Software
Houzz Logo Print
kristicame

Help Me Choose a Countertop!

8 years ago

I'm going to drive myself crazy trying to pick out a countertop. I'm looking for something that will brighten up the kitchen - which isn't super small, but isn't large either. We do not have an island, only an L-Shaped counter. Our cabinets are white and the flooring will be a gray/brown vinyl plank. The walls with either be white or Repose Gray.


For materials, I've narrowed it down to Iron White Granite & Airy Concrete from Caesarstone.


Granite - I know that it is builder grade and outdated and many people have said on Houzz it will hurt our resale value. However, homes in my neighborhood weren't built with stone countertops (many have laminate) so I'm not sure if that would apply here? It's a lot cheaper, and the colors tie the gray walls into the white cabinets and brown floors nicely - but I'm worried it might make it too dark. Or it might be too busy.


Airy Concrete Caeserstone: This is a new CS color so I can't find many reviews on it. Existing reviews for Caesertstone's other concrete colors (which are darker) are pretty terrible. Because of the rugged finish, people are saying they see water marks and fingerprints consistently plus they are hard to clean. I've tested my small sample against stains and scratches, but I'm not seeing the fingerprints/watermarks like reviewers have said. Maybe the new material is better, the lighter option doesn't show as much, or my test size is too small. If the reviews were a little better, I would probably choose this option. But I don't want a countertop I have to baby - otherwise I would be getting Super White dolomite!


What would you do if it was your kitchen? Any other suggestions similar to those colors you think would look good? Help!!


Photo of the samples in my kitchen with the floors (bad lighting makes the cabinets look yellow)



Photos of the actual slabs:





Inspiration Examples:






Iron White Granite
Airy Concrete Caesarstone Quartz

Comments (27)

  • 8 years ago

    Neither to be honest. The Iron White Granite is a builder grade granite. It is super common and can be found everywhere. Which there is nothing wrong with if you want your kitchen to look like everyone elses.

    The concrete finish in quartz is absolutely terrible. Its leaves residue, eats glass and aluminum, and just is a pain to maintain. If you want quartz I will always recommend polished instead of "leathered","matte","rugged", or "concrete".

    kristi thanked Mrs. Gopher #BringBackSophie
  • 8 years ago

    The Iron White granite looks very similar to Azul Platino, which is one of the granites I had considered for my own kitchen. One of the reasons why I didn't use it is because I thought it was a bit too speckled for me, and I usually like speckled granite and quartz. I was afraid it was too much of a good thing. However, the price was great.

    By me, even though some granites may be considered "builder grade", I don't see them "everywhere". The subdivision a minute from my house is only 10 years old and they offered many different granite choices for new builds. I know many people that live there and take notice of their kitchens (just because I like looking at their kitchens :) ). I have only seen the same granite used twice, and I didn't even realize it was the same until I asked. The lighting, cabinet choices, and other colors in their homes made it look completely different. So if the Iron White is something you really like, I would not let that dissuade you.

    I had a sample of Airy Concrete and thought it was really pretty, but I had to take it out of the running because of the price. Since it's one of their newer colors it was really $$$$$. Like you, my sample passed every test and I had no problems with water marks and stains.

    I would nix the Airy Concrete because of the rugged/leathered finish. I too would not want something I had to baby.

    Can you find the designer of your first inspiration photo and find out what countertop they used?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We faced a similar choice earlier this year (see thread https://www.gardenweb.com/discussions/5087266/help-me-choose-countertops). We wanted to lighten up the space and get rid of the dark brown, speckled, granite-look laminate. We wanted granite, but couldn't find one that was consistently non speckled, and light in color, for a good price - Colonial White, I'm talking about you!. We looked at all the marble-look and light grey / concrete-look quartzes, and ended up with LG Viatera-Nimbus (swirly grey wih small chunks of glass). I read those negative reviews of the concrete quartzes, and was not willing to take a chance. Here's the Nimbus:

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks for the insight everyone! I'm not 100% sold on either of them, so maybe this is just proof I need to continue my search.

    chocolatebunny123 -- Thank you! I actually did find the countertops in the first inspiration photo - they are a laminate that came standard in their home, so the only info I had to go off of was that it was laminate. I suppose I'm not totally against the idea of laminate, I just wasn't considering it at this point.

    abbycat9990 - - I will check out that thread, thanks! That sounds exactly like what I've gone through so far this summer. I started out trying to find a marble/light gray and white look and none of them were doing it for me. I love the look of natural stone and a lot of the Quartz I was seeing looked too fake which brought me back to granite. Ah! So frustrating. How do you like the LG Viatera-Nimbus so far?

  • 8 years ago

    Kristi - that laminate looks pretty darn good! I am switching from laminate to quartz and hope I don't regret my decision.

    Silestone Lagoon and Ocean Jasper are popular light grey colors. I believe there is a long thread on Ocean Jasper. I saw Silestone Forest Snow display and thought it was really pretty too. Hanstone Pewter is a bit darker and more consistent but more reasonably priced than some of the other brands.

    kristi thanked chocolatebunny123
  • 8 years ago

    kristi we love the Nimbus. It's a nice, light reflective surface; it's pretty to look at; and the quartz feels like a luxurious upgrade. We have eased edges, and there is some chipping around the sink. I have become very careful when washing pots, etc. Definitely recommend it, and wouldn't change a thing.

  • 8 years ago

    I just agonized over choosing countertops for our reno... I shied away from quartz because of chipping complaints. I also didn’t find one that didn’t look fake to me. If you have your heart set on quartz, you might look into Ironsbridge by Cambria. I think that’s the color you‘re trying to achieve. I don’t personally like the spotty aspect of granite. I do think black granite is pretty, but that’s a distinct look and I think you’re looking for lighter.

    I ended up choosing Taj Mahal quartzite(my slabs leaned more grey and brown without the yellow undertones some TM has). If you do look at lighter quartzites, be sure it is a ‘harder quartzite’ some slabs that are labeled quartzite are actually dolomitic marble. Take a chunk home and try to stain it, hit it with a hammer, etc...

    They say that natural stone is easier to repair in the years to come than man made quartz.... you can repolish stone, fix chips where they aren’t noticeable, etc. With quartz, you can’t do that. I’m not sure if any of this info will help you, but I thought I’d share since choosing countertops was a tough decision for me too. Good luck!

  • 8 years ago

    I love quartz. LOVE! I have had Silestone for maybe 15 years and zero problems. That stuff is indestructible. I am putting it in my new place and can’t wait!

    I think you can do a lot better than those choices. That being said, go with what you like. Good luck and have fun!

  • 8 years ago

    Melissa – Thanks for your insight! Why do countertops have to be so hard! The Taj Mahal in my area right now looks a lot different than some I've seen online with a lot of the yellow you mentioned :( I really lean more towards natural stone, because like you I'm having a hard time finding a quartz that doesn't look fake to me. As for stone - I have yet to find a slab that is durable and light enough for what I'm looking for for our kitchen.

  • 8 years ago

    stumpydarby – what color of Silestone do you have? I just went to Lowe's to check it out last night but unfortunately I don't think I have a retailer locally that carries the full slabs.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    If you like the Airy Concrete, maybe take a look at the CS Bianco Drift which comes in polished so won’t have those issues honed/concrete finish quartz does. It is a bit of a warmer grey with white and taupe too but the patterning is quite subtle (obviously check your own slabs etc!) but the white and the taupe/brown may compliment both your cabinets and floors. Here are some photos I found of it online; we have it in our new build too and I can take some photos of it this afternoon and post them later.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, Rai Kai!! I would love to see photos of yours installed. I really like the inspo pics!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Okay, will take some today for you; I have white (Alabaster) cabinets and a not very big kitchen as well :)

    kristi thanked RaiKai
  • 8 years ago

    I like granite, and always will. A good granite is never outdated. Your granite is busy, and if all the rest of your kitchen is solid white like the inspiration pics I say it will look great. Ubba Tuba is another builder grade that would look good in your kitchen and be less busy. Get something for you if you are staying for the long term, if you are going to sell soon get something affordable that fits with the house style and neighborhood.

    kristi thanked Josie23: Zone 5: WI
  • 8 years ago

    Do a search on the forum here regarding the Caesarstone concrete color - IIRC people were having a lot of trouble with it staining.

  • 8 years ago

    I was going back through my phone to look at all of the pictures I've taken and I stumbled across this Siberian White granite. I took it out of the running at first, but now that I've exhausted other options I'm considering it.


    I know this isn't as speckled as the granite in my original post, but would you still consider this "builder grade" ?

  • 8 years ago
    Kitchen counters … I have had Blue Sahara for almost two decades. (This was back when Silestone didn’t have that many colors.) My twin sis has solid blue Silestone. She has had that in her kitchen for almost just as long.

    We also have Silestone in our bathrooms. It is very durable and we love to look at it. I have granite in one bathroom. We went with a remnant to save money. Nobody really loves it and you have to “baby” it more than quartz.

    For my new place, I am getting Silestone White Platinum. I am also getting quartz and recycled glass countertops in all the other bathrooms and laundry. (I am using Compac brand/Titaneo and I love it!! It’s beautiful!)

    I don’t know where you are, but I would go to Silestone.com or another quartz company and find a local fabricator. Lowe’s has to use someone … they are just the middle man. Go directly to the source. Lowes and Home Depot only have a few samples … you need to go to a granite and quartz yard. If you really don’t have those, find a kitchen a bath shop. They should have a lot more samples. You have soooooo many options!! My fabricator carried just about every line of quartz. It made it easy to get exactly what I wanted!
    kristi thanked stumpydarby
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    We just selected Airy Concrete for a client who wanted something more unique than a typical quartz. We loved the finish and above all the "airy" feel of the movement of the material. We have done our own in-house tests to see if the material stains and have found it to be no less durable than other Caesarstone options. The website does say: "Due to the nature of the surface design, it is recommended that common household spills like liquid droplets and rings are dried immediately. Additional care and maintenance will be required." But that might be more of a disclaimer than what we have truly experienced in our own spill tests.

  • 8 years ago
    The Wiese Company — please do post photos once it’s installed, I would love to see it!
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    kristi,,,no to the siberian white. go to a different stone yard and look around for something else. Maybe Alaska White, or River White or Princess White granite?

    I have Super White in my bathroom and I haven't had to baby it at all.

    It's actually pretty darn strong. stronger than marble. I've spilled all sorts of things on it and haven't had any issues.

    since you were looking at quartz,

    Cambria Ironsbridge?

  • 8 years ago
    I LOVE my caesarstone bianco drift -no staining and easy to keep clean. The matte finishes on caesarstone always look dirty.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sorry took so long! Here are some pictures of my Bianco Drift counters. Photos, as always seem to be for me, are squashed so please click on them for better accuracy!

    Please note lighting at time was 4 x 3000 LED cans; still waiting for pendants to be installed.

    Sink is wrong - should be Cinder so will be switched out. This one does not look bad, just not what we picked.

    Close up of counter shows patterning but as you can see it kind of blends or blurs more at a distance. We don’t have a very big or fancy kitchen as you can see (it’s just a production build); we wanted something that added some contrast against white cabinets but was not too dark. This is an open space - that first picture basically shows the remaining space of a dining nook to left and living room over by fireplace - so we wanted kitchen to be cozy and inviting but not domineering.

  • 8 years ago
    Rai Kai - thank you so much for posting!! Your kitchen is amazing. I’m definitely going to go and try and get a sample of that this week.
  • 8 years ago
    Beth H — your bathroom is AMAZING! Thank you for the recommendations, I will check those stones out!

    If so many people didn’t complain about the super white staining and scratching I would use it in a heartbeat, it’s such a beautiful stone.
  • 7 years ago

    RaiKai, the pics of Bianco Drift you have there are showing beige more than light gray on my computer. What color in person would you describe it as ?

  • 7 years ago

    Also, if i might ask RaiKai, what have you chosen as a backsplash?