Software
Houzz Logo Print
wendy_pitcher

Kitchen Cabinet advise

8 years ago
I am trying to decide on material and colour for new kitchen cabinets. I have decided on a Shaker style and am looking for a clean more updated look. The granite and black splash will not change. We have oak window trim and oak floors and baseboards which will not change. I am thinking of Maple cabinets because I do not want anymore grain (there is already enough in the floor, baseboard and. window trim). I want to get away from the honey oak colour of the original cabinets and need to keep the kitchen bright. I am attaching photos of the cabinets as they are now. Looking forward to any suggestions...thanks. Please ignore the white cabinet door in the last photo...also bottom drawer is being repaired.

Comments (13)

  • 8 years ago
    Why don’t you just paint the cabinets u til you can do a full renovation. You can’t rip out cabinets but keep a countertop
  • 8 years ago
    While it’s most likely true you can’t replace the cabinets without damaging the counter tops you can replace the doors and drawers with a different style to completely change the look of your kitchen at a fraction of the cost of all new.
  • 8 years ago
    I am working with a cabinet maker who will keep the lower cabinet boxes and convert mostly to drawers. Not having drawers on the bottom is my main complaint about the existing cabinets. The granite and glass tile backsplash is fairly new and we want to keep them...I have extra tile if any of the backsplash gets damaged in removing all of the upper cabinets. The granite will not be damaged as all of the boxes will remain on the bottom.
  • 8 years ago
    What do you think of the maple cabinet colour in this photo....not the style as I want shaker
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    If the cabinets are structurally sound, I would get them refaced which includes a thin veneer that can be matched to new doors and drawer fronts. That’s the best way to reuse the countertop, and a skilled firm can modify to include more drawers. If possible I would add a refrigerator surround to allow the uppers above it to be deeper. With refacing you won’t have to deal with oak grain, you could get maple veneer to match maple doors and drawer fronts. Not sure if you are in their service area, but Kitchen Magic has an excellent blog that includes a lot of info on refacing.
  • 8 years ago

    I would think about painting the cabinets antique white.....it would keep the kitchen bright and would break up all of the wood you have and be very cost effective. I have traditional cabinet doors, but several of those drawer pull outs inside them that are wonderful.

  • 8 years ago
    Thanks for your reply! I appreciate the input. We live in a small town and there is no one nearby to do refacing. I had looked into doing that but I want to work with the local cabinet maker and have new cabinets on top and remade boxes to accommodate drawers on the bottom. The cabinet maker can do this. I agree with changing the cabinet above the fridge and also am thinking of changing the cabinet above the microwave as well. My design dilemma is not what can be done but what material and colour to use.
  • 8 years ago
    Gosh I don’t know if changing from oak to maple will give you the most bang for your buck. I do like the maple color in the photo you posted, but I am wondering if a more contrasting stain will be better if you are trying to get away from the yellow tones? I tend to agree with another comment- that if it were me, I’d paint the cabs until you could do a total remodel. It’s a tough one.
  • 8 years ago

    Keep in mind that maple turns yellow over time. This is not due to the finish yellowing as happens in the use of oil based products, but because it is a natural trait of maple. It also can stain splotchy if not done well - have your cabinet guy show you a sample of a good size piece with stain:

    According to the builder, this is quarter sawn oak:


    Craftsman Kitchen · More Info


    These are cherry:


    Ireland in CT · More Info


    Quarter sawn white oak - seeing a lot of white oak cabinets in newer design pics:


    Quarter Sawn White Oak Kitchen with Island & Desk Area · More Info


  • 8 years ago
    Thanks again for your help! I am trying to get away from Oak although I appreciate that the quarter sawn white oak has a less busy grain, I am looking for something more modern. I found this photo but there is no information on the type of wood. It is more of the look I want but might not be enough of a contrast with backsplash and granite. Does anyone have any idea what the wood is and any comments on the colour?
  • 8 years ago
    I just built my youngest grandson a toy box for Christmas. I used pine and red alder. The middle board is the alder with just a clear coat over it. If you like the color, don’t worry about the knots because I wasn’t using the furniture grade wood your cabinet builder would use. If you want to go with more of a brown tone you might want to go with birch and pick a stain color you like. Be sure to test the stain on whatever type of wood you choose because different woods take stain differently. Also be aware that plywood can take stain differently than solid wood even if they are the same variety. Personally I love walnut but around here it’s crazy expensive but might be a good choice where you live.
  • 8 years ago
    Thanks...I’ll check out the Red Alder without knots..
    ....I have looked at walnut and it is beautiful but way too much grain for this kitchen.