Software
Houzz Logo Print
momrules5831

Insurance Claim - Experiences?

8 years ago

We own a rental property, a single family home leased to a pair of divorcees. They were both away overnight during a weekend when a valve on the side of a toilet in the master bathroom broke and water gushed from the pipe for ~18 hours until the tenant returned home the next afternoon. By that point, there was water pooled 3-4 inches deep through the entire house. Luckily I have a homeowner's insurance policy specifically written for landlord/leased property coverage.


This was a Sunday, so I called ServPro (a water remediation firm) and they started cleaning everything up that afternoon. First thing Monday morning (Sept. 30) I called to report the damage. An inspector came to the house on October 3 to survey after which he prepared the estimate of damages and cost to repair/replace.


It took several weeks and lots of prodding before I finally got the completed estimate. The remediation bill alone is almost $10,000. I have loss of use coverage so the company is estimating 4 months' lost rent. All flooring has to be replaced (remediation company ripped it all out the first day to get at standing water), all baseboards, plaster walls, repainting of entire house, new kitchen cabinets etc. The entire estimate is in the high 5 figures.


My tenants were unable to live in the house of course and opted to break their lease and move out, which I understand and which is their right under our state's real estate laws.


So, it is now November 14. The house is a wreck, I can't lease it out because it's not livable and I'm still waiting for a check from the insurance provider. I do not want to begin repair work until/unless I know what is happening with the insurance. I have of course kept meticulous track of EVERYTHING from correspondence to records of the damage (tenant actually had the presence of mind to video the gushing valve and the house when she found the damage). I have been emailing or calling at least every week and I keep being told the process is ongoing.


Clearly this is a worst case scenario and I truly have no idea whether a wait of 6 weeks and counting is typical and normal or whether I"m being jerked around by the insurance company. I have never experienced anything like this--the only homeowner's insurance claim we've ever filed was to get reimbursed for a generator after hurricane Andrew in 1992.


I'm sure there are folks here who have gone through home disasters and insurance claims, so any advice or experience would be most appreciated!

Comments (26)

  • 8 years ago

    Lukki, thanks! Hadn't thought of that but I am going to check now. The manager at the insurance agency that sold us the policy helped get the estimate at least completed and submitted so I suppose moving up the chain of command is now an option.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We had a similar situation at our parents home. The insurance agency (Travelers) assigned a case manager. All invoices, including ServPro, were submitted to and paid by the insurance company. This was 10 years ago.

    runninginplace thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I've had to call my state Insurance Commissioner twice (2 different states), and had FAST, EXCELLENT results both times. It would seem the insurance companies take them pretty seriously.

    runninginplace thanked Bestyears
  • 8 years ago

    Sorry you had this experience. Last April we came home to a flooded house. The line to the ice maker sprung a leak. We had been at our cabin for a few days so had no idea how long the the water was spraying. Every room in our house had damage to the floors.

    Our first call was to our insurance agent, who gave us the number the claims dept of our carrier. The insurance company had the crew from the drying company (Advanced Drying Systems, great crew) at our house within 2 hours. They did all the cleanup, pulling up wet carpet and flooring, raising furniture so it wouldn’t be damaged, etc.

    They pull off the baseboards and started the drying machines Luckily our drywall was ok.

    The insurance adjuster came about a week later. They sent a contractor to give an estimate of repairs. (We also had our own people give us estimates).

    We had a check within 2 weeks of the first call.

    Accepting the initial check did not mean the case was closed. If more problems arose, we could have put in another claim.

    As bad as the whole experience was, dealing with our insurance company was a breeze. A pleasant surprise because we have heard horror stories.

    (We never saw the bill from Advanced Drying Systems, that was handled by the insurance company.)

    AND our premiums did not go up. Yet!

    Good luck!


    runninginplace thanked maddielee
  • 8 years ago

    Ugh. I am so sorry to hear you are dealing with this. I know insurance industry practices vary by region and I am in Canada, but here we had a 3rd party person (can't remember the title of her position) who dealt with the insurance company. She mediated when we had issues with the restoration company, helped us find a place to live while ours was being restored, etc. Hope you are able to resolve things before too long.

    runninginplace thanked daisychain Zn3b
  • 8 years ago

    We had a similar situation in our house(not a rental). Water running all weekend in the kitchen while we were away skiing. We have nationwide insurance. Called them on Sunday afternoon when we returned. They had remediation team there 8am Monday morning. We never saw a bill from them. They moved all the furniture to a lower level family room. Ripped out all the wood flooring, Removed all the kitchen cabinets. Ran high power fans and dehumifiers for two days. Offered to put us up in a hotel. We declined. Closest hotel was too far, kids in high school, we were working. Our upper level bedrooms were livable. When we complained that the LR and DR furniture made our family room unlivable, they put a pod in our driveway and moved all our furniture into it. On Monday afternoon, nationwide adjuster came to assess damages and handed us a check for $3K for immediate needs. Told us to keep all receipts for restaurants and take out.

    We made up a list of damaged items. Insurance gave us replacement value on everything. Only a few lower kitchen cabinets were damaged and at first they only wanted to replace those. We argued that replacements wouldn't match and they relented, giving us $20K to put towards new cabinets. We received checks from them incrementally, as costs were agreed to. I think we received all monies from them within 4 weeks of the incident(about 80K in total). Our microwave stopped working about 2 months after the flood and they replaced that for us too.

    runninginplace thanked czarinalex
  • 8 years ago

    So sorry this is happening to you! Good reminder to turn off water when we go out of town!

    runninginplace thanked cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Oh what a nightmare to deal with!! I am so sorry!

    I had a good friend who had a similar experience.

    They were out of town, house sitter flushed a toilet on the 2nd floor, left for the weekend and the water ran for 48 hours. The house was only 6 months old.

    Water permeated down through the entire 1st floor of house. The whole house had to be gutted back to the studs. New flooring, new kitchen cabinets, new electrical wiring, light fixtures EVERYTHING had to be replaced and even some new appliances.

    The insurance company also paid to have their furniture cleaned and then stored. When it was determined that the house would have to be gutted, they then had to find a rental home that would lease for "short term." Since their furniture was in storage, they had to rent furniture.

    t took over 8 or 9 months for the process to be completed. My friend is quite tenacious as well as meticulous. She had to stay on the insurance company constantly. There were times she said she wished she'd just turned it over to an attorney.

    Good luck!

    runninginplace thanked pudgeder
  • 8 years ago

    Yup - we always turn our water off when we are out of town unless we've left the cats home with a cat sitter. And cabin water off whenever we're not there. I'm sure it would be hard to get renters to take responsibility for doing that.


    runninginplace thanked 3katz4me
  • 8 years ago

    Well, I’m glad it’s a place for you to start, I’ll keep my fingers crossed for you and watch for an update!

    runninginplace thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Any chance the House has a mortgage on it which may complicate receiving a settlement? In our case there is no mortgage so the check came straight to us. Just wondering what may be causing the delay?

    runninginplace thanked maddielee
  • 8 years ago

    Sorry to hear your experience. We had a small leak from the outside faucet, down the wall and into a bedroom. Noticed it when we returned from a vacation. Ruined the wood flooring and molded the clothes. Our insurance experience with State Farm was first rate. A crew was on the scene the same day with the dehumidifiers and such, even before the agent showed up. Replaced all the flooring, dry cleaned all the clothes, premium didn't increase.

    runninginplace thanked jrb451
  • 8 years ago

    Are you in an area affected by recent hurricanes or fires? If so, it may just be that the insurance company is overloaded with claims. But I agree with others on contacting the state insurance regulator. My sister used to work for a Congressman and she advised the same whenever there was any kind of issue with an insurance company. They do not want to be on the state’s radar.

    Donna

    runninginplace thanked msmeow
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I appreciate all the responses, it is so helpful to hear about what others have experienced and you've given me some great suggestions too.

    I did check my state insurance commission website (great tip Lukki) and there is a homeowner's claim bill of rights that includes a deadline for getting insurance settlements; it's 90 days so at 6 weeks I suppose that is within the time frame. Still, since I have loss of use and weeks ago they calculated a 4 month payout (we are heading into the end of month 2 with nothing done at all), if this goes on I'm going to push to increase that sum, since the policy is limited by a dollar amount not time length. Of course we are now also heading into the holidays, which delays things even more. I can't see how this house will be rentable again before the New Year.

    Tomorrow I will contact the adjuster and the manager at the agency, and tell them both that I'm going to escalate to the owner of the agency and the state insurance commission if the payment is not forthcoming. Otherwise I think they will just keep dawdling on for who knows how long?

    To answer some questions, the insurer is Lloyds of London and several folks including the remediation company manager said they take a long time; even the agency manager said they handle claims 'differently'. There is no mortgage on the property. And the remediation was top notch-they came within a couple of hours of my call on a Sunday afternoon and had place dried out and flooring, etc removed within a few days. They are supposed to be paid directly by the insurance but I'm wondering if I will soon get calls from them since I presume they haven't gotten a check either.

    I'll check back in when things get resolved and thanks again!

  • 8 years ago

    I have no personal experience with a homeowner claim, but do with a vehicle hit in my driveway and totaled. An attorney told me to never except the first offer and if a large claim you should hire an advocate. In other words hire a claims adjuster for yourself. I don't know if this is really needed, but I refused my first claim on my vehicle, itemized every little thing, including destroyed contents of vehicle and ended up with a lot more.

  • 8 years ago

    I grew up in the insurance business since my dad was an independent agent. I later worked for an insurance company. In between, I worked with a couple of law firms. I've seen insurance claims from every angle -- I would not recommend hiring an attorney or claims rep until you have fully tried to resolve things yourself or unless you really aren't able to represent yourself.

    You will have to do the legwork to gather the proof of what was damaged and why what you are being offered isn't sufficient. Another person is not going to be able to pull that out of the air and without it, you aren't entitled to payment.

    Be thorough, meticulous, but reasonable and most people should get the same amount with or without -- and you don't have to pay someone else to double your work. Lawyers will typically take 30-40% of what they recover -- PLUS expenses. And they will be looser with expenses than you will be because it doesn't come out of their share.

    As for timing of payment, they should be able to tell you what is holding things up or when you can expect payment. It is possible that they will pay contractors for the work done rather than pay you in advance of the work being done. Find out where the log jam is. And if they should be paying you, check with your state insurance department. There may be a time frame within which they are supposed to pay your claim once a reasonable determination of coverage and amount has been made.

  • 7 years ago

    Runninginplace, I am wondering where you stand on this. We are just starting the process with my MIL's house after a pipe burst.

  • 7 years ago

    Bonnie -- I hope you know not to wait on the insurance company to take measures to dry out everything as much as possible and remove anything so saturated it cannot be dried (carpet and padding are often in that category if a lot has been saturated. Corners, edges and smaller areas can usually be dried -- the carpet may be able to be dried and re-stretched even if the pad has to be replaced.

    If you act quickly, you may be able to save a lot. I had a toilet water connection split and flood an upstairs bathroom, seep into adjoining carpet and run down into my front hall and master BR. My biggest fear was the wood flooring downstairs. Between grabbing towels, sopping and wringing into the bathtub and then doing the same downstairs, followed by a shop vac over and over along the crevices between the boards and setting up a number of fans, I was surprised that we were able to save the flooring.

    If you need to buy fans, a shop vac or hire someone to help with the immediate water removal and dry out, that should be covered by insurance, subject to the deductible. Don't start replacing things other than repair of the pipe until you have talked to an adjuster. Hope it goes smoothly for you.

  • 7 years ago

    Hi Lascatx, While en route to my MIL’s house we called the insurance company and SerPro. ServPro was at the house within an hour using vacs, dehumidifiers and dryers. Because it was a holiday weekend it took a day to receive a call back from the insurance company, but they reassured us that calling ServPro was absolutely the right thing to do. We took MIL to our vacation house for a few days while her house dried out. ServPro was back this week for a site visit with the insurance adjuster and to start demo on ceiling removal. To be continued. Thank you for your feedback.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    ServePro is one of 2 or 3 big companies that are considered the experts. They are the ones the insurance companies call. If it's more than you can handle, you did exactly the right thing. And doing it quickly is so important -- wet is one thing to deal with, but moldy is worse. So at least you know you are off to a good start. :)

    ETA: After Harvey, there were ServePro trucks and crews camped out in our Costco parking lot where they and their insurance adjusters set up temp offices and RVs for sleeping, etc. If they can clean up the nasty stuff that water brought, they can handle anything a normal house can throw at them.

  • 7 years ago

    Lascatx, sounds like you had the same type of leak/flood we experienced, except in my case there was nobody home so the water gushed unimpeded through the house for 18 hours!

    And Bonnie, our situation is very similar to yours; we also called ServPro immediately and they were at the house within an hour or so--on a Sunday afternoon! They did an amazing job drying things out and actually had all the flooring off within about 36 hours of the flood to completely dry out the underfloor and avoid mold which is a HUGE issue as you can imagine in Miami FL. Like your MIL's house they placed large fans, dehumidifiers etc. and checked on a daily basis to ensure the moisture levels were low. We also reported the damage immediately on Monday morning and the insurance adjuster told us the same thing, that ServPro was exactly the right choice.

    As for an update, the day before Thanksgiving after almost daily email inquiries for weeks I finally got the paperwork saying the claim was approved, along with a statement of loss I had to sign and notarize to process the payment. I sent that in earlier this week and was notified yesterday the payment will be processed (hopefully meaning a check issued!) within 10-14 business days.

    Based on that I told my contractor we can get started. I picked up floor tile samples yesterday, focusing on in stock materials because his floor guys will start work December 10th. Even if I don't have payment in hand, everything seems legally in order so I am comfortable moving forward. Once the work is done I can get the house on the rental market again although I hope things aren't too slow during the holidays.

  • 7 years ago

    With all the floods, hurricanes, fires and now this earthquake, I can only imagine how backed up insurance claims must get at times. Glad you got through that phase and hope the reno goes smoothly now.

    I was lucky to be home when ours happened -- although it took me a few minutes to realize what had happened. DH and I had planned to leave together than morning but I was finishing something on my laptop and he took off with me following behind him. I can only imagine 18 hours worth of water. Ugh. But glad you got ServPro out so quickly. My dad always told me and his clients that quick action as soon as you discover the problem is important -- don't wait.

  • 7 years ago

    Running, I am so glad to see you’re last post. What an ordeal! I was also surprised to see that the wait you had is considered to be “acceptable”. I will keep my fingers crossed that the rest of your project goes smoothly!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thanks for the good wishes. I'm working with a contractor that has done two projects for me already--and one was the complete rehab/updating of this flooded house when we inherited it! That was a HUGE accomplishment because the former owner was a chain smoking hoarding eccentric, so I know my guy's work and his standards are excellent. I'm very hopeful this phase will be accomplished smoothly and without delay.

    I'm going to install wood look tile throughout the house as replacement flooring. It's a popular option here in FL; easy to maintain and hard to damage which are both renter advantages. I'm planning on using it for our vacation/retirement home as well. So I'm viewing this as a decorating trial run to see an install done 'live' by the workers who will probably do mine too since I'm going to use the same contractor :).

  • 7 years ago

    Hi Running, what a relief for you to be moving forward on this. I hope the restoration goes smoothly and that this ordeal will soon be over.

    We are just starting the process of getting contractors in MIL's house. It is a challenge dealing with a 91 year old who has dementia and does not want to leave her house.