Software
Houzz Logo Print
emily3907

Can't decide on countertop material!

8 years ago

My husband and I have went back and forth so much on deciding what material to use. We recently moved into a new home and we are re-doing the kitchen piece by piece. Next step is counters.


Quartz is just out of the budget right now.

We seriously considered solid surface (LG HiMacs to be specific).

We are now leaning towards granite (Silver Pearl aka Gray Steel).


I have always had laminate counters, so I am "trained" to always use hot pads/trivets and cutting boards. I honestly would use a cutting board, regardless of surface, because I want to protect my knives.


There are just so many pros and cons to each surface and I am having a hard time deciding what to get.


The granite installer we would use is very highly regarded and installs granite all over our city with amazing reviews. We would also have the ability to hand pick our slab from the yard.


If we went with HiMacs, we would probably use the installer that our local Lowe's contracts through (which is where we would purchase from).


The one thing that keeps me going back to HiMacs is the ability to repair if need be. My major concern is the install process (I have read with this surface it is all about installation) and the scratch resistance.


With granite, I wouldn't have to worry about the scratches as much but, I worry about staining. It is also near impossible to repair granite.


I use my kitchen a lot and I have never had a need to repair a countertop. I am pretty careful with everything and I am good about wiping things up as they happen. I also wipe down my counters at least once a day.


I just can't decide what is right for our lifestyle.


Is there something I need to consider that you won't find/hear about through a sales person? :-)



Comments (26)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    There are pros and cons with every countertop. It's all about just figuring out what you personally can live with. I'd lean more towards granite, simply because if and when you ever go to sell it will be a selling feature and people love natural stone.

    emily3907 thanked Sina Sadeddin Architectural Design
  • 8 years ago

    I love natural stone provided it is not very busy. I don't like not being able to see crumbs and small spills/drops of junk. I would choose Gray Steel granite over Silver Pearl myself.

    I like Corian/solid surface much more than I like quartz. I prefer plain white solid surface, though. I have an aversion to materials masquerading as something they are not.

    My two cents, go with Gray Steel granite. Use trivets. Get a slightly rounded profile to avoid chipping and see if you need to seal the stone (though I doubt it.)

    emily3907 thanked Rita / Bring Back Sophie 4 Real
  • 8 years ago

    My husband is pretty much sold on the granite. He likes the darker surface with our off-white cabinets for contrast. Whereas, if I went with solid surface, I would probably go with HiMacs White Quartz or Cloud.

    I have been assured by many that the off-white cabinets and dark gray of the granite counters is a classic combo that will last through the years. I have also always loved Ina Garten's white cabinet and dark counter combo.

    While we are putting together a kitchen we love, we are also trying to go with a more classic look that won't be dated in 5 years. It won't be often that I will be able to talk the husband into kitchen updates like this! ;-)

  • 8 years ago

    @Rita - that was also always my hang up with granite. I also don't like busy counters. I like being able to see what needs to be wiped up. That was the issue with the counters we have now. Way too busy for my taste (plus the previous owner burnt the edges of the counters around the stove).

    When I saw these gray counters that were consistent in color and pattern (as much as granite can be), that is what started to sway me to granite.

  • 8 years ago

    With the granite you are looking at, you're not likely to have trouble with staining. You clean up promptly and can have it sealed. Its rather dark and has "splotches" which will help to disguise any staining you do get. If you like the look, go for it.

    emily3907 thanked kariyava
  • 8 years ago
    Here's a before/after collage of my kitchen. We went with leathered steel grey granite on the perimeter counters. (It's also called brushed, same thing as leathered) and I LOVE it. Easy to clean, doesn't show fingerprints or dust... and... I HAVE had repairs done (tiny chips around the sink, a simple eased edge looks nice but chips easily FYI) and you can't see them. ;) Seriously, they're really hard to find. The repairs just blend right in. I can't speak to how a polished finish would be with repairs (or fingerprints or dust) but the leathered finish is just fantastic. Oh, and I have had zero issues with staining or oil marks, and I'm a messy cook with a large family (of messy people, arghhhh!!!! LOL!) Lets just say that my kitchen isn't babied.
    emily3907 thanked skmom
  • 8 years ago

    Are the cabinets new that you are putting the granite on?

  • 8 years ago

    @Catt Combs - thanks for that info. As I said, the granite fabricator we would be working with gets really good reviews and based on reviews is very good about client satisfaction. We were told (by an unbiased party) that they replaced an entire island top (at no extra cost) for a client because the client was unhappy with a spot on her island. Even after she did not pick out the slab herself.

    @skmom - Thanks for those photos. We are considering the leathered finish as well. My husband isn't sure he loves the texture of it, so we are still deciding.

  • 8 years ago

    @jck910 - No. They are the original cabinets that we have painted. The cabinets were in really good shape and I hated to get rid of them.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    "any decent fabricator can repair anything granite throws your way"


    Except toilet bowl cleaner or a hot pot circle. Not a problem with solid surface, but can be death to stone or engineered stone. Don't make me post the pictures, please.

  • 8 years ago

    Have you looked at Absolute Black? You can have it leathered and/or honed which keeps fingerprints and lint from being a huge problem. My understanding is that you should avoid AB from India- but Brazil, I think, not certain, is the real deal.

    Other nice black counters are Virginia Mist and Via Lactea. Honed finishes are best for these too.

  • 8 years ago

    I have looked at Absolute Black. My fabricator currently has a nice honed slab, but I have not seen it in person yet.

    I have not seen Virginia Mist, but my fabricator does have Jet Mist (both honed and polished). That is one I am wanting to see in person for sure.


  • 8 years ago

    Do not do AB . the seams on it will look terrible. Jet mist is much better.

    @ Joseph. Been in business for 15+ years. Never encountered toilet bowl cleaner. & our hot pot circles only occur on quartz

    emily3907 thanked Mrs. Gopher #BringBackSophie
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks @ Catt Combs!

    Jet Mist definitely looks more like my style. I will have to see what is available. AB is okay, but I want a *little* bit of design in the granite, just not too much. AB doesn't have enough going on (at least from what I have seen on samples).

  • 8 years ago

    AB lives to its name it is absolute black. nothing much else happening. Maybe try a negressco polished or honed too.

  • 8 years ago

    Also, where are you located i would love to show you around my yard?


  • 8 years ago

    I am in southern Indiana.

  • 8 years ago

    oh poo. Well I hope you find something you love!

  • 8 years ago

    Have you considered soapstone? It handles heat effortlessly, cleans up easily, doesn't stain, and if it scratches, you can sand it out yourself. It runs much cheaper in TN than granite (though it's not as hard).

  • 8 years ago

    I honestly have not considered soapstone. Looking at some photos though, I am intrigued. I will have to do some research.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    granite is all but bulletproof. really. some of the very white, light granites have had some staining issues, but any of the darker ones will be fine. I've had mine for 13 years and don't have one stain, scratch or chip. i even set hot pots on it from time to time, all though, i do use cutting boards.

    be very careful with Absolute Black. the genuine stuff can be hard to get and cost more. the chinese black granite or some shady stone yards will take a inferior black granite and dye it. if you are looking at solid black granite, take a rag and acetone with you. wipe it across the surface. if it comes away black, you have a dyed piece and not AB. AB is one of the few 'true' granites (geologically speaking the others are metamorphic stone,,,,but I digress) and will not even accept a sealer. you cannot seal AB, it's too dense.

    So, your granite choices should be safe. if you're concerned, do the lemon test and stain text with a small piece or edge of the slab. otherwise, you'll be fine.

    soapstone will cost as much as quartz, so if budget is an issue, then that's prob out. quartzite is another one to consider. it's harder than granite. some have more calcite deposits which is where they get their "it stains and etch' reputation from. it just depends on your slab.

    speaking of cost, if you have a small area to do, look into the pre fab granites or even quartz,,350-550 bucks is what you spend for a 9' piece, already cut like these

    this quartz counter was going for 500

  • 8 years ago

    It's amazing how the prices differ across the country. Here, Quartzite ($150/sqft) costs around the price of Cambria quartz or more ($135-160/sqft). Granite ($65-110) costs a similar range to most quartz ($70-100sqft based on brand/color, except for Cambria $$$$ above). And soapstone runs $55-60/sqft. It probably has the most to do with supplier saturation in each market.

    We were seriously considering soapstone, but our kitchen doesn't get enough natural light to be able to handle such a dark countertop. Yours has very nice lighting. :)

  • 8 years ago

    We have about 49-50 sq. ft. to cover. so we will definitely need some larger slabs.

    I think my husband has talked me into the granite, for sure. Now, I just need to find the right color/slab.

    I think AB is out, mainly because it doesn't have enough character. I am leaning towards Steel Gray or Jet Mist. They also have a Milk Way slab that I was told is pretty consistent in color and pattern. I am also going to look at Negresco.

    While we are at the yard, I am going to keep my eyes peeled for other gray/black options.

    Ultimately, it is going to come down to price. I am willing to spend a little more per sq. ft. for the right slab, but budget is a factor for sure. We are trying to keep it around $60 per sq. ft. (installation included).

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Negresco is nice. this one is honed/leathered. (polished black will show every fingerprint)

    Jet Mist is also nice. do a honed or leathered finish.

    steel gray granite reminds of baltic brown granite (but without the brown spots. same pattern)

    has a very purplish black undertone.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I put solid surface (HiMacs - Arctic White) in my mom's kitchen and she LOVES IT! She got the intragel sink as well as the radius backsplash which makes the surface/edge/backsplash/sink appear to be one piece, after installation. She is not a stone person and worries about breaking her crystal and china on a stone top.

    Having said that, I worked with a stone installer who said he re-used the stone countertops he installed AFTER the building had burned down. Even the cabinets the tops were on burned down. They just needed to be cleaned up. AND stone CAN be resurfaced. Not as easily as solid surface and it will cost more, but the likelihood this happening is l-o-w. You can purchase stone by the sf through Home Depot and Lowes.

    Good luck!