Software
Houzz Logo Print
kay_hackamack

Replacing HVAC in Houston

8 years ago

Our house was built in 2003, 3600 sqft two story, lots of windows. We are looking at replacing system, it has the old Freon, Is it necessary to replace the whole system or just the condenser? We have been quoted for both, big dollars. We want to start by replacing the downstairs unit first, it currently has 3.5 ton 12 seer. Is there any benefit to going with 4 ton which we can get 17 seer as opposed to 3.5 16 seer system? So part question here. Thanks so much for the advice!

Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    By going to the 17 SEER, you will get 2 stage cooling. This should give you better comfort and humidity control. Yes you will need a complete system, both in and out and 410 refrigerant. The downside is your ductwork both supply and returns will need evaluation to see if it can handle the extra CFMs cooling air.

    IMO

    Kay Hackamack thanked tigerdunes
  • 8 years ago

    Where are you located. Sizing-wise, if you're in Death Valley, Nevada, that's one thing; if you're in the southeast gulf, then that's another.

    Kay Hackamack thanked sktn77a
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Title: Houston.

    The plus of going to 4 ton is 2-stage. This allows as stated better humidity control when running at the lower stage (along with a variable speed blower).

    The down of 4 ton may be that it is oversized for your house. You need a load evaluation (Manual J) to see what your actual load is. You can get a hint from how your current system ran when it was good: all the time, good cooling, good humidity removal? etc.

    Kay Hackamack thanked weedmeister
  • 8 years ago

    The majority of the sq ft is downstairs, with most of the living room and entry way open to the second floor and lots of huge windows. We just bought the house, but the master bedroom downstairs is noticeably warmer than the rest of the house. The inspection report stated the compressor was pretty much shot. I think the 2nd floor unit is 2 ton. So if we replace the whole system, when it is time to do the second unit (in about 12 months or so) we would just need to do the outside unit., correct? Thanks for all the input. I am leaning towards the 4 ton 2 stage unit. So would the 2nd floor unit remain the 2 ton? They are suggesting 5.5 tons for our space, is there any negative to more tonnage? This is Houston- AC= more power as Tim the Toolman would say. Thanks again for all your input!

  • 8 years ago

    An over sized AC will short cycle and provide poor humidity control. Short cycling wastes energy and will shorten the life of the equipment. The duct work would have to be measured to verify it has the capacity to handle the extra capacity.

    The right way to do this is to do a load calculation to determine what is the correct size. I assume you have two systems each with its own air handler or furnace and condenser. Over sized equipment is common in Texas. People think bigger is better when in actually is can make things worse.

    Don't assume the 2 ton size is correct for the second floor. Each floor should be sized independently.

    If you change the outside condenser at a minimum you will have to change the indoor coil. You should also change the air handler or furnace at the same time.

    Kay Hackamack thanked mike_home
  • 8 years ago

    Too-large of a system reduces the run-time (reaches the set-point quicker), less humidity removal than longer run-times ... can lead the occupants to lower the setpoint to compensate.

    Just to say .... my 2003 house is 75-ish miles from Houston depending on the specific destination. 2,350-ish sq ft, single story but high ceilings so slightly more volume than average. 5-ton system, although may be slightly oversized (depends on the desired temperature point), 4-ton probably would be sufficient. Kay Hackamack has 1,250 more sq ft.

    Kay Hackamack thanked dadoes
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Being that you just bought the house I suspect you are planning to live here at least 10-15 years?

    If that's the case it's probably best for you to replace the whole system. To achieve higher efficiencies you would have to do this anyway.

    While it's more likely a 17 SEER machine may be a 2 speed machine, that is not always the case. You have to know what you are buying.

    I service the Katy, Texas area and some far west Houston area locations.

    Kay Hackamack thanked Austin Air Companie
  • 8 years ago

    Is someone telling you need 5.5 tons just for the first floor?

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz