Software
Houzz Logo Print
diana_locke

Hiring a designer? Architect? Contractor?

8 years ago
We have just purchased a house that needs a lot of work. Two bathrooms, flooring, Kitchen need updating as well as the floorplan. We also plan on doing an addition in the future (5 yrs). Our budget for immediate work is about 60k. I'd like to create a whole house plan, that we could implement over time. My husband and I are also very handy and capable of serving as our own GC and doing a lot of the work. What type of professional should we look for to help designing and creating a plan like this?

Comments (12)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    It depends on much work you're doing. If you're completely redoing and rearranging a floorplan I would say an architect would be most useful. For the kitchen specifically, though, use a certified kitchen designer. They will save you money and save you from making poor design choices!

  • 8 years ago
    Thanks. I'm not sure how much work we will be doing, that is where I'm stuck. There are some major layout issues with the house, most notably a very small galley kitchen and awkward adjacent breakfast area. I'd like to accomplish a larger kitchen feel without moving walls, but am open to a floorplan change if need be. I also feel like the dining room and formal living room should be flip flopped so that the focal point can be the deck and pool (once pool is installed). Pictures below.
  • 8 years ago
    more pictures
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Hope the pool is not part of the budget.Have you ever worked as a GC before it is a lot harder than you can imagine kind of like juggling 5 balls.My advice is live in it for at least 6 months and a year is even better before beginning this journey. A house has a way of telling what it wants and IMO best to listen to it. From what I see there is no terrible porblem at the moment and for god’s do not keep pink and blue bathrooms because they somehow need to be preserved. I have a MCM house that took us 200K plus to get to where we wanted, yes we kept some of the features but not all . IMO an architect needs to brought in right from the beginning in order to get the addition considered before anything is done.

  • 8 years ago
    The pool has it's own budget - which is actually bigger than the houses haha. We did our previous house on our own and it was fine. A pain to manage the subs, yes, but worth it. That house was more cosmetic changes - new kitchen, baths, flooring etc. but no moving walls or rearranging plumbing or anything like that. Perhaps for now we will just do like for like upgrades in the kitchen and baths, along with new floors and live in for a few years before doing anything too drastic.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    "... do not keep pink and blue bathrooms because they somehow need to be preserved."


    Patrica:


    This is without question the worst advice you've ever given on Houzz. Your lack of stewardship and context is truly breathtaking and a threat to our collective heritage.

  • 8 years ago

    The hardest part of doing a remodel is to find a person to do it.

    And, just try to find some one like a plumber to do small jobs! They all want to come in for thousands of dollars and tear it all out and rebuild.

    I called around all over for a plumber to change out a shower valve in an opened wall ( easy, plumbing 101 and no carpentry to be done) and I want a toilet replaced in a basement bath. Sure, I can, and have put in new toilets. But, I suspect that the bolts may be rusted on this toilet and I am getting older. The bathroom gets daily use.

    Just try to find a plumber to do some small jobs. I could not find anyone to come and do these simple jobs. Never mind the price. We never got that far.

    We have hired a contractor to come and redo the deck and build a screened in porch. It is making me a little nervous that I have to contact him to ask him when he is going to schedule our work. He does answer,but.........I hate dealing with these people. I found him on Angies list and he comes with accolades. We will see....

    I had one contractor out to give me an estimate for redoing two baths. His prices were so high and he would not do a simple layout for me. He wanted to do too much for too much. These folks around here do not want small jobs. They just want the big jobs.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    "( easy, plumbing 101 and no carpentry to be done)"


    wednesday morning:


    I've found your problem. Anytime I get a phone call from a potential telling me how easy their job is, I run for the hills. People who think they're capable of assessing the complexity of the job also think they are capable of assessing what it's worth and that's not enough for me.

  • 8 years ago
    Wednesday Morning I agree.

    We are very handy and capable of doing a lot of work ourselves. but everyone gets to a point that is past their ability, or that they simply don't have the time to do. the trouble is finding subs who want to take that 20% you need to accompliah the job. An update on our reno- we are in the middle of gutting the place. Floors are up, kitchen walls removed, bathrooms gutted. It's hard work but not rockets science. Once the house is cleaned up we have a couple contractors who actually are going to work with us in doing things "here and there." AKA rough electrical, plumbing and carpentry.
  • 8 years ago
    And not only will we save the 20% contractor fees for the job, we have the flexibilty to shop for our own materials, and will save substantially by doing things like cabinet install, baseboards, doors, some tiling, finish plumbing and electrical ourselves. But we have done this before, it's not easy and it does take much longer than paying the professionals to do it (who usually will do a better job as well). but when you dont have 50k to spend on a kitchen, or 25k on a bath it's really the only option!
  • 8 years ago

    Joseph, I consider replacing a toilet to be a simple job. And, the shower valve is in an opened shower wall. All you have to do is just stand there and do it. There is absolutely nothing in the way and it is a clean and pleasant place to stand while you are working.

    I used to have a custom window treatment business and I understand what you mean about some people underestimating what they think they want and I also would not take jobs to remake their old curtains or refit anything old to a new window. If I was to "own" the job, it had to be mine from the beginning to the end, or I would not take responsibility for it. I understand that. It was futile to explain some things to some people, such as the fact that that double ruffle around those decorator pillows was going to take more labor and more fabric than the actual pillow and that is why it was going to cost so much more. Most saw the ruffle around the pillow being secondary to the pillow. The reality is much different.

    If that same customer wanted to give me precut pillow pieces that they cut themselves, I would have rejected that. However, if they wanted to put in their own pillow forms or provide the lining fabric for the pillows, that would have been fine.

    As someone who was called in and consulted on how to make their fantasies come true, I understand your point. What they thought they wanted and the reality were not coming together.

    But, I do wish that I could find someone to just create a basic bathroom for me and leave the finishing work to me. I wanted them to come in and leave me with an newly installed shower with a finished wall around it, a new subfloor ready to be finished and walls that were ready to be primed and painted. I guess what I was asking for was not one that would make for a good photo shoot on their portfolio.

    My BIL has been a contractor and he would not take on a job unless they agreed to take it back to the studs, so to speak. I have no problem with that, but I only want it finished to a degree. My budget is limited and I am still perfectly capable of doing finishing work.

    I, essentially, gave up on the complete remodel of the two rooms .The result is that I am now rebuilding one of the showers myself and I am now in need of some simple plumbing. It is going quite nicely, but slowly...new shower pan, tiled shower walls, etc. But, I do want a plumber to come and replace the shower valve before the wall gets closed in, and I don't like to mess around with plumbing that runs under the basement floor. Thus, I want a guy to come and put in a new toilet down there. Those jobs should be 101 plumbing jobs. That is all I am asking for now, simple plumbing.

    I did the upper level bathroom a few years ago--replacing tub, surround walls, new toilet, paint, new vanity and tilled floor. It went well. I did get a plumber to install a new shower valve. He left me with capped off live plumbing before the wall was closed in. But, I am not having the same luck now with finding someone to do that simple plumbing job.

    Hiring a tradesman or a contractor is a pain.

    I have a friend who got himself certified to do his own wiring because it was just easier than hiring someone. He got an actual certification and education to do it.