Those seem like very low quotes. I paid nearly $1000 per window (including inside painting) for Marvin windows about 7 years ago.

I wonder if I should go with the Pella 250 series?

I would go with the 100 series Andersen every day of the week over anything Jeldwen or Pella. Just my .02..................

Did you just edit that last question Michelle? Didn't it just say Andersen 100 series?

haha I did millworkman. Not sure what is better hahaha and so many options

When we replaced all of the windows in our 100 year old house, we were newbies and went with Pella Architecture series because they had such a great reputation in our area (Philadelphia). I really don't like them. Many of the panes have some gray goopy putty like material leaking from them and they are very difficult to open/close. We have Marvins in our mudroom addition and Anderson 400 series at the beach and they are much better.

"Not sure what is better hahaha and so many options"

Andersen 100 Series from those choices..........................

Thank you all! we are going with Andersen 100 Series :)

We'd be happy to answer any questions for you, Michelle.

Are these casements or double/single hungs?

i think the 100 casement is a nice unit , the single hungs are side loaded with pockets sills which I am not quite fond of.

We are going black exterior with Marvin Integrity.

Anything but Jeld-Wen, horrible customer service.