Option A is far too busy with that granite. Option B is better, but I don't like the diagonal layout of it.

Love the busier floors....The last picture looks just fine! It will hide lots of things!

I think your pictures might be mislabeled. Floor A is under the pic of your present floor. The pic I am going to look at to decide is the last pic - and both are a great improvement on the present floor. I lean a bit more towards the lighter one.

B - simple floor option.

Floor B looks great!

Agree that the busy floor is too busy with your granite. I vote for Option B.

What are the floors in the adjoining spaces?

Floor B PLEASE

Option B.

B

they both are simple I think but different shades ..judging from the photo of them next to each other on the existing, indeed very busy, floor. I think you downloaded wrong pic for floor A. can you attach it?

ETA: I think I found it. second pic that says "new choice"?

Floor B!! Not even a question . The other one is WAY too busy and conflicts with the granite.

B

As others have said floor B for sure. I'd choose the lighter version of the tile as well. From the photo it looks like it will match better with the countertop.

of the 2 sample boards, the darker one.

I have the same granite. Fiore Bianco? We have hickory floors with ours. I would go with Option B, but I think you have them mislabeled. I would not go with white grout though.

Yeah B was My first n only choice I’d go with. Usually the first one is the one I always go with and the one I like the most. But trust your instinct, u know the answer of what works for u.

B

B is best so you don't have two patterns fighting each other.

B is the better of the two, with grout as close to the color of the tile as possible, and narrowest grout lines within manufacturer’s specifications.

B

I like the lighter floor -- in the last picture, the sample in the foreground.