Software
Houzz Logo Print
carolynrpi98

Fantasy Brown, 8 months later

8 years ago
I know there are many threads on this counter top already, and I, too, agonized over whether to choose it for my kitchen. So, I thought I’d share my experience so far in case it helps someone make their own informed decision.

Does it stain? The short answer is yes. I had a large, nightmare inducing, yellowish/orange stain on my island from the stamen of flowers that had dried and fallen onto the counter. I panicked and did exactly what you’re not supposed to do....wiped it up with a wet cloth (spreading it around and making it larger and more nightmarish). I panicked more. I cried. I lost sleep googling what to do about it lol. But, I did get it out (yay google)! I used a poultice of flour and hydrogen peroxide. I wish I had a good before picture but I don’t but trust me, it was bad. Very noticeable, but no trace of it now!

I also had the experience of our coffee maker overflowing (it was set on a timer) and coffee flowed all over and sat and dried over night. Cleaned up no problem. I also spilled red food dye (Christmas cookie decorating) and that also cleaned right up. Did you get that?! RED FOOD DYE!!! Now in all fairness, my counters had just been sealed so maybe that’s why it didn’t stain. So be sure to seal them. (And be even more careful then I thought I was being when stirring food dye into frosting. Lol.)

Ive also been known to not wipe down my counters immediately (I have 3 kids that eat constantly, I’d/they’d be wiping them all day) and I cook a lot and sometimes leave the cleanup until morning. I’ve never had tomato sauce or cooking oil stain as of yet. So as far as staining goes, I’d say easy peasy lemon squeezy. Which brings me to....

Etching. Have my counters etched?? Yup. We etched ours with lime juice, even though we thought we were careful. We apparently didn’t wipe it all up quickly enough, which was pretty damn quick. But you know what? You can only see it if you know where to look and with the right light. So I’m going to continue to celebrate Cinco de Mayo with Coronas and guacamole without worry. I should note we went with the honed finish so that definitely helps camouflage any etching. I’ve also been told that you can always rehone your counters if they look terrible at some point but you can’t “re-polish” if you choose a polished finish so that’s something to think about.

So, that’s my best summary of “real life” with my Fantasy Brown quartzite counters. Maybe they’re marble, who knows, but mine were labeled quartzite for what it’s worth. Hopefully it eases someone’s anxiety if they are on the fence about it. Now that I’ve lived and learned a little with these counters, I no longer feel like a slave to them. They still look great and I’m confident that any blemishes I may inflict on them in the future I can probably fix or live with. Go for it!

Comments (8)

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals