Software
Houzz Logo Print
astro777

Eat at table or counter height?

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

We have a dated laminate two-height island. The top part is the island, the lower part is the same type of counter, but is used for eating right in the kitchen (sitting in regular chairs).

I want new counters and I KNOW that simply extending the island counter (in quartz or granite) would LOOK better.

However, my hubby and I are torn about whether we want to sit at counter height every.single.day. We have a dining room but rarely use it as the kitchen is just so convenient and has a better view.

So. Is it crazy to put in a two-height island counter when putting in expensive new counters? And is it doable with quartz/granite? Or maybe I should do the lower part in wood?

Comments (12)

  • 8 years ago

    I prefer to eat at table height, but since I am recovering from knee surgery and I am tall, I am currently eating at the counter. But I want to go back to table height ASAP.

    Donna E thanked artemis_ma
  • 8 years ago

    I dislike counter height and really prefer table height. Post pics when you’re done - good luck!

    Donna E thanked cyc2001
  • 8 years ago

    I also prefer table height. I do not understand how anyone likes the counter height seating (no offense to anyone).

    Donna E thanked sherri1058
  • 8 years ago

    I like counter height for a quick cup of coffee or for breakfast but for dinner we prefer table height.

    Donna E thanked cpartist
  • 8 years ago

    I prefer sitting at a table over a counter, too.

    You could do the table height portion in wood. These are beautiful examples of that.

    Thames Dr. · More Info


    Highgate Kitchen · More Info


    The Cliffs at Mountain Park: Private Residence · More Info


    Contemporary Kitchen · More Info


    Clontarf | Modern Kitchen · More Info


    VP Interiors 2010 · More Info


    Barton Hills · More Info


    Contemporary Classicism · More Info

    This one isn't quite table height but it could be.

    Transitional White Kitchen in NY · More Info

    Or you could top it with marble and make it double as a baking center.

    Additions and Renovation - Oley, PA · More Info

    Donna E thanked lisa_a
  • 8 years ago

    I prefer counter height.

    bad knees and as you get older easier to slide off a stool.

    Donna E thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    @lisa_a, wow those are some great inspiration photos! Thanks so much! It's great to know that if we do table height seating in wood it's not totally crazy.

    I think I personally would be fine with either but we're trying to decide if my hubby would he okay with the counter height. I kind of doubt it and don't want to make an expensive mistake.

    Interesting how people really prefer one over the other!

  • 8 years ago

    Can you feet reach the floor if you are sitting on a counter top stool or chair?

    Is the counter top stool or chair as comfortable as a table height chair?

    I am way more comfortable sitting at a table than a counter and I have bad knees :-). Regular chairs - especially if you get comfortable chairs with arms and backs for seating are not difficult for elderly people to get out of. I am way more uncomfortable perched on a stool with my legs dangling - are you planning to put in a foot rest along the bottom of the counter side? LOL

    Donna E thanked Helen
  • 8 years ago

    Wow, these comments and the photos are really making me rethink my plan. Thanks!

    I thought our island was hopelessly outdated and counter height was the only way to go. But I don't think my dear hubby will like it.

    Now I think we might persue the lower table height part, done in wood. Certainly worth considering.

  • 8 years ago

    It seems as though functionally, your family would be more comfortable with a table height counter.

    Your only issue is whether it will appear "dated" or not be on trend - i.e. whether aesthetically it will somehow be embarrassing :-)

    The pictures posted above show that a table height counter top can be aesthetically beautiful - especially in the wood contrast you are contemplating.

    Therefore, to me, it's a no brainer as there is no functional or aesthetic reason NOT to go with a wood table height counter.

    Donna E thanked Helen
  • 8 years ago

    It depends on how much counter space you need. I went from a two level island (counter and bar heights) to a solid counter height. We sit there all. the. time. And I love all the extra counter prep space when I'm working in the kitchen.

    But if you don't need the counter space, the table height options are very nice as well.

    Donna E thanked gotgoatmilk