Software
Houzz Logo Print
lauren_barnard

Please help! BM Oxford White with BM Chantilly Lace

I’m going insane. I want to paint my living room (east exposure) white & am looking for a lovely wall/trim combo. I was going to do Chantilly Lace in semi-gloss for the trim and fireplace mantle with Decorator’s White in Matte on the walls. However after doing some test patches last night I’m afraid the Decorator’s White will read too gray/silver against to the Chantilly Lace. I’m trying to achieve a soft white for the walls & would like to avoid yellow undertones. I’m thinking Oxford White in Matte for the walls will help me achieve this look, even with the semi-gloss Chantilly trim, but I cannot find any pictures.

Thought it was worth a try to reach out to see if anyone has a picture of this combo or can direct me to a site that does. Thank you!! I’ve attached a pic of my space...Chantilly is on the right & Decorator’s is on the left.

Comments (23)

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Why not stick with the Chantilly Lace on the walls as well? Just having a difference in sheen will give a nice, soft effect, and since you like the Chantilly Lace for trim, and you want a white room, then why not try it on the walls too?

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The two colors you mention are so close that it's not worth agonizing over. As Wow Great Place said, do the walls and trim in the same color. If you want a contrast, then select two colors that really are different.

  • 7 years ago
    The wall below the bench is Oxford and the trim/ area next to the tile is Chantilly lace. This room has east and north-facing windows.
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    You've proved my point--they look exactly the same.

  • 7 years ago
    I have Oxford white but my large room is west facing and I love it . The trim colour is unknown, it was in the house when we moved in. We’ll have to paint it soon.

    How big is your room ? I noticed my Oxford white looks a bit blah in one of the small bedrooms.
    General rule, whites look their best in large spaces
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Your perception of the colors is totally dependent on the lighting in the room. I'll repeat my comment from before--the colors are too close to provide a nice contrast, but in certain lights you are possibly seeing a difference in hue, chroma or value. The best course of action if you aren't adept at mixing whites is to use the same color on both the trim and the walls.

  • 7 years ago
    Thanks Lauren for the post..I am in the same boat. Want to use BM decoreters white or BM chantilly lace for the walls..they are so similar!!
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    Thank you all for your input!! I appreciate all the pictures! I think after seeing them (they’re all gorgeous) we want to go a bit higher in chroma for our walls...I’ve seen pictures of BM White Heron and really like it, but I’m unsure of the chroma value...anyone know?

    Our living room is 16x19 and the sun room (directly off the living room) is 8x14.

    Also considering BM Simply White too. We are deciding today so please wish us luck
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I'm going to repeat myself a third time and state that White Heron is another very light white which is very similar to Chantilly Lace and Oxford White, so I wouldn't use them together.

    Please use the same color for trim and walls UNLESS you want a real contrast between them. In that case, use a real color with some umph in it--dark or medium gray/green/yellow/orange/blue/purple.

    Now I'll get off my soapbox....

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    Thanks Diana - I was simply asking if anyone knew the chroma value for White Heron so that I could determine how close it is to Chantilly since I didn’t know. I had only seen pictures. I also believe that is the first time anyone has mentioned White Heron in this thread so I’m not sure why you feel the need to say that you’ve explained something for the third time now.

    I ended up choosing BM Cloud Cover...not yellowish, but more of a neutral toned down white. I think it’s perfect so far...not done painting yet.
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Sorry, Lauren, if I came on too strong about White Heron. I know no one mentioned it, but because it's a light white with a very hard to discern hue it's going to present the same problems that using Oxford and Chantilly Lace did. Namely that the colors are much too close.

    The one you chose, Cloud Cover, looks like a nice contrast to the Chantilly Lace trim.

    Good luck with the rest of your project!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I painted our trim Oxford white and used ballet slipper on the walls. Looks a little to yellow I i wanted a warm white to go with Oxford trim?? any thoughts.

  • 5 years ago

    Oxford white is more of a cool/gray...

  • 5 years ago

    Is there any way to put a soft white with the Oxford white trim. What do you suggest?

  • 5 years ago


    White Dove is a more colourful White than Oxford White - see the difference in Chroma.

    In comparison Oxford White is much more neutral.


    Oxford White is also slightly higher in Value so is just a little lighter.


    You would need to view in your space to see if you like the combination, but the difference in Chroma should ensure neither looks dingy/dirty next to the other.

  • 5 years ago

    I'm trying to decide on a white for a rental apartment in a row house where the front and back rooms get good light but the two middle rooms are a bit darker. Would Oxford white be good for that? Considered Chantilly Lace but it's a tad too gray, and Simply White reads a bit too yellow in a smaller/darker room. Thanks!

  • 5 years ago

    Hi all, deciding on our wall color in our kitchen. For some reason everything is showing up very dark in our space, I have no idea why. It’s open concept with a slider and triple double hung window. This was taken at night, trim is chantilly and I’m deciding between these (top: white heron, middle: Oxford white, bottom: white wisp). Any ideas why they are showing up so much darker in my space than others? Leaning toward Oxford but curious

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Stephanie, start your own post. this belongs to someone else, and is over two years old. start your own w/your own info and pictures.

    In fact, I don't know why other people are piggy backing on this post with personal questions. if you want help, make your own post, otherwise, no one is going to read this.

  • 5 years ago

    I figured it was relevant since all 3 paint colors were mentioned but I am happy to start a new one.

  • 5 years ago

    Oxford white is a soft white it has a passive slight warmth it doesn’t feel icy or overly warm I love it ♥️

  • 4 years ago

    @hemina Hey i have Oxford white as my wall and chantilly Lace as my trim in my family room abd I love it but I have Oxford white as my trim in other rooms now if you go on The Benjamin moore site they now actually list Oxford white and Chantilly Lace as cordinating/matching colors They also list White Dove as a similar color to oxford white.. White Dove walls with oxford white trim is Gorgeous just like Oxford white walls with Chantilly lace trim ♥️



  • 4 years ago

    @Nice would you mind sharing a photo of your Chantilly trim and oxford walls? I am considering this combo now because Id like a touch of warmth on the walls