I'm kind of a symmetry person so 3 look better to me. That's just me. Both look good to me.

I like the three Windows for sure. I would not do black Windows. Stick with white.

3 windows, all board and batten siding. I love board and batten siding and feel it adds an interesting character to a home.

I really like Beverly's suggestion. Of your two options, the 3 windows. I think white windows not black would coordinate better with the white trim, I wouldn't get rid of the brick.

In a different post OP mentioned that the front is two separate rooms. With that in mind I say three windows.

3 and keep them as one unit, there can be casing between the units so they appear as one or spread the iambs

I do not agree they should be 3 separate windows if your mock up is what you want this is going to be more “modern farmhouse “ than what the rest of the house is so I would rethink black windows and I would do board and batten everywhere unless all the windows are being changed and that will open a whole other can of worms .

All windows in house are being replaced. Considered black windows like rawketgrl’s pic. Seems most don’t agree with the black windows. Still indecisive about keeping brick and starting board and batten above it or just removing all Brick.

Definitely 3

I like Bev's idea as well. I would not do board and baton unless I was redoing the all the siding, maybe not even then.

Cute house! I definitely prefer the symmetry of the three windows. I would do white windows. Board and batten siding.