Software
Houzz Logo Print
caseycarr

Move Some Duct in Attic

8 years ago

We have duct work in our house hallways in the false ceiling, but in the kitchen the duct work continues in a soffit above the kitchen cabinets. We are putting in new cabinets and would like to put in 42" wall cabinets Because we have a small galley kitchen and could use the extra cabinet space. We will need to remove the soffits in the kitchen to do this. One side of wall cabinets sit below the soffit that has the duct work. Our contractor says it is no problem to put a flex duct into the attic for that section of the duct work in the kitchen.. I'm concerned about doing this. It's hot up there in the summer and cold up there in the winter. The attic is ventilated. There is insulation on the attic floor. We live in central NM. I think it may be taxing on our new furnace And new evaporative cooler If we put this flex duct in the ceiling. My husband agrees with our contractor And thinks if we add an insulated wrap around the flex duct it will not be a problem. my thought is to leave the duct work in the soffit. I'd like to hear from some experts please. Thank you.



Comments (13)

  • 8 years ago

    Correction:. "if we put this flex duct in the attic".


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    As far as I know:

    -Duct runs in a soffit (which is within the home's conditioned "envelope") is the best place, and is what's done in modern energy-efficient homes and other buildings.

    -Having ducts in the attic is the worst place.

    -Hard metal ducts have the best air flow and can be insulated the best.

    -Flex is a cheap expedient and usually isn't insulated as well.

    caseycarr thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 8 years ago

    I don't see the necessity for extended duct in a small galley kitchen. Why can't you just discharge air where it enter's room.

    caseycarr thanked klem1
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I live in Katy, Texas one of the most brutal summer time destinations imaginable.

    99.9% of homes are built here with equipment in the attic and ductwork in the attic.

    Go back with R8 insulated flex properly hung, you'll be fine.

    caseycarr thanked Austin Air Companie
  • 8 years ago

    Flexible duct work in the attic is fine. Get the the highest rated r-value wrapped duct. Texas climates are just as severe as Central NM, maybe worse. And if you are still concerned wrap the duct with more insulation.

    caseycarr thanked wacokid
  • 8 years ago

    In general I think installing flexible duct in an unconditioned attic is a bad idea. However is this is a short run then it might be possible to build an enclosure in the attic and insulate with R30 or higher insulation. You would be basically raising the ceiling and conditioned space.

    You could also to a compromise and install a 36 inch cabinet with crown molding. That would give you about 6 inches of space to install a duct. The 36 inch cabinet has 3 shelves but they are 3 inches of additional height. You can stack and store more items. The 42 inch cabinet has 4 shelves but are 3 inches less in height. It is hard to read the top shelf in you are shorter than 6 feet.

    You could also install shorter cabinets below the soffit, and taller cabinets elsewhere. There is no rule that they have to be the same height if you like that look.

    caseycarr thanked mike_home
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Austin, you're describing what you see, not what you know would be optimal if starting with a blank piece of paper.

    Keeping equipment and ducts out of the attic reduces energy usage and air leakage substantially in all climates, this has been studied by experts to the hilt and the results are not in dispute. Why are they put into the attics, especially for newish slab on grade construction as is so common in Texas and other areas? It's cheaper for the builder, who walks away after the house is sold and has no expense for energy usage. No other reason. Cheaper, not better.

    Agree with Mike, if a short run and the space is better used another way, then so be it. Remodeling always involves trade-offs and compromises.

    caseycarr thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Flex duct in an unconditioned attic is not ideal but its done all the time and we're all still here alive! Just be sure to specify R-12 (it's available from Lambro and others), to take into account the hostile environment.

    caseycarr thanked sktn77a
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you all for your advice and input! I really appreciate everyone's suggestions. We will likely go with taller cabinets on the one side and shorter on the duct side to preserve our duct work. Makes sense. I thought it might look odd, but we are removing the small cabinet above the sink and opening up the wall above the sink (duct side). I think it will provide some balance. Thanks again everyone!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    This is my normal response to the suggestion of ducts in the attic:

    Ducts leak. Duct systems leak when new and only get worse with age. When Outdoor ducts leak, they turn your air handler into a power vent. They blow out conditioned air and suck in unconditioned air, sometimes from some of the groadyest places possible. In humid environments, hot humid air gets sucked in, hits cool surfaces, condenses water, grows nasty stuff, and rots stuff. Want more? Read the following, especially 10, 9, and 8.

    Don't do it.

    vented attics and outdoor ducts

    You are not normal by most peoples' standards on this board so my normal response may not be maximally appropriate. This might be better:

    You have a furnace for heat and a simple evaporative cooler only for cooling, or do you also have mechanical cooling? If the former, and it uses the ducts mentioned above, I'd have to think about it and even then I might not know how to answer. Your air flow for cooling is one-way. It is flowing constantly on hot days and with quite a bit of volume and velocity so there might be sufficient flow to make attic-duct heat gain negligible. I suspect water costs have risen considerably since I lived in the swamp cooler zone, but perhaps evap coolers are still considerably less expensive to run than mechanical cooling which could make it silly to compromise your cabinet plans. The pressurization of the building in cooling season makes sucking in air leaking supplies in an uncontrolled way impossible, but you still have heating season. What is your altitude?

    Do you have a cool metal roof? Have you been evaluated by a home energy rater (BPI or Resnet)? They can help you answer these questions much better than some Yankee, Canadian (author of above top ten list), Texan, Carolinian, or anyone else not experienced with evap cooling.

    caseycarr thanked ionized_gw
  • 8 years ago

    I appreciate your response and the information you provided!

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Austin, you're describing what you see, not what you know would be optimal if starting with a blank piece of paper.

    People don't have the option of starting from a blank piece of paper. So what good is it for me to illustrate what you can do from a blank piece of paper? I don't build homes, I fix the ones already built.

    Windows and their placement will have a far greater impact on this homes heat load than a well insulated properly hung duct in an attic will.

    But you know the con is to focus on foolish things that don't matter nearly as much as you think they do.

    My light bill was $60 last month and I sleep at a comfy 74 degrees. My poor system is in the attic as well as the duct work.