Software
Houzz Logo Print
jordansrq

Help!!! How bad is this cabinet install?

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago















I recently purchased a home and I used Lowe’s for my cabinets and installation. How bad is the installation? The cabinets are shenandorah, style: Irvington, maple linen (painted). Should I make Lowes tear out all of the cabinets and order new ones? My problem is that I don’t really have much time because my lease is ending and I have to be into my home by the end of December.


I am seeking honest opinions on what I need to do?


Are the base cabinets installed incorrectly? I thought the screw went through the frame. It appears the installer torqued the screws too much and ended up gluing it back?


The installed bent my water pipe during the install. I verified the measurements prior to ordering. Lowe’s even sent a guy out to measure. I think they installed my cabinets wrong and didn’t follow the design.


The wall cabinets are installed with screws in the bottom of the frame which is visible.


If you open the sink cabinet, it hits my waste basket and pushed it to the side.


The contractor made a lot of holes in my wall.


Do I have unrealistic expectations?

Comments (25)

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    Not acceptable to me. Hack installers. Nice cabinets but they are very poorly done. Make them fix. Plus, holes put in cabinets with some inappropriate tool is mark of hack.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Yes, it's an appalling installation, but not one that would justify ordering new cabinets (for which you would likely need to wait for many weeks). That would just be throwing the baby out with the bathwater. As long as the cabinets are securely mounted to your satisfaction, most of this amateurish work will be covered up once all the doors and counters are installed. The exterior door and drawer gaps are all over the place, but I would assume all the door hinges and drawer glides have adjustment features that would enable one competent guy with a screwdriver to rectify it all in an hour or so.


    None of this work meets my own standards, but what do you expect from "big box store" subcontractors?

  • 8 years ago

    Unacceptable. I would insist they be fixed.

  • 8 years ago

    I would insist they fix but using another contractor. The one who installed does not have the skill or just does not care. Take these pictures and any others directly to the manager of the store not a sales person who has no authority. Sorry about your experience but it can be fixed.

  • 8 years ago

    The installer claims it’s standard to install the screws for the wall cabinets where he did. He claims that way you do not see the screws when you open the cabinet? That’s not true is it?


    I am not very very educated on cabinets and cabinet installation so any help is much needed so I have the proper information to push back against Lowe’s.

  • 8 years ago

    ^^ agree with Flo, take your photos with you, and I would insist on another installer to correct the issues.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    You may want to hire a good local kitchen designer to inspect this, and take pictures, and create a written document outlining the deficiencies. Which are numerous. A customer without industry knowledge base discussing issues with a store manager, who doesn't know what is industry standard either, is not going to get this project moved forward in the most productive manner.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    The cost of that would probably not be on the budget. I would firmly but politely talk to the store manager. If you don’t succeed at that level then you go higher at store district manager level, then possibly pull out the third party expert.
  • 7 years ago

    It's in the budget because HD needs to pay for it. They sent the incompetent installers.

  • 7 years ago

    Unfortunately I’ve talked to the store manager and the installation manager at Lowe’s and they have been no help. The installation manager actually did a site visit and said she didn’t see any issues. She said they realigned the cabinet drawers and doors but I have not been there to look.


    She also stated the wall cabinets are typically installed in the bottom portion as shown in my pics.


    She also states that base cabinets are butted together in that fashion. Said that it since it won’t be seen then it is at an issue.


    She said the water pipe wasn’t an issue.


    She also said making a lot of holes is common in order to find the stud.


    i do not believe this is accurate. Can someone please confirm?









  • 7 years ago

    Jordan, that's just a shame, but were it me, I'd go higher up the chain of command as has already been suggested. However, I suspect this may be as far as you get - realigning the cabinet drawers and doors.


    Many people these days remain unaware the big box stores often hire what I'd call lower level installers. Sad, but true. Some get lucky. Others, like you, not so much.


    This information, from me or anyone else here on GW/Houzz won't get you anywhere other than to know you are correct:

    No, there should not be screws underneath and showing as in the 2nd photo.

    No, it is not ever, ever common to make "a lot" of holes finding studs. They make stud finders. However, those holes in your drywall can be filled in.

    Not sure what you mean by the water pipe got 'bent'. That sounds like damage. If so, did they replace it?


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Oh my gosh. She has no business working in that department. Contact a corporate manager. Such incompetence!

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    very poor quality and so are the cabinets


  • 7 years ago

    Shes wrong on all accounts. Go above her. This is unacceptable on every level!


  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thank you for your post. I have a customer purchased set of factory cabinets coming... my trusted finish carpenters will install. Wish me luck.

    Are the base cabinets installed incorrectly? I thought the screw went through the frame. It appears the installer torqued the screws too much and ended up gluing it back? Glue looks factory applied.

    The installed bent my water pipe during the install. I verified the measurements prior to ordering. Lowe’s even sent a guy out to measure. I think they installed my cabinets wrong and didn’t follow the design. Have them verify design. Did they account for fillers, etc? I'm noticing that the sides of each cabinet box are "inset" from the actual front box dimension. An experienced cabinet maker/designer/installer should have caught this during measure but I find that lots of minor adjustments get made sometimes...

    The wall cabinets are installed with screws in the bottom of the frame which is visible. Typical for factory.... look at the in store display. I know, it sucks.

    If you open the sink cabinet, it hits my waste basket and pushed it to the side. This is their problem to fix. It should work as sold.

    The contractor made a lot of holes in my wall. <<-- unrealistic expectations

    Do I have unrealistic expectations? Yes & no. Doors & drawers should align. Cabinets should work as designed. They should offer (for a price) a finished bottom to the upper cabinets.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Tell her she needs a new job.


    Lots wrong here but all easily fixed which is the sad part as the time spent inspecting they could have just fixed the issues. Poking holes in a walls to find a stud is crazy $10 buys you a stud finder.


    Problem is you don't have the greatest cabinet there and with the bad installation they are racked and all out of alignment. Upper cabinet are made with a back brace to screw through.


    holes in the wall easily patched move on


    Cabinet to cabinet screws just make sure they are holding well and the screws are in an inconspicuous spot


    water stub out no big deal rough cut will be hidden with valve and trim


    upper cabinets need to be taken down and hung properly.


    base cabinets need to all have the same done.


    Probably $5-1k worth of work. Hire someone else and be done. Anybody who works like that is not going to suddenly know how to do it correctly.


    Cut your losses and spend the extra money to have it done correctly. Hopefully they haven done any real damages to the cabinets that cant be touched up.

  • 7 years ago

    Jordansrq, I am sorry you are going through this. You may have to decide if it is worth it to go above this manager and see if they will fix it. I would encourage to try. I like the idea of printing the photos. Print the photos and include them in a written letter to the district manager. And send them to along with a letter to Shenandoah Cabinetry. Reaching out to Shenandoah might help you find someone from their office to help you get these installed properly.


    And this may affect you moving into your space. If you could use a friend's kitchen, or use a bathroom as a makeshift kitchen you could move in while they continue to work on your space. A toaster, coffee maker and crock pot could get you through a few weeks while they correctly install your cabinets. It will be tough to do this but at least you can be there to watch the corrected install.


    Do you have any photos from further back? Do you have a level? You might want to see if they cabinets are level and photograph that too.


    Meanwhile here is a link to Shenandoah...


    Shenandoah Cabinet installation guidelines

    PDF Shenandoah Cabinet Install directions


    Wishing you luck as you tackle this challenging kitchen dilema.

  • 7 years ago

    Many problems. The least of which is bad communication. The installer did not do a proffessional job. It is easy to know if the placement of the cabinets is correct with all needed spacers and trim by looking at the detailed design used to order the cabinets that you should have approved. The actual instalation is not proffessional. Get and look at the instllation guide from Shenandoah. And ask for a representative from them for a site visit. They are proud of their cabinets and want them installed properly and you happy. A good 90% is a sloppy install. Do it right the first time. So what if the kitchen isn't ready when you move in? Coffee maker and microwave til it is right. Take the long view, not the hurry up view. Lowe's stands behind their sales, it is corporate policy so dont give up. But do be reasonable.

  • 7 years ago

    Definitely go above this department head clown. We have had a few small issues with big box stores-nothing as troubling as your kitchen. It is very variable as with what installers they use, and who is in charge. At a minimum they should be trying to please you and resolve the problems. Maybe they did fix a lot of it and you have not seen it yet-but if not, keep escalating. Also did you pay by credit card? That is always the last resort, but if you did not get what you paid for, dispute the charge. That gets people's attention.

  • 7 years ago

    I would like to thank everyone for educating me about cabinetry. The feedback and instructional guides were very insightful and helped me support my stance.


    I presented my pictures, a marked up asbuilt I sketched out and a list of my complaints to to the store manager. His response was that’s “piss poor” so I believe I am on the right track. He was particularly concerned with the way the wall cabinets were mounted and the way the base cabinets were butted together causing damage to the frames. The installation company and that particular installer apparently does the majority of the cabinet installs in my area. What a very scary thought.


    The installer did correct a lot of things today and covered up where he placed the screws in the bottom of the frames. The cabinets look a lot better now and without but there are still a bunch of issues such as not installing per plan (there are three cabinets in wrong spots, the wrong cabinet on the wrong end and not installing the fillers as noted on the design document.


    However I received more bad news today when I measured the opening for the fridge and the height is only 71 3/4 inches to bottom of cabinet (floor isn’t finished either). The fridge I ordered is 71 -7/8 inch with hinges. It’s a counter depth fridge and it has the built end cabinet look so I don’t think it will work.


    The top of the wall cabinets are over an 1-1/4 inch lower than the design. I’m not sure how he even got the crown to work. I provided the specs for the fridge to Lowe’s when we worked on the design. The designer said oh no problem you have over an 1 -1/4 to 1-1/2 inch in additional space. You will be fine. I asked multiple times because the margin of error seemed low to me regardless. He obviously didn’t account for a lazy installer.


    Thanks to all,

    Jordan



  • 7 years ago
    Unfortunately, at the big box sub level, making a lot of holes to find a stud is common...not the correct way and should not be necessary. I admit to using that method on occasion but I prefer to hide the holes behind the item as I certainly don't want to advertise my lack of preparation or ability to find the stud.

    It is sloppy work and unfinished but that level of workmanship may meet the expectations of the local store management. It is typical to notice how the installation quality sounds great in the sales pitch but those promises are just empty words when the careless guy shows up to do the work.

    If the Lowes management does not see problems, ask them if they would like to display your photos in their portfolio as examples of a typical cabinet install.
  • 7 years ago

    Shoddy, shoddy workmanship. Remain calm, speak in a reasonable tone, "Mr. District Manager, would your wife accept this in her kitchen?" Stand firm and good luck.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    That's poor workmanship. Definitely should be redone.

  • 7 years ago

    Just saw your update were you said "and the floor isn't finished yet". You never ever floor in cabinets if you are using a floor with any height. The cabinets are installed above the height of the floor so that things such as your refrigerator and your dishwasher can slide in and out rather than being in a "hole". That needs to be addressed NOW!

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio