Software
Houzz Logo Print
ned_b

Wood Refinishing Progress

7 years ago

Just sharing a little progress on our 1924 home renovation/restoration. This afternoon we received the first trial run for our refinished doors. As you see in the before below, all of the doors in our house had first been painted a cranberry color. For that matter all of the woodwork in the home had been painted except the stair handrail and front door, but scraping in several places revealed dark stained finishes under only a few layers of paint. We determined everything must have once been natural finishes, and been that way fairly recently.



What from the initial exposures was thought to be walnut turned out to be birch. Apparently birch was a common wood type for the period and valued for it's ability to be stained pretty much any color. Assuming the wood had darkened considerably over time (and the stripped birch was much darker than virgin wood), we aimed for a color that was similar but lighter than the historic finishes, The grain pattern in the center panel ended up being rather interesting. Here are the final results less reinstalled hardware:



It's hard to believe that anyone looked at that and thought that that white would be better. The cost to paint this door was probably $100 at most. Stripping and refinishing it was $600 for the door panel only, and I believe took a professional 8 hours. If we wanted to do the whole house we would be looking at over $60k in refinishing. That's unrealistic for our budget, so we would like to instead do all of the doors and windows and select a couple public rooms to do all of the trim. And like everything else with this project we will spread the work out over several years.


More than anything I wanted to post this to get this point across: for everyone that says to go ahead and paint your woodwork; do what makes you happy at that moment and it can always be reversed -- that reversing it will either be expensive far beyond the cost of painting or require hours of drudgework. It's not a decision to make lightly especially with historic and special woodwork.

Comments (15)

  • 7 years ago

    Absolutley beautiful. Who in their right mind would paint over that?!

  • 7 years ago

    Wonderful grain!

  • 7 years ago
    I think that frequently when reading the encouragement to paint beautiful woodwork and cabinets.
  • 7 years ago

    Amen! DON'T PAINT! We are also stripping select pieces....not enough money/time for all.

    Your wood looks amazing!

  • 7 years ago

    Your door is beautiful. What a shame someone painted it.

  • 7 years ago

    Beautiful door, it's a work of art. Thanks for emphasizing the importance of researching before making changes. My old home is from a period when woodwork was either painted or faux stone painted. Is that floor original too?

  • 7 years ago

    That is a gorgeous door!!!

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks everyone!

    Thanks everyone!


    The floor in the photo is from the last 20 years. It's an alternating absolute black granite and nero marquina marble pattern (our issues with getting it re-polished are the subject of another topic). I'm not sure what it replaced, but since it is in the kitchen, foyer, main floor bath, and breakfast room, likely multiple materials. Elsewhere in the house we have an original red quary tile floor that may have been in some of these spaces.


    Another interesting find, someone did some research for us and pulled up this on our doors:


    Apparently the Paine Lumber Company of Wisconsin was one of the first to produce a veneered engineered flat panel wood door. The center panel is veneered over plywood allowing it to be much thinner than prior door center panels and the styles and rails were done in several layers of locking jointed hardwood for better door stability. They were popular from roughly 1910 into the 1930s. A catalogue from 1923 is here:

    https://archive.org/details/PaineLumberCompanyLtd.

  • 7 years ago

    Gorgeous!

  • 7 years ago

    It looks really lovely and I'm so glad you were able to restore it.

    Have you given any thought to DIYing it? I am not particularly handy but I am finding that wood refinishing is more of a messy craft project than anything else. It doesn't cost a ton (tools needed, heat gun, sander) and while it is time consuming, if you tire of it, you can just stop and pick up later.


    I am stripping, sanding, restaining, and refinishing ours too. What makes me so angry is our woodwork wasn't painted, rather they stripped and re-stained it a sickly blonde color (an original untouched door was left in the attic) ;(


    I totally agree with doing what you can in the space and triaging what you can handle - I am doing our windows first, as a matter of getting them all functioning and preserved. And then I will go from there.

  • 7 years ago

    I agree with kats - I'd try doing it myself.

    I've had good luck with a product called CitriStrip. It is not as nasty to work with as a lot of chemical strippers, and it works REALLY well. I would definitely try it (maybe on a door that you don't see all time), to see if you are willing to do the work and satisfied with the results. If you have several layers of paint, you might have to coat with CitriStrip more than once. The secret to using this product is to apply it more like frosting than paint, cover the entire piece with plastic to keep it wet, and wait 24 hours before starting to scrape off the stripper and old finish.

    After seeing the beauty of this door, I would not be happy until every door in the house looked as good!

  • 7 years ago

    >It's hard to believe that anyone looked at that and thought that that white would be better.

    No it's not. This forum is littered with people who have homes with beautiful woodwork that either they want to paint white, or are being encouraged to paint white.

    I can second the recommendation on Citri-strip. It works pretty well. But don't cover it. I've found it works much better if not covered. It stays wet very well on it's own.

  • 7 years ago

    Sam - I agree it's sad to see originally stained woodwork painted but do remember that styles were cyclical. My home is much older and from a time when woodwork was either painted white or as faux stone. There are a number of historically accurate houses of the same period here to use as examples.

    I do need to strip a large amount of paint to recover the details from many paint layers and want to use something like the "silent paint remover", it's infrared.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The door reveal is amazing- GORGEOUS!!!!