Any thoughts?

Not a match made in heaven, I don't think. I'd be looking for an oval table with those chairs. Something with rounded edges, in any case.

I think it looks fabulous together.

I like it

I like it, too.

I like the choice but you do need a larger rug and move the table out from the window and have the ligh position changed right now there is no way someone can get into those chairs in front of the window I think I would like to see that table top with a much more refined base but thats me.

I like all the geometry of the table,including the base, with the chairs. I would change the rug,

The table should at the very least be oval in shape. The wood is not complementary and as designs go pretty brutal it its details. 86 it.

I don't agree that you MUST have a refined table to use Platner chairs. Warren Platner designed them over 50 years ago and they achieved classic status because they can look fabulous when mixed across styles, even across sensibilities. Same holds true for all iconic chairs,in my opinion. But then,I always prefer a collected over time feeling.

Ok, agree, the oval tables look better :) tried with a few different carpets as was was suggested... Which one do you all like best, please? Thoughts?

I think your original mockup looks the best. The one with the rectangular table and the red rug. That setup looks fab. Imo that version only needs a different light fixture and art.