Software
Houzz Logo Print
paulsiu

gutter guard and heavy rain

8 years ago

Because there are a lot of trees in my yard, In certain parts of the year, I am constantly trying to clean out the gutters, otherwise my gutter fills up and water starts pouring out the side of the gutter. This eventually cause the sump pump to run continuously if the gutters are clogged. Worse yet, rain storm has become heavier in the past couple of years. I now pools of water everywhere.


My gutters were damaged recently and I am in the process of getting them replace. I was thinking about gutter guards, but wonders if they will actually make things worse. I am going to get larger gutters because I have a very steep roof, which cause the water to run into the gutter at a very high velocity. To prevent spillover, I decided to replace my gutter with wider gutters I thought about gutter guard the vendor said they carry Shur Flo and Raindrop. The Shur Flo appears to be a aluminum sheet with holes in it. The Raindrop appears to be a plastic grate. After examining the grate, I am wondering how it will work in a really heavy rainstorm like close to 5 inch an hour? is the water going to start rolling over the gutter guard and into my foundation?


Paul

Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Are some trees (what kind are they, btw?) too close to your house, i.e., do the limbs overhang the roof? If so, that should be the first thing you take care of. Now, if the gutters aren’t able to contain the deluge, it could be that your downspouts are clogged up with debris. Have you run water through them to make sure that water can flow freely? Also, where does the water go when it reaches the bottom of the downspouts: Do you have underground pipes that either carry it to a sewer or someplace on your property? Or does it dump out above ground, either right next to or near the house?

  • 8 years ago

    Of those two, the Raindrop is a better design assuming it's installed properly so that there's a pitch to them to allow your tree debris to blow off. The Shur Flo's look nicer, but guess what, they have a nice trough that will just fill up with your tree debris just as your gutters would so you'd have to clean them out anyways.

    I have these below from Amerimax, and they work great.. that is until debris lands on top and covers them. Unfortunately my gutters are installed so there isn't much of a pitch in the guards so stuff can collect. Maple helicopters, cotton crap and other small debris has a tough time washing away on it's own and will sometimes stick to the top and if enough sticks on, it will cover the whole top of the guard in some areas. The gutters stay clear of debris, but the water is washing right over the top of them.

    The Raindrop ones might be less "grippy" too.


  • 8 years ago

    Oversized gutters are a great idea. The screen or grate type gutter guards will be the better choice, but which design depends on a couple factors. The types of trees(specifically what they shed that will collect on the guards and possibly be caught in the openings, the area of the roof that drains into each gutter(figuring the amount of water being caught/carried, and the size of the down spouts(which need to have a larger capacity than the gutter).

    The other gotcha is the fact detris from the trees will collect on the guards and need to be cleaned off periodically. At least twice a year(I do spring and after the leaves fall in fall). Because, if that is not done, the same problem will exist. The use of the guards decreases the amount of time/labor to do that.

  • 8 years ago

    A search on this site and others should turn up lots of comments on gutter guards. I don't have the impression that they get a lot of love.

    In my experience, there's no substitute for frequent gutter cleaning. I use a good, gutsy shop vac with a long, large diameter hose (this one) and a big crevice tool.

    You can also get J-shaped vacuum kits that let you clean gutters from the ground, but I'd rather be up there, so I can see what I'm doing.

    The links are meant as examples, not as endorsements.

  • 8 years ago

    I actually get all types of trees here. Usually in the fall, I have to clear the gutter like weekly because it sits next to a really large ash tree. On the other side, it's a river birch. I also get tiny seeds of some kind and stuff that look like cotton. There's also evergreen stuff and stuff from trees that are not even in my yard.

    I can clean most of the gutter, but some of them are dangerously high. I have pros that come at least once a year after the fall to clear out the gutter in preparation for the winter.

    Half the down spout goes into a pipe that drains out to somewhere else in the yard. The yard slopes downward so generally rain doesn't collect. I have more problems with the gutter that drains out. I need to figure out better ways of moving that water further away.

    I notice that the Raindrop problem is sloped, so falling leaves probably get flushed off. However, my concern is that heavy rain fall may result in water just going over the guard.


    Paul


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Have him put up some sample pieces so you can demo them.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I've got huge oak, pecan and crape myrtles, which, imho, are three of the trashiest trash-making trees ever created. I have the screen-type gutter covers. Keeps leaves from clogging gutters, but doesn't keep small bits out. I have to routinely clean off accumulated tree debris at the roof valleys.

    Btw, adding larger/more downspouts is more effective than larger gutters alone. After I upsized my downspouts, the gutters are pretty much self-cleaning.

  • 8 years ago

    I had Leaf Relief gutter covers (perforated with small holes, flat metal style) and hated them, precisely because I had to climb up on the roof 3, sometimes 4 times each year to clean them -- they would be clogged. A major part of the problem was that they were improperly installed I believe. They were flat on the gutters, and with the gutters tilted down toward the wall instead of down away from the wall; and the edge of the roof shingles protruded over them (in some spots by over 50%!) so that the small leaves, flowers and seeds from the neighbor's maple and honey locust would pack under the shingles instead of blowing away, and then subsequent debris would stick to the covers until they were completely clogged.

    I had water penetrate under the roof before I realized that my new gutters and covers still needed to be cleaned. BTW the roofing contractor came with recommendations from neighbors.