Software
Houzz Logo Print
lauren_cruz28

Testing Electrical and Plumbing Sytsems

Unfortunately, my contractor told us that we had received the city inspections required to approve framing, electrical and plumbing thus approving our home for the the clear to close and to put up the walls. We now have drywall installed but found out that he had not even called for those inspections, let alone passed them! Due to this deceit, we worry about the quality of the electrical and plumbing work that is behind the walls. Is there a reliable way to check the electrical and plumbing work that has been done without removing all of the dry wall and having to replace it all?


Thank you in advance for your assistance.

Comments (24)

  • 8 years ago

    X-Ray vision isn't a thing... that's why it has to be inspected before the walls are closed up.

    Here's a tip... don't own the problem. Make your contractor own it.


    Tell him to open up the walls enough for it all to be inspected - on his dime.


  • 8 years ago

    If he didn't call for inspections, he didn't pull a permit, which means he and his plumbing and electrical subs probably aren't licensed or insured. Don't pay him another dime until you talk to your local code department and tell them what's going on.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Thank you both for your quick responses. Permits were pulled on both but no inspection called for. It leads me to believe he did not really have any intention of finishing the project but more so to partially finish many things to get as much money as he could. Thus, he put the drywall up so that he could move on to finishes and start getting paid on that.


    Logically, I agree, that we should not pay for the work and that he should refund us for it or remove and replace everything on his own dime. Given what we've learned recently, I can't imagine that he is going to reimburse us and I worry that if this was the quality or work he did while being paid, what quality would he do or damage would he do to our property if not being paid?


    We contacted our inspector who came out and confirmed nothing had been inspected but he didn't seem to care too much about what was behind the walls, unfortunately.

  • 8 years ago

    You're going to have to stand up for yourself. Go to your code department, tell them what's going on, find out what's required and tell your contractor he can either do the work legally or get off your property.

  • 8 years ago

    Yes, there are ways to check the electrical and plumbing. I have seen this done as part of due diligence of commercial building sales.

  • 8 years ago

    You mentioned your inspector? Your city codes department inspector? Or someone you hired? The inspections should be a part of the permits--which are generally pulled at the codes office.

    If the work is required to pass a city/county code, then the city/county should provide inspectors. If that does not happen, you potentially have a situation where you could be sued(by the city/county), be required to remove the drywall so an inspection by city/county inspectors can be done, be able to sue the contractor for illegal work, or even sue the city/county codes office for dereliction of duty(or similar charge).

    There are ways to test plumbing for the absence of leaks by pressurizing the system with water(water can leak when air will not). There is not much way to find such a leak without seeing it. There is no reliable way to test electrical connections sight unseen. Or test for hidden junctions(in boxes or not are not code compliant) or proper cable/wire mounting security.

    It will be less expense to do that now than later. At best, the contractor will do it right. At worst, you may have to sue. Seems to me it would be a good idea to contact a lawyer now for advise.

  • 8 years ago

    Drywall has to come off, and the codes enforcement has to come out.

  • 8 years ago

    "There is no reliable way to test electrical connections sight unseen."

    I wouldn't say that. An ohmmeter can tell you something about the quality of the connections.

    But you shouldn't even need to do that. Unless you have flying splices inside the walls, which would usually be a code violation, all the electrical work should be in accessible junction boxes. These don't require drywall removal to inspect. Just remove the cover plates and canopies, unscrew any devices from the boxes, and pull the wiring out for a look.

  • 8 years ago

    Have you contacted an attorney? It could get real ugly when you tell your contractor that there's no more money coming until he makes it right. He might try to get a contractor's lien placed on the property.

    And yes, the drywall will have to come down. I have never met an inspector that would allow a builder to cover up new work before an inspection. Did he even have the framing inspection done?

    JM$.02W

  • 8 years ago

    Ok - let's back up a bit:


    It's important to know that code inspections work differently depending on the jurisdiction. Some places are very strict, some are very lax. I happen to live in a city where it's very lax - so I can speak to that. In my city there is VERY little inspection done on single family residential work. As long as you pay for the permit, it's unlikely you will ever see an inspector. If you call for a rough-in you can proceed with the next phase if an inspector doesn't show in 48 hours. You can bet that an inspector isn't going to show -- particularly on a small remodel job. Your situation might be different.


    You can get a feel for the quality of electrical work by removing the outlets / switches / fixtures to assess the quality of the work that's visible. Is the wire the right size? is it wired properly, is it done in a workmanship type manner? Are the required circuits in place? Are there GFCI's where required? etc. This doesn't take the place of a rough-in inspection... but will give an idea.


    Plumbing, particularly DWV, is more difficult to assess without seeing it.


    The thing is that if you have questions about the quality of the work - my guess is that you have good reason to be concerned.


    If you can find a home inspector that you really trust - or a GC that you really trust -- that doesn't know your current contractor that's the place to start.


    Also can you post some pics on here of work that you might think is questionable?

  • 8 years ago

    Just FYI: You want to document everything. Do things in writing. Take pictures.

    If you suspect seriously bad work or gross malpractice then you need to stop doing business with him. If it was less than that, you need to give him a chance to correct the problem.


    Know that getting an attorney involved isn't where you want to go first. That can be more expensive than taking the drywall down.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Why do people keep saying that you can't tell if DWV is done right without seeing it? DWV is probably the easiest thing in the house to test.

    There are two questions being addressed here, (1) inspection and (2) quality. I am not going to comment on electrical but for plumbing neither of these things are usually a huge endeavor.

    First, as to inspections, no one other than the inspector can completely answer this question, however, usually even if the inspector wants drywall off he will not require a lot of drywall off. In my experience they usually just want a 2' tall section of drywall removed starting about 1' above the fixture outlets, which is a very easily patched in piece of drywall. Again though, only the inspector can answer this, and he may do a visual inspection of what is available and order pressure tests.

    Next, as to quality, you can pressure test both the supply and DWV lines pretty easy. For supply lines just disconnect them at the water heater and tie in the hot and cold supply lines together with a pressure gauge and inflate it. For DWV buy the appropriate sized caps or plugs and attach a pressure balloon at the lower cleanout. Cap or plug all the outlets, get on the roof drop a plumbing smoke bomb into the roof vent and cap it. Put a small amount of pressure on it, if you see smoke you have a problem.

    Finally, check the general workmanship of the exposed plumbing. Plumbers who do good work, generally do good work everywhere. Now that isn't going to tell you whether or not your plumbing is running downhill or whether they put in the proper vents, but I rarely find plumbing done by actual plumbers that attempts to run uphill and skips venting, it simply isn't that expensive or hard to run the vents and it isn't worth the call back when you don't.

    -----------

    It is always a good idea to go through your home right before drywall is put up and take pictures of everything in the walls. I used to do this when it took film and never regretted it, now that we have cameras on our phones and digital image storage it just seems like a no-brainer. It can save you a lot of trouble later on.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You can't see if the proper fittings were used for DWV, or if venting was done properly, or if there is proper pitch or if any of the plumbing was protected with plates.

    I agree though that generally people who do good work on the exposed part (electrical or plumbing) generally do good work on the unexposed parts.

    An inspector may be satisfied with opening only specific areas rather than all of it.


    I like your idea of documenting everything before closing up walls. Sure solves a lot of second guessing later.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Without inspection, you may not be able to get a certificate of occupancy ( CO ) when you go to sell the home. At this point, I would get a lawyer.

    This story or a variation of it, is constantly repeated here on Houzz. You need to be involved with the project from start to finish - you can do most of this when the trades people leave for the day: read the permits / you should keep the signed off permits / look at the work yourself (neatness) / measure windows - door placement / tile / tile grout color / paint color - don't let any of these go buy without verifying.

  • 8 years ago

    You can't see if the proper fittings were used for DWV, or if venting was done properly, or if there is proper pitch or if any of the plumbing was protected with plates.

    Yes, but if the inspector isn't going to make you pull the drywall off, then this is about the best you can get. You are never going to get a contractor to expose plumbing for inspection that the inspector doesn't demand be exposed.

    So when testing for quality, that is really your only option. Of course, if the inspector demands everything is fully exposed then there is your answer, but my experience with inspectors is similar to yours. On commercial projects our inspectors tag work that is fine but pass residential work over the phone.

  • 8 years ago

    Yes, but if the inspector isn't going to make you pull the drywall off, then this is about the best you can get. You are never going to get a contractor to expose plumbing for inspection that the inspector doesn't demand be exposed.


    Well what are you paying $1,000's of dollars in permit fees if the work isn't inspected?

  • 8 years ago

    I assume this means you did not take any pictures of the plumbing or electrical while it was exposed? If you know where the plumbing and electrical are in the walls and have pictures of how its installed, you may not need to remove "all" the drywall to know if it was done correctly. And of course you only need to remove drywall on one side of a framed wall to view electrical and plumbing.


    It sounds like your AJH might be a little lazy about inspections, and your contractor is even worse. However, I'm sure you want to know the work was done correctly, so you do need to open the walls, as needed, and allow the inspector to do the inspection and sign off. If you let the inspection slide now you may never get a final approval, and then you are really stuck.


    Bruce

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    "Is there a reliable way to check the electrical and plumbing work that has been done without removing all of the dry wall and having to replace it all?"


    Yes. It depends on the working relationship inspection has developed with the mechanical subs. If he hasn't issued them a red tag in a while, he may take their word that the work is fine.

  • 8 years ago

    Good points, Ron, thanks for bringing those up.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I don't know how it works in your area, but the municipalities we work in require the trades to pull their own permits and request their own inspections. If this is the case, the problem could be a consequence of a simple misunderstanding and not an attempt by the GC to short circuit the inspection process.

    Joseph Corlett provides sound, practical advice. Depending on the quality of workmanship the electrician and plumber are known for, the inspector may give them a get-out-of-jail free card. Domestic hot/cold water piping is normally subject to a pressure test which can be done without removing any drywall.

  • 8 years ago

    Here, the owner is responsible but the GC is almost always the one who handles it on new construction.

  • 8 years ago

    It sounds like there are a couple of issues here:

    1. How to move forward with an inspection so that the City is satisfied and so that the permit can be closed out and COO issued or otherwise finalled. This all depends on the inspection department and ranges from "Open it all up" to "yeah, we don't really care about this little job, we take your word for it".


    2. Perhaps the bigger issue - How can the Owner trust that the contractor has done a reasonable job and isn't covering up bad work for just long enough to get paid.


    Those are really two different issues. The City (issue #1) is easy enough... have your contractor call the city and schedule an inspection or otherwise deal with the issue and provide documentation that it was resolved one way or the other.

    Issue #2 will be more difficult: If you suspect that the contractor is covering up bad work, there's usually a reason you suspect it. Get a trusted, unrelated, contractor or home inspector to give you an unbiased opinion.