Software
Houzz Logo Print
lsiebs

Paint wood trim in kitchen?

8 years ago

For the past month my husband and I have been renovating our 100+-year-old house, and today we had new quartz countertops installed in the kitchen. We kept the previous owners' maple shaker cabinets because they're in great shape, and we ripped up the old vinyl flooring to refinish the original maple floors underneath.


The result is.... a maple explosion. To add to the intense wood look, the previous owners used dark wood trim around the windows, doors and baseboards (the baseboards are currently ripped out as the floors are still being refinished). I'm debating if I should paint the dark trim white or leave it alone. The walls are painted Sherwin Williams Roycroft Vellum.


There is beautiful original wood trim throughout the living room, entryway and a sunroom in this house, but the previous owners painted over the wood trim in the dining room, so we have an odd mix of white and dark wood trim throughout the first floor.


Here's the kitchen in its current state. I'm thinking of doing a white/off-white arabesque tile backsplash above the counters, but that's an entirely separate issue. Any thoughts on whether or not to paint the dark trim are much appreciated!





I'm also considering ripping out this piece above the kitchen sink, although we'd lose some lighting by doing this:



Entry into the dining room, where you can see some of the trim that's been painted:




A before pic of the kitchen, for good measure:




Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    I would paint it.

    Lauren thanked Krista S.
  • 8 years ago

    I would paint it because I don't like the contrast with the white windows.

  • 8 years ago

    My grandmother's house was a beautiful little craftsman with wood trim in the living room, dining room and hall, but white trim in the kitchen, and I think the bedroom trims matched the wallpaper:) The overall look of the home went together so it was not startling to go from one room to another. Many really old home dating back to the 1700's have different color trim in every room. Older homes get to have a little more leeway with design - the evolution of a home over time - just try to keep the look cohesive. The dining room looks a little cold compared to the kitchen - but your home and your call:)

    Lauren thanked jhmarie
  • 8 years ago
    Paint trim and remove valance! It will look great! Also, go with a lighter tone backsplash. A glass subway tile would be nice.
    Lauren thanked Bri Bosh
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    absolutely paint it. it's too dark to go w/everything. you have an updated, modern kitchen. doesn't make sense to keep 'old' trim. besides, that trim is not original to the home.

    yes, remove the valance over the sink. you can hang a pendant over the sink.

    I'd also paint the trim and the new baseboard a neutral white. not a creamy white. a neutral, nice white. Simply White or even white dove

    what is the weird window on that one wall? could you put in a single, glass door in that spot?

  • 8 years ago

    Hi Beth, that odd window on the wall doesn’t go directly outside, it actually looks into a vestibule/staircase going down into the basement. Previous owners hung a small piece of stained glass there. Then to the side of that window, we have this door leading into the back vestibule/staircase. It’s a little weird but came with the territory of the old house!

    I was thinking we’d do Sherwin Williams Westhighland White for the trim, to match the living/dining room, but I’ll see if that’s too creamy with the countertops.

  • 8 years ago

    Yes to paint and yes to remove the thing above the sink.

  • 8 years ago

    Don't remove the "floating shelf" someone called a "wood valance" -- by whatever name, it's potentially useful for more than just much needed lighting. One option might be to add a pair of glass doors or even just one door with a top hinge and make the shelf a cabinet.

    Since it's probably costly and impractical to strip the painted trim, I'd at least want it all painted white.

    Not a fan of fixed windows -- would want to change that for a window that opens or, if there's a porch on the other side, perhaps a patio door.

    Lauren thanked suezbell