while they are not perfect--look considerably better than that.

    Ours were a light/natural stain pine or maple cabinet. I really did not want to strip and sand everything and with some homework found an excellent alternative and it turned out great! We just scrubbed the cabinets clean and let them dry well. Then primed with Khilz Adhesion primer (roller, 1 coat) and then painted with SW Pro classic paint (its about $75 a gallon with a contractor discount and took 1 gallon for a kitchen with quite a bit of cabinetry). It took two coats on the base, and we did a third coat on the doors just to make sure they were good. The paint dries within a few hours, but really does take a while to to really cure/harden. I chipped one spot the first week, fixed it, then we ended up traveling for several weeks after that. it allowed the paint time to really harden, and we have gone almost a year with no issues.

    Our contractor/handyman used this method in our in-laws house 5 years ago and other clients homes as well. Everyone seems happy with it.

    *if he rolled them, make sure he was using a very high grade roller made for doors/cabinetry.

    Another thing to think about is it may have to do with if the paint is latex or oil based. Many pros will do oil based in a sprayer for cabinets, which was out of the question for us due to being a DIY project, but we were told was hard to do, so maybe your contractor is not a pro at this particular skill if that was his method.

  • 8 years ago
    Hi thank you gthigpen and adparker for the responses!

    These were new cabinets, spray application, oil base paint, and the house had ac/heating if they needed to adjust temperatures.

    I guess the best option is to fire his painter and find a good painter but since Harvey hit Houston, seems it'll be hard to weed through the bad beginners.

    Attached a pic of the overall concept. I paid 15k for custom and was partially happy until the painting and now I feel it looks like a budget kitchen.
  • 8 years ago
    oh and adparker, they did prime, it appeared to be a primer from Sherman Williams, I'll get the paint brands later tonight. I'm thinking that they didn't sand, prime properly or they mixed to much thinner and the paint was too thin to have good coverage? But I'm glad you guys agree, contractor made me feel crazy like the paint job was normal.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    15K would be low for that for something Really Custom. 20-40K just for the cabinets would be more like it. The average cost for a Professional grade conversion varnish finish, not housepaint, mostly done Off Site, is 7-9K. Only the boxes would be done in house. And that is for a remodel.

    New cabinets should never be coated inside your house! The finishing costs almost as much as the construction of the cabinets. Or, it should. But that should be an invisible cost, because any cabinet maker who doesnt finish in his own in house clean room is a woodworker, not a cabinet maker. A cabinet maker wants to control the job from start to finish, because he is invested in the end result.

    That is pitiful.

    I’ll take a $1 bet that you are in, or closely located to, TX

  • 8 years ago
    @Sophie I'm trying to pull constructive info from your comment, what it seems you've said is that the job was pitiful. Thank you we both agree. I do live in Texas, Houston which Harvey effected. Ill take your advice in the future.. my budget should be higher and I should expect the cabinets to be done offsite by a true cabinet maker. Thank you for your comment.
  • 8 years ago
    @Sophie any advice on what will remedy the issue? I have another contractor scheduled tomorrow morning to try and correct things so I can't go anywhere now but forward with the mistakes I've made with selection and budget.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You can’t sand your way out of the completely wrong coating with the completely wrong application. That is a total remake. Or he can give your money back and you can buy better elsewhere since the cabinet guy doesn’t know how to finish properly. I’d go buy Medallion.

  • 8 years ago

    Sophie is over the top as usual. $15k seems high for a kitchen that size, unless there is more work involved than what I can see in the picture. I haven't used oil based paint in many years, but this looks like an atomization issue. This is not a problem with the wood. The paint when applied properly should level itself out and become one consistent film. Those holes are signs that this isn't happening. This is why most professional spray painters will use fine finish tips which help with atomization. Proper temperature and pressure setting on the sprayer is also important. Good spray painters know how to adjust on the fly to deliver a professional job. No job is the same when you are working in the field so small adjustments may be required. Also, it could be that the paint just wasn't applied heavy enough. Perhaps they were scared of going too heavy because of getting sags and runs, but going too light isn't good either. There is a chance that you can solve this problem by lightly sanding and applying a proper fully atomized coating, but it becomes difficult when you realize that you are dealing with painters that might not know what they are doing.

  • 8 years ago
    Thank you Paintguy and Sophie. The likely option will be to reapply. It is very unlikely I'll have the contractor agree to refund the cabinets in full, I doubt the bank contract even specifies quality so I'm stuck. I'm going to also try to find a construction lawyer, if there is such a thing, to see what legal options are available.
  • 8 years ago

    I've gotta look & see if I can find my entry-windows trim I did a few years ago. Used FPE stuff..... Enduit/Brushing-Putty, their Oil primer, sanding, & 2 coats of ECO.

    Just wanted to see how good a job I could do! :-)

    Faron

  • 8 years ago

    Sophie, I'm really curious where you are located that custom cabinets are that expensive? My mom is currently building a custom home- and between her kitchen, 3 baths, 2 sets of built ins, and laundry/pantry storage--she only came in around 30k. And might I add that includes all soft close and in cabinet organization.


    daniel- asked a friend who flips homes about this. His thoughts were in line with paintguy. Hoping that the issue can be resolved with some sanding and another coat--best of luck!

  • 8 years ago
    Thank you adparker, I really appreciate you taking the time to ask a friend. As home owners, especially the ones new to contractors and remodeling, don't know what to expect until it's going/gone wrong.

    I'll update you guys with what the new paint contractor says tomorrow.
  • 8 years ago
    @Faron I'll look into those products. Thank you also for the pointers.
  • 8 years ago


    I replaced the wood under there after this! Look where the dime is laying tho'... :-)

    See?! I don't just blab about stuff unless I've DONE it! :-)

    Faron


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Edi here- Oh my!! Not even close to a decent paint job... Using a thinner does not help in final texture. Using a self leveling paint like Flotrol (for latex) is imparative. I am not certain my android will take a good close up pic of the kitchen cabinets that I did myself last year. The existing cabinets were new maple but I hate dark colors. Especially in a kitchen. Or in this very small kitchen.

    The dark is the original. The last is a closeup that I just took- smooth finish if it shows in pic. Sanded original thoroughly. Two coats SW Bond Primer. Used SW Pro Classic. Three coats. One coat per day. Each with Flotrol using a best quality very short nap roller then let it dry minimum of one week. Then 2 coats Minwax Ultimate Clear Floor Finish (only clear finish that will not yellow over time and is rock hard). Let that also dry for a week before handling. Still need to decide on cabinet/drawer pulls... I have done a whole kitchen before and it held up well- 2 rottweilers. great dane, cat, sometimes a calf, foal or kid goats in kitchen when had slow start in cold Cody Wyoming winters for 12 years. Then this kitchen in damp Florida. Your current 'pro' painter needs to redo. My 2 cents worth! Forgot to add what a klutz I can be due to an injury that makes me drop things against lower cabinets usually or opening cab door too hard so that it slams against other door. No damage due to type of paints/additives/final clear coat made for floors.

  • 8 years ago

    All of the voodoo recipes and extra work when all that is needed is the right custom guy with his own off site paint booth and a conversion varnish. There isn’t anything tougher with twice the work.

  • 8 years ago

    Some people like to do their own projects- as we do when able to. As newly retired, we now have more time than God to xo things that we could not do when working. The yard is another fun area. Just need help with extremely heavy things. When E's father retired he and her mom bought a small 1800's estate in Georgia that they restored. Her father loved woodworking especially. Piece by piece/room by room came back to life. E's favorite restoration was the carriage barn! Doing things yourself bring a great feeling to many of us- and is many times superior than having a 'professional' do the job. It is called 'hobby'.

  • 8 years ago

    So, learn to spray the right stuff if you want a hobby. There is zero point in hand digging a water line trench when a Ditch Witch can do it 100x as fast and better. Work smarter, not harder.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Did the first guy add anything like Floetrol before spraying it on? If not, tell the next guy to use it. I've sprayed new cabinets before and Floetrol will fix lots of issues exactly like that.

    And no you don't have to throw them out and start over fresh. You (or the new guy) will definitely need to sand down that poor finish though. Get a good orbital sander and some gritty sandpaper - once through that bubbly layer, finish with some ~300 grit, wipe them down and respray.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sorry Sophie- have no desire to spray- I like the perfection of doing it the old fashion way! No need to hurry anymore!

  • 8 years ago
    hey guys so I did take your guys advice and fired old and hired a new cabinet builder/painter to try and fix all of the mistakes onsite.

    I can't follow Sophies advice since it's already installed and I'm not rebuilding/replacing but I will definitely remember her advice.

    Paintguy and Faron when I looked at the primer the old guys used latex primer and oil paint. Big no no from what you guys mentioned. Same result on both coats, So just fired them.

    dRad, the guys I fired did not use any flotrol/paint flattener of any kind.

    New guy is sanding everything down and starting from scratch regarding paint. Then he's priming and touching up any imperfections and painting. I'll update you guys with the results. As I quizzed new painters I listed for much of what you guys mentioned..

    Faron you window sill looks good as did your kitchen Ed. I appreciate the guidance and inspiration.
  • 8 years ago

    DB-

    Oh my!! Latex primer....with Oil on TOP?!?!? Oh dear.....

    IF you decide on FPE products, you won't need any leveling additive if you're brushing!! A newer-generation leveler is "Latex X-tender" by XIM. ACE stores can order it. I've got it in my paint area.

    Here's the qt. I used in my lower bath....


    HERE'S the pic I wanted of the entry-trim paint! Used the ECO-Brilliant White on the side-lite trim.
    Faron

  • 8 years ago

    Hello - also painting new cabinets in Texas post Harvey. I’m just here to add a curveball idea... after new paint job is complete if you are still not thrilled consider perhaps doing a distressed / glazed look (this will hide a great deal of imperfections). The paint forums on houzz are very informative but often don’t line up w real life experience / options in our area. Painters are in top demand around here right now and vary greatly in bids, quality and technique. And contrary to what some would have us believe no the bid does not always dictate the result. Good luck and hang in there - paint means you are nearly at the end of a VERY long journey. God bless.

  • 8 years ago

    Sanding all of that back to bare wood will be more expensive than buying new cabinets and starting over. Not sanding it to bare wood will mean that the threat of future adhesion issues will always remain.

  • 8 years ago
    Sophie, respectfully you're not giving advice I can follow at this point.
  • 8 years ago
    Sophie in the future I'll try and post in the planning stages and hopefully you'll still be around giving advice. it's appreciated just unable to do the things suggested this late in the remodel.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    So, have that all sanded to bare wood. Latex primer on bare wood will always haunt you otherwise. It’s a permanent issue, and you don’t know if things are going to just peel off at some inopportune time without going through at least a season of standard humidity changes.

    The labor for that from anyone worth hiring will be more than replacement costs. It’s tons more work to fix problems than prevent them. But maybe you could get money refunded from the first painter for ruining them.

  • 8 years ago

    Floetrol is not required, so don't get freaked out if your new painters tell you that they are not using an extender. Also, using a clear finish of any kind over paint is not required. It's not even beneficial really. The paint itself has the shiny finish built into it and when you slap some finish on top of that, there may be compatability problems there which are just not worth the risk. Using high quality washable paints is all you need to do.

  • 8 years ago
    So how do your cabinets look now. What method did the painters end up using to fix the problem.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Paint guy- don't know if you referring to clear coat for 'shine'. In my case it is not- it is strictly for a harder surface than paint has. I/we are not particularly careful with cabinets but want them to look good. We have large dogs that can scrape with their metal tags, hard toys. Currently one rott is in a hard ecollar for 3 weeks due to injury. Hard ecollars scrape cabinets/anything. Small grandkids with toys/scooter in kitchen also when here. There are times there are foals, a calf ,kid goats in the kitchen for a short time. Small kitchen in current house means infractions. Next build= bigger kitchen. If I ever had stained cabinets I would still apply finish coat. Floetrol gives slower paint settle which gives you more time to correct a flawed stroke. It does make a difference. I also hope the original poster tells us how her cabinets come out.

  • 8 years ago
    Hi, I promise to update with repainted cabinets. It's taking a while to get it completed.
  • 8 years ago

    Floetrol can make a difference, yes. I'm just saying it's not like all painters use it, especially when spraying. The paint sprays just fine without it. Also, if you are using a high quality paint with a sheen, adding a shiny finish on top of that is not going to increase your durability. Applying a clear coat on top of some junky paint may make it more durable, but why not just use the high quality paint to begin with?

  • 8 years ago

    Wishing you success in getting the cabinets repainted, hopefully a new contractor can help you get this all sorted so you can have the kitchen you want. People forget may of us on this site are not professionals. We have to learn by trial and error and don't have unlimited funds to spend. I feel badly you are going through this. I have painted cabinets in a past reno myself and they came out fantastic. I spent weeks prepping the doors, filling in old marks, scuffs, divots etc to create a perfectly sanded door which would take a primer. I almost wonder if your painter did not prep the doors properly. But you say he has done this before.. Maybe he is using a new or different product. In any case sounds like you are unhappy with the results which may be more than just the paint, it might be the contractor. Wishing you success in this project.


    Here is a link that I have used to help me

    https://www.thisoldhouse.com/how-to/pro-secrets-painting-kitchen-cabinets

  • 8 years ago
    Here are a few more pictures.
  • 8 years ago

    Looks great!

  • 8 years ago

    Those look so much better! I’m happy you found someone to correct the work satisfactorily. Yay!

  • 8 years ago

    Lovely kitchen! So happy to hear and see the update

  • 8 years ago

    WHOO HOOOO that is a fantastic improvement. It is wonderful you found a talented painter!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Looks so much better!!

  • 8 years ago
    still trying to get everything completed with the remodel but heres the kitchen.
  • 8 years ago
    Looks beautiful!! What a great job! Are the island cabinets a natural wood finish? It’s hard to tell in the second two photos. Or were they painted black?
  • 8 years ago
    The island is stained, the darker pic is just to show the pendants/lighting accents when dark.
  • 8 years ago
    oh the stain is a minwax mixture of jacobean, weathered gray, and a little ebony.
  • 7 years ago

    Daniel- I know this is an old post, but do you remember how much sanding your painter ended up doing? Did he go all the way back to the bare wood? Or did he just do enough to remove the bumps/clumps, and orange peel and make it smooth?

  • 7 years ago

    Looks great! I'd love to see a pic of your finished kitchen. Btw, what is the wall paint color?

  • 7 years ago

    Andi, they did a lot of sanding to remove a majority of the paint all the way down to the wood, they used Sherman William's Bondo Glazing & Spot Putty to hind imperfections, applying about 2-3 coats sanding between each coat.

  • 3 years ago

    Hi Daniel. Beautiful kitchen and I am glad you were able to resolve the initial poor painting job with your cabinets.
    How are your cabinets holding up now? Any issues with using oil-based paint and not conversion varnish? Asking because I recently completed an expensive remodel and had my new cabinets painted in-house with SW oil-based paint. Discovered Houzz after the cabinets were painted and everything I read on here makes me think my cabinets will be a wreck because they weren’t finished off-site with conversion varnish. I am hoping that’s not true. It’s been almost a year and so far, so good, but in the back of my mind, I worry that I will have an expensive mess on my hands with peeling paint, etc.
    Take care and thanks!

  • 3 years ago

    @TXBuckeye - First, there is a reason that most industrialized countries have banned true conversion varnish for consumer products. Even China has added Xylene (the catalyst in conversion varnish) to the ban list. It should be banned for U.S. consumer goods and even four years ago, when this thread was started, we knew it was bad. Additionally, it is not something that any manufacturer would allow being sprayed in a home.

    So you certainly shouldn't be upset that your cabinets were not sprayed with conversion varnish. At this point 2k polyurethanes are dominating the market for a good reason and even then I wouldn't spray it in an occupied home.

    ---

    Now, to your point... Houzz is sometimes a problematic resource for things like this as it lacks any real perspective. Certainly, various commercial/industrial coatings are stronger than oil based paints. However, it is not the difference that people often pretend. There are cabinets with oil based paint chugging along and looking great for over 100 years. It is just a kitchen, you are spilling milk and not industrial solvents. Most people will not see any durability difference between a good oil based paint and an industrial coating. Their cabinets look great today and will continue to look great. There are a small percentage of people who will see a coatings failure from oil based paints that wouldn't see that failure from conversion varnish or 2k poly's. However, those coatings also have failures, e.g. many 2k polyurethanes struggle with coffee stains.

    In the end, you have what you have. If it doesn't fail there is no need to worry about it, and if it does there is no guarantee it failed only because it is oil based. Having said that, oil based paints tend to yellow some over time and that is the real problem most people have with them.

    ---

    A piece of advice for those who are having cabinets sprayed. Find a good painter who has taken the time to inform themselves on coatings and try to listen to them. Application errors are far more likely than coatings failures. I suspect that most will be spraying some post catalyzed water based coating such as a 2k polyurethane, but so long as they are able to discuss the various coatings and have a good reason they chose the one they did, then I would listen... unless they settled on Xylene catalyzed conversion varnish and in that case I would kick them to the curb.