Software
Houzz Logo Print
sssparklee

radiant heating Worth it?

8 years ago
I really wanted radiant heating throughout my house (~2500 sq ft) as we are remodeling the entire house, with all the floors being replaced.
We live in Bay Area (Los gatos), and I am being persuaded against it by contractor and architect for the reasons of:

1. Weather on our area don’t get cold enough to have radiant heat
2. Expensive
3. No Central air conditioning.
I think it’s worth the investment but since I have little knowledge in this area, wanted to get some thoughts.

Thoughts? (Anyone heard of war board or similar radiant heating system)

Thanks!!!

Comments (5)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    In Los Gatos, you have much more need for good central air conditioning than heating. With a good duct system in place, adding a furnace is trivial and not very expensive to buy or operate. You can put in radiant heating if you want but then you'll essentially have two HVAC systems.

    Radiant heating in the Bay Area isn't all that common, especially not in Silicon Valley with our hot summers and very mild winters. As a result, really good radiant HVAC contractors are also not that numerous.

    I know two people with radiant heating, both systems embedded in concrete slabs. One had a leak and the concrete had to be busted open to fix it, it was a mess. For the other, it works fine in the original part of the house but in an addition, a water to air heat exchanger was used to produce forced air heating and it works poorly. Both would change out their radiant systems if it weren't so expensive to do so.

  • 8 years ago

    Can you explain why you really want radiant heating?

  • 8 years ago
    Hi Mike. Thank you for your feedback. I wanted radiant heat for two reasons:
    1. Less dust through air duct
    2. Less dry during heating

    I probably will end up with central heat and air.
  • 8 years ago

    Susan,

    A forced air heating system doesn't create dust. If you have a good 4 inch media filter and change it regularly you should not have a dust problem. If there is any air borne dust the filter will collect it.

    Forced air heating system also do not dry out the air. The major cause of low indoor humidity is outside air infiltration through leaky windows and doors. If you do have low humidity, a humidifier could be installed. In this case having a forced air system would be an advantage.

  • 8 years ago
    Thanks Mike. We will opt in for central heat and air instead of radiant. It makes sense. . Thank you for your advice