Software
Houzz Logo Print
karlatamez456

backsplash dilemma

8 years ago
Hi everyone, its been 3 months since we got our granite countertops installed (absolute cream) and we still can’t decide on a backsplash, mostly because me and my husband have very different taste, i love subway tile and he doesn’t, he likes travertine, today we are going to a tile store and i will get some samples, but a month ago i got a ivory glass subway tile sample to put it on my granite to see if it would look good but seems to change color to white, almost gray :/

Comments (21)

  • 8 years ago
    These are a few more pics of my granite, it has cream, gold, green, brown,black i guess some gray quartz and some burgundy dots
  • 8 years ago
    I like light subway tile but i also like these
  • 8 years ago

    I was going to suggest the tile I had in my old kitchen. In fact I liked the tile so much, I used the same tile in a different color in my new kitchen. The color I'm thinking of for you would work really well. It's Jeffrey Court Sand Bar. What I like is the crackle finish to give it a slightly more natural look as well as the slightly darker edges. Here's an old picture of it in my condo I sold. In the photo on the Jeffrey Court website it looks redder on my screen than what it was in real life. Just an FYI.

    They also have it in a hex shape which looks really nice and might be a nice compromise for you and your hubby. Hex shape

  • 8 years ago
    @cpartist and @mayflowers thankyou for your recommendations, i got 2 different samples, a taupe glass subway tile from jeffrey court and 4x4 travertine, i love the glass tile and i also like the travertine but i do fear will look dated on my kitchen and that the color of my granite against the pinkish undertones in most travertine will clash, my husband surprisingly liked the glass tile (mostly because is glass) but he has also told me how much he LOVES travertine in diagonal, with that sparkly stripe all across that traditional kitchens seems to do, here are some pics of the samples i got, and also a pic of the only kitchen i found that uses this glass tile with dark cabinets(darker than mine) and santa cecilia granite(mine is absolute cream)
  • 8 years ago
    I must have said my husband liked the glass tile because is DARK
  • 8 years ago

    I'm not a fan of stone backsplash with a stone countertop - but the combination of that travertine with your countertops is particularly bad. Sorry to be so blunt. The colors and textures don't seem to complement each other at all. Yes, stand your ground against the travertine unless you want those surfaces to look like Hulk Hogan fighting Andre the Giant for attention (godspeed, Andre).

    I usually don't like dark backsplashes but I do like the color of the 3rd photo (in your last post); the 1st one is nice too. Those colors and finishes appear to go very well with your countertop. If you prefer lighter colors, try something in a similar finish with smoky gray tones.

  • 8 years ago

    The white is too stark for your countertops. I would go with something more tan or beige.



  • 8 years ago

    If your husband actually thinks the travertine isn't atrocious with the granite, he should be banned from making any further style decisions - there is a difference between preferences between two equally valid style choices and those that are match made in hell like that travertine and granite combination. It would be like asking someone completely color blind to select colors :-)

    The dark subway tile works well with the granite but what is the rest of your kitchen in terms of light and cabinets as it could read very dark especially if you don't have really good under cabinet lighting.

  • 8 years ago

    On my screen, the travertine has a pinkish cast, against the gold/brown of the countertop.

    Here's what I would do, with those DH opinions. I would go get 4 or 5 or 6 samples of different glass tiles (or handmade ceramic tiles-that's what I personally would like to see in there), in the shape you like, with proper warm colors, with some "interest" to them (crackling, hand-glazed--something besides plain glass--try an octagon, or interesting lantern-shape). Make sure that YOU can live with any of them, and then show him those choices. Perhaps he will be able to make a selection, and then have actually contributed to the decision, which in many cases is all that needs to happen. I wouldn't bring home any more travertine for him to see.


  • 8 years ago

    Tell hubs you'll dress your kitchen like it's 1994 if he grows a mullet and buys these jeans.

  • 8 years ago

    Sorry, he can't have that travertine tile. Could you compromise and get larger scale tile on the diagonal or squares that are set in an off set pattern?

  • 8 years ago

    I don't usually chime in on backsplash discussions, but the darker glass subway (looks gray on my monitor) looks fab with your counters! What if you used that in a herringbone pattern? Would that satisfy hubs diagonal desires. :)

  • 8 years ago
    @zmith yes its gorgeous, in some light it looks grey, and it kind of changes colors between gray, green and brown
  • 8 years ago

    Before you commit to glass (you have a couple really nice candidates there) take the time and expense to do a mockup on a piece of scrap plywood. It can change color based on the adhesive used since it's a little transparent and you'll want to test out grouts anyway.

    Yes, the travertine just plain clashes. :)

    I like matte finish/tumbled glass tiles. Your DH might like those better than the crisp modern-looking ones. They are harder to find, though.

  • 8 years ago
    Sooo i think im choosing the dark glass tile, i love how it looks with my granite, i finally told my husband that i dont want travertine in my kitchen, he seemed kind of bummed but i also told him that he can use the travertine on a house he has in mexico, is a rustic style so i think it might look better there, now we are trying to decide the grout color,im not sure if it should be white or something close to the tile color, also im adding picks of my cabinets because i need hardware and don’t know what kind would look good
  • 8 years ago
    Hello... after 4 months without backsplash im still struggling to find the perfect one, just got another sample from HD from the Jeffrey court line called royal cream, 3x6 beleved, this week im going to Lowes to see what i can fiind and next week to Floor & decor, i decided against the taupe glass tile since i have read its pretty difficult to install and can change color after installed, also i glued some behind my stove just to see them in different lighting during the day and sometimes it ended up looking a little too dark :/ the first pic i compare the royal cream next to a true white tile and in person the royal cream tile doesn’t look as stark white as in the picture
  • 8 years ago

    The cream tile looks nice. You're wise to stay away from the stark whites.

    You may be familiar with F&D already, but in case you're not, I feel compelled to warn you...if you find something there that you like, buy as much as you need for the backsplash because if you wait, it will probably sell out before you get back to buy. BTDT. :( You can always return the tile within 90 days.

  • 8 years ago
    zmith yes i have been at F&D at least 3 times and the last time i went with my husband i had such a difficult time since he loves travertine in angle and specially likes how it looks with sparkly stripe all across and a design behind the stove and that is not the look i want for my kitchen, i have 2 F&D in my city so next time i go i will pick up some samples, i know people like to order their tile off the internet but im affraid that if i order like big quantities and tiles come broken is more tedious to return it, wait for more tile instead of just going to the store and exchange it
  • 8 years ago

    I understand completely. I've ordered online before with bad results, but mostly everything arrives in tact.

    Maybe hubby needs to stay at home next time. ;)

  • 8 years ago
    Lol yes!! He’s not going with me, we both got to the conclusion that we have just different tastes, he likes very traditional, rustic, tuscany kitchens and while i like it too i just dont want that on my own