Software
Houzz Logo Print
mcpherson007

Would a sisal rug work in this room?

8 years ago
I would like a new rug in this room. I have sisal in adjoining foyer and dining room. Would it be too much of the same?

Comments (29)

  • 8 years ago

    Too much of the same, and it would turn your very lovely room to a very bland one, I think.

    mcpherson007 thanked groveraxle
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Grover, I appreciate your expertise very much.

  • 8 years ago
    The cluttered mantel and whatever that thing is on the wall above it are at odds with the finesse of the rest of the space.
  • 8 years ago

    Wow, that is a very old fashioned room. No, I would not put a sisal rug in there, that would match nothing that you currently have in there. I agree that you need a new area rug, but I would stick with something more traditional. And then I would think about removing at least the most dated pieces in that room like the table with a table cloth over it and the overly ornate wall hanging over the couch. Then remove that strange wall scone and do some matching art on either side of the windowed door for symmetry.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago


    Kinda blah, don't you think?

    mcpherson007 thanked groveraxle
  • 8 years ago

    I like it.. thanks Grover! but I respect your advice. I think the rug I have now is too formal.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Anne I agree, and I will modify the mantle! the magnolia wreath is left over from Christmas. I did not think it was that bad.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    How about something a little edgier?

    Maison Rouge Eliot Handmade Floral Blue Area Rug (8' x 10') - Free Shipping Toda · More Info

  • 8 years ago
    Yes. I like the rug, but the color is a little too bold. I am not sure about the blue.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Accessory love · More Info

    I would look for a less formal rug that still carried in some colour. While I typically love a natural fibre rug (especially in a diamante or other pattern) in a formal room,just don't think it will work that well here. Unless you are planning other changes?

  • 8 years ago
    Your rug is BEAUTIFUL. The problem is your wall color IMO.
  • 8 years ago
    We had to finish the kitchen later so will finish kitchen later for P will be happy for the owner be happy
  • 8 years ago

    Hi mcpherson007

    Your baby in your photo is adorable!

    You say you want a less formal look in a rug than the one you have now-

    Do you want a less formal look in the room as a whole as well?

    Can you show us a photo of an inspiration room that has the look you want to achieve?

    That might make it easier for us to suggest a floor covering for you.

    Thanks!

  • 8 years ago
    We had to finish the kitchen next week for March 29 so I’ll be back on Monday and Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
  • 8 years ago
    loobab I like the room, but not the rug so much. I inherited the rug and it’s not my look.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I realize you want light and airy but there is a problem when the room is two stories, it feels like a cavern. So I gave you visual of going slightly darker with the color. And NO to putting down a sisal rug in that room over the rug that you have, that would be a “felony.” You’d manslaughter the room. LOL. HOWEVER, I hear you as we get ready for spring and summer that you might want something lighter. It actually was very common in grand houses to put the wool rugs up for the summer. So you could use your wool rug after Labor Day until Easter and then the sisal from Easter to Labor Day. I would think about an overmantel mirror to add to the wow. There are always some nice ones on Ebay. What I did when I had a room like yours was to take brown butcher paper and do a mock up of the mirror above the mantel to see what size I would like. It saved a lot of trips and mistakes.

  • 8 years ago
    How about a sea grass rug? They have different patterns (like chevron) and fabric borders. The material is hardy like sisal but much softer, and the right weave could add interest and texture.

    Since this is clearly a sitting room, it might be nice to pull the sofa forward and put a console table behind it. If you have the budget, trade out the two chairs for trendier matching chairs. You’d probably still have room for the wood one closer to sofa, by windows.

    Also I would recommend some color on the wall. What is your favorite color and would it look good with the green sofa?
  • 8 years ago
    Bellburgmaggie Thanks I appreciate the paint ideas, I agree I may change that too. I do have a big mirror over the couch. Do you think It would look better over the mantle?
  • 8 years ago
    Too many pillows and the cover on your round table doesn't do anything for the room.
  • 8 years ago
    Hollybar I love your rug but I think in my room it would be to much all the same color.
  • 8 years ago
    I work for the room for the dog P on it and scratch it
  • 8 years ago

    andrewvidela, what are you talking about?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Hi mcpherson007

    Is this living room the look you are going for? This is a Southern Traditional look, made less formal by the coffee table.

    https://www.southernliving.com/home-garden/decorating/traditional-family-friendly-decorating-ideas#traditional-southern-family-room

    (Sorry, I can't seem to copy the pics in here.)

    You could get an are rug like this, in a seafoam green (or however you would describe your color) with white or ecru pattern or a criss-cross, or trellis or quadrefoil, something like that on the green as shown in the above article. What would be a bit more interesting is if you used a slightly deeper hue than exactly matching your upholstery. (Again, apologies for not being able to copy the photo directly into this column, but if you click on the link, the article with the photos pops right up.)

    If I may make some more suggestions to give your room a more vibrant and today look and feel,

    Your room would be additionally enhanced by swapping out two of the animal print cushions on the sofa for cushions incorporating a deeper green, and you can use the green of your beautiful plant or the green of the new rug.

    You can mix the deeper green with the seafoam, use a velvet for wonderful texture, for example. I would also do that in exchange for the large cushion on the chair that has the simple grey and white print.

    You might want to rethink the lamps. I can't see the lamp to the immediate right of the entrance, but from what I can see, the shade is could be improved. If the lamp base itself is appropriate you can replace the shade for one that does not have that kind of dated curve.

    The pair of lamps, the one to the left of the entrance and the other behind the chair on the right look too fussy and formal, just like the rug you want to take out. Please keep your eyes open at tag sales for another pair that has simple clean lines. You can always get a substitute shade if the shade it comes with is not in good condition.

    You can lighten your look by substituting the brown underskirt on your side table for a cream one to match your curtains.

    Another thing you might want to look for at tag sales and consignment shops is a really good (but reasonably priced) wood side table that is a recognizably high quality vintage piece. It doesn't have to be antique (over 100 years old). It can be a very good reproduction, and it doesn't have to be of a specific period, either. It just has be be superbly made in very good condition, or restorable to very good condition. You would put this in place of your current side table to the right of the entrance which is too similar to your cocktail table. (Matchy-matchy furniture is not congruent with the well-lived, gracious style of lovely things accumulated over time and generations.)

    You can put artwork over your mantel or a mirror. If you choose art work either over the mantel or over your sofa, it would be a great idea to incorporate at least one of its colors in your throw pillows as well.

    It's difficult to see the mirror over your sofa. If it is truly lovely, then you might want to hang it over your mantel where people will really look at it, and it will reflect the art work you will hang over your sofa.

    Is that my imagination, or are the candles in the candlesticks on the decorative brackets leaning against the wall? You could try a few things to get them to stand straight. You could try crumpling a small piece of aluminum foil in the opening of the candlestick around the candle to take up some space and serve to cushion the candle, and additionally, melt a little wax under the candle and hold it there while the wax solidifies to hold it in place, or use some Quake Hold to hold the candle in place, and still crumple some foil around it.

  • 8 years ago

    if you want to recycles the pieces that are in the room the mirror over the sofa could be placed over the FP along with a pair of sconces if space will allow.

    see ref pic

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I think having a flat rug is the right way to go, but a bit of a pattern could benefit the room. IMO it's time to give the room an accessory update.

    mcpherson007 thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Further to my remarks above a change of table and lamp to the right of the sofa will freshen the space. changing the mirror to over the fireplace will leave space over the sofa for the framed picture seen at the back to the right next to the french doors. Ideally a pair of these would look nice over the sofa.
    .Also, I see quite a bit of wrought iron. You could change this up by adding another lamp to the table while still keeping the integrity of yr space.

    ref pic for table or similar and lamp

    this is not the lamp i wanted to show.

    Where is the edit button???

  • 8 years ago

    pic of table

    Wooden Round Accent Table · More Info

  • 8 years ago
    Wow, to all the comments it has to be overwhelming to the OP. IMO I would find a painting to place over the sofa and get a proper over mantel mirror over the fireplace. This is a sitting tea room and having been raised in the UK I got i t.
    mcpherson007 thanked gtcircus
Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations