Software
Houzz Logo Print
prentiss_leaird

Urgent help need picking a sink

7 years ago
I picked out granite yesterday and convinced my fabricator to bump my templating & install dates up so we can have a working kitchen before Thanksgiving. They are coming to template on Thursday and installing next Wednesday. I have to give them a decision on a sink ASAP! I could really use some advice.

All 4 pictures have our granite choice (Bianco Antico) with off-white cabinets similar to what we have. Backsplash will probably be a solid-color and fairly simple so it doesn’t compete with the granite.

We will have darker brown colors coming in with a walnut island countertop, medium brown hardwood floors, oil rubbed bronze hardware and light fixtures.

Appliances are stainless steel.

Faucet can go either way - stainless or oil rubbed bronze.

Our sink options are Kraus stainless steel or Silgranit in either biscuit (cream), truffle (light brown) or cafe brown (dark brown). Pictures are just for color reference. The sink will be a 50/50.

Please chime in with advice to help me make this difficult decision. I have not seen any of these sinks in person but they are very popular here on Houzz. Thank you!

Comments (47)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I do not care for the dark sink at all. I like the cream, if it goes with your cabinets and granite - and stainless is always a safe option.

  • 7 years ago
    I would choose stainless. Keep in mind that all stainless steel is not equal. Get the best and heaviest you can.
  • 7 years ago
    My husband likes to hand wash a lot of our dishes. He prefers a 50/50 sink. If he does the dishes I’ll let him have what he wants. I only hand wash dishes in a dire emergency.
  • 7 years ago

    Have you ever seen a Silgranit sink, or at least the material, in person? I know a lot of people like them but I’m not a fan, so if those are my choices I would go with stainless. Kraus makes a good quality sink (definitely get the heaviest you can).

  • 7 years ago
    Stainless double sink smart/low divide. Best of both worlds!
  • 7 years ago
    I haven’t seen any of these sinks in person. If we go with stainless I will order the Kraus from Amazon. I’m guessing it is better quality than the one the granite fabricator sells and costs the same or less. They can provide the Silgranit sink if we decide to go that route but their price is higher than elsewhere. I will probably just order that one from Home Depot with 2 day delivery unless they agree to match the price. Unfortunately they don’t have one in stock for me to look at.
  • 7 years ago
    Correction: Silgranit is available from Lowe’s not Home Depot.
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Blanco is what we have and love it. Its 12 inches deep and I can even fit my tall 3 year old in there for a bath since his tub was being repaired.

  • 7 years ago

    I have a Blanco Silgranit Biscuit sink, my husband dumps his black coffee in the sink. It is always looking dirty. I have to follow the Blanco instructions for stubborn stain removal regularly. It is annoying. I am getting stainless next time. It is also chipped from where people have dropped forks into the sink and the tines were facing downward.

    Per Blanco: For stubborn stains ~ a solution of
    50% bleach, 50% water should only be used for tough, stubborn stains. Let the solution sit in the bottom
    of the sink for one hour; then scrub. Rinse well.

  • 7 years ago
    That’s concerning. Honestly I’m hesitant to get stainless due to scratching but I would be more upset with chips in my granite sink. Color-wise I am wondering if the truffle or cafe brown would show less stains than biscuit.
  • 7 years ago
    As a wise man has said here often (Joseph!) scratches can be easily buffed out of stainless.

    Here’s a pic of our Kohler sink. It’s huge and gorgeous! I’ve had an equal divide for 15 years but with the larger size sink, an offset bowl will work even better for my needs.
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Nobody wants a 50/50 sink anymore. He does dishes? Great! Use a mat next to the sink:)

    And nothing is easier than stainless. A good one . Nice big single bowl for the pots and pans.

    You need that onsite for template. You're way late

    Mt fabricator would not cut without sink

    in HAND at the shop . Today is 11/6.

    Good luck

  • 7 years ago
    Stainless, we have the Kraus and it’s a great sink. Mine came with a bottom sink protector .
  • 7 years ago

    I would do the truffle silgranit. I have an elkay quartz sink. It's a 60/40 low divide. We can do dishes in it easily. We use it a lot. It hasn't stained (it's black), and there are absolutely no chips. We don't baby it at all. I have 6 kids living at home, 7 during the summer, and this has taken a lot of abuse. We've had it almost a year.

  • 7 years ago

    My Kraus sink arrived yesterday, I can't believe how great the quality is! Highly recommend! I got their prep sink also, blown away that I got these amazing sinks for such a great deal on amazon.

  • 7 years ago
    Jan Moyer I just ordered the granite this morning. If I order the Kraus it will be here Thursday, Friday at the latest. Templating is on Thursday and they have said that is fine if it comes on Friday. It’s all a bit rushed but this wasn’t a remodel we planned to do. Our dishwasher turned on us while we were away on vacation. We came home to mold and a kitchen that had to be gutted. There has been very little time for planning and researching.
  • 7 years ago
    I have no experience with the colored sinks (I have stainless steel), but I’m intrigued by the light brown. It looks pretty with that granite and it’s different. Seems like it would hide stains. I don’t love SS, just a personal preference- it feels too industrial for me.
  • 7 years ago
    luckyblueeye did you get the standard stainless finish or the scratch-resist?
  • 7 years ago
    Karen Rose fo you have the standard stainless finish or the scratch-resist finish?
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I have had fireclay sinks and stainless steel. I lean toward SS. I currently have a Krauss sink in this new build. We like it. We have also had Oliveria. I loved that sink. It was huge and made really well. It is now double the price of the Krauss so we went with the Krauss. I agree get a sink that you like to use. Double or single make sure it is what you like. And get a sink that is heavy that won't rust. Look for 18 percent chromium and 8 percent nickel to avoid corrosion. Get a sink that 16 or 18 gauge. You want to stay away from 22 gauge. They dent a little more than the others. But when I say dent, All sinks will get dented or scratched but I have found a satin to sort of hide those minor scratches. There are sinks that claim to be scratch resistant. I don't think they really are.

  • 7 years ago
    Boxerpal which Kraus sink did you order? Some come with the option of an embossed finish that is supposed to be scratch-resistant. I can’t get a good idea of what it looks like. I’m afraid it might look odd.
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Karuss This is from the add.


    Kraus KBU14 31-1/2 inch Undermount Single Bowl 16-gauge Stainless Steel Kitchen Sink



    And here is mine,



    Boxer's kitchen choices 2018 · More Info


  • PRO
    7 years ago

    single

    huge

    SS


  • 7 years ago

    60/40 with low divide. I always have things in the dish drainer in the small side and hate having it on the counter.

  • 7 years ago
    I would choose stainless. I chose a large single stainless sink 5 years ago and still love it. You can fit large pans in it. Stainless I’d also easy to keep clean and shiny.
  • 7 years ago

    Definitely stainless. I prefer a large single bowl but if a double bowl would inspire my husband to do dishes I could be persuaded to a double bowl.

  • 7 years ago

    Prentiss, I got the KHU100-30 16 gauge for the main sink

  • 7 years ago
    I let my granite installer talk me out of a Silgranit sink and I’m still irritated. I chose the Franke Kubus stainless steel sink, which is bulletproof, but I’d rather have the quieter nature of the composite. My sink has neat gizmos, though — hanging colander and mid level drying/washing rack. I have a very busy kitchen, and the stainless is probably a better long term choice. Sigh.
  • 7 years ago
    Count me among the single-bowl enthusiasts. We have a split sink and except for a few things drying (that never seem to get put away because the sink is their hiding spot), it serves no purpose. (For drying dishes, there are racks that hover over the left side of your big single basin.)

    But I can’t say how many times I wanted a bigger sink for sheet pans, lasagna pans, etc. As for the stainless, the only downside seems to be scratches—which, honestly, is nothing to worry about as (a) it’s a sink, who cares (what next, polished and waxed toilet bowls?) (b) after a short while, the scratches cancel each other out and you see none of them.
  • 7 years ago
    Mine is the scratch resistant and noise reducing 16 gauge.
  • 7 years ago
    You don't have time to order a sink with the template happening on Thursday. Go to the best plumbing and fixture place in town for the biggest selection, or Lowe's or Home Depot for an okay selection and buy something they have in stock. I have the rounded two-size bowl sink and really like it. You want two bowls for your main kitchen sink.
  • 7 years ago

    When we moved into our current home, it was a newer build and had the dark brown sink installed, with white/grey quartz and dark cabinets. I would have never chosen the combination, but I have to say that I love the sink!! It doesn't show any spots, easy to clean.

  • 7 years ago
    I have the blanco cafe brown and love it. Went 60/40 and can wash large pans. But regret not getting the one bowl.
  • 7 years ago

    Stainless Steel and get Bar Keepers Friend to keep it shiny and new looking. Single or double but as deep as your cabinets will allow.

  • 7 years ago

    Single bowl. How will you wash the Thanksgiving roasting pans and baking sheets in a split sink?

    I hate split sinks, obviously.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    +1 on what localeater says. I went back and forth between stainless and silgranit. Couldn’t find a stainless sink in my price range that didn’t have 0 radius corners. Went with white silgranit. Ditto the coffee stains, which I clean with pretty much every other day with baking soda and dish soap. Ditto the chips from forks or what-have-you that are discolored and don’t come clean. So so so disappointed.

  • 7 years ago

    A sink is a personal preference. What works for others might not work for you. Once a granite counter is installed, a sink cannot be changed. Similar to Jan Moyer, my fabricator had ro have sink prior to cutting granite. I would not rush an expensive decision that may cause remorse. Personally, I’d eat out for Thanksgiving.

  • 7 years ago

    I had a Silgranit sink in our last kitchen and loved it but went with stainless in our new house because our builder didn't offer the color we wanted and honestly it's just as nice to me.

    I would either choose the stainless steel or the biscuit one...no one wants a poop brown sink. But, the biscuit will show more food particles, etc so I'd personally lean more toward the stainless.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    We are going with Blanco Silgranit and even my husband is excited about the choice. We have seen them in person and like the appearance and the feel (and all the positive reviews). We have not finalized our color choice, but it will either be Metallic Gray or Truffle. We like having color, either light or dark, whichever will match the best. Not a fan of stainless. Can you take Blanco color samples to your fabricator (and home with a counter sample to look at in your own light) to help you finalize your color choice? FYI, I believe the dark brown sample we saw was pretty dark. The cream may be too light.. Truffle might be a good fit, would be great to get a color sample to hold next to your counter material. Oh ~ and I concur with the suggestion to not rush the decision/install. A new kitchen (especially one forced upon you by a rogue dishwasher or other disaster) is a big deal. An expensive, long-lasting big deal. Don't rush. Good luck!

  • 7 years ago
    Thanks everyone. The sink has been ordered. After several people on this post reported chips and stains in the Silgranit sinks we decided to go with stainless. Our new Kraus sink will be here on Friday which is fine with our granite fabricator. They won’t actually cut our granite until Monday.
  • 6 years ago

    How is your Kraus sink holding up? I’m about to purchase a Krause or a Franke and need to decide this week! Thanks.

  • 6 years ago

    Kari - I just bought my workstation sink yesterday from Rachiele. Check out their Clearance page if you're interested, or email them about what you're looking for. Good Luck!

  • 6 years ago

    Kari I am just now seeing your post. Our Krause sink is holding up fine. We are happy with it.

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks for the reply Re the Krause sink. We just received our Franke SS Kubus 28” Sink. We purchased it because of all the positive reviews about the inside “shelf” - it was 3x the cost of the Krause, so I hope it will prove to be worth it. Made in Switzerland 18 gauge which we were told is as good as the 16 gauge Chinese....we hope so. Now to buy the bottom rack and the middle shelf rack...all the accessories sure add up. Also looking for a sleek gooseneck faucet now - considering Grohe.

  • 6 years ago

    I had a 60/40 SS in my last house & I miss it!! The 40 side was fine for the few hand wash things to drain. It was always clean for washing veggies, especially greens.

  • 6 years ago

    I have the second sink (60/40) with stainless footed grid inserts...really like it. The previous sink was the same make but didn’t have the grid inserts...a very useful addition.